Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

#168: United Lose to Hull City

53:54 recording · EN · 1 speaker

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Hosting solo because co-host Aaron Moniz was away, Kees van Hemmen recaps United losing 2-0 at Hull City in the Premier League opener, with Hull sitting deep in a back three or five and United unable to create width or depth without Ahmad Diallo and Sesco.2:24
  • Both Hull goals came from set pieces: on the first, which he reviewed with frequent guest Jake Fox, United's whole defensive structure collapsed towards the ball before contact and the back post was left unmarked, while the second, just before half-time, he calls an execution and physicality failure with Luke Shaw bullied deep alongside Andre Santos and Masraoui.7:26
  • Answering Reddit user TMG80 on tactics versus personnel, he sets out a three-question framework — what is the tactical approach, is it coherent for the league and opponent, and are the players suited to purpose — and concludes this match was both, while saying it is hard to condemn Carrick with Amad Diallo and Cesco unavailable.13:56
  • On fitness he argues Carrick's selection preferences have made the team less athletic — Mainu for Sesko, Tielemans replacing Casemiro via Andre Santos, Lissandro Martinez locked in at centre-back — creating vulnerability in the press and at set pieces just as the league has gone the other way.38:12
  • He closes by listing the failure modes the match revealed — defensive transition without Carlos Baleba, teams defending deep without Sesko and Diallo, no pressure when trailing, and a set-piece deficit likely to last the season — while still saying he is fairly optimistic and nobody should panic.50:11

Brief overview

United's 2-0 defeat at Hull exposed Carrick's structural, athletic and set-piece weaknesses, but not panic-worthy.

  1. Hull's block exposed United's lack of width and depthWith Hull in a back five and no target man, United were reduced to speculative balls into the box.
  2. Both goals came from set-piece failuresThe first was structural collapse towards the ball, the second individual physical losses at the back post.
  3. Technicality over physicality is the persistent worryCarrick's selections lowered the team's athleticism in the press and at set pieces as the league got more physical.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
How did Manchester United's Premier League opener at Hull City go?

United lost 2-0 away to Hull City, who were making their debut back in the Premier League for the first time in almost a decade. The host calls the result and the performance incredibly disappointing, while noting it fits within the canon of what we have seen under Carrick.

Answered around 2:24
Why couldn't United break down Hull's defence?

Hull set up in a back three that became a back five, which gave extra width when defending and made it easy to step up on wingers receiving in deeper wide areas, in particular Bryan Mbeumo. Unable to stretch them wide or pin them deep, United were limited to speculative balls into the box.

Answered around 4:43
Which key attackers were missing for United against Hull?

Amad Diallo was not available to start and Sesko was only available off the bench, two players the host considers key in fixtures like this. He adds he is not even confident Amad starts if fit, given a pretty clear preference for Mbeumo, though he does think Sesko probably would have started.

Answered around 3:38
What went wrong on Hull's first goal?

Jake Fox's main takeaway was that United fell back into old habits, with players stepping forward towards the ball before it was even kicked. Freeze-framing the set piece shows the entire defensive structure collapsing towards the ball, Hull winning first contact, the back post left unmarked, and an open goal.

Answered around 7:59
Was Hull's second goal a structural failing too?

No. It came from a set piece just before half-time, but the host calls it an execution issue rather than a structural one. Luke Shaw gets bullied and pushed deep, dropping the defensive line, and with Andre Santos and Noussair Mazraoui also not physically robust at the back post, the marks are lost.

Answered around 9:35
How do you judge when tactics are the issue versus the personnel?

First establish what the tactical approach actually is. Then ask whether that approach is coherent given the league context, the team's aspirations and the opponent. If the tactics misunderstand where goals come from, he forgives player failures; if the coach makes a favourable-odds gamble, player quality comes under greater scrutiny.

Answered around 14:56
Has this United squad become less athletic under Carrick?

Yes. Mainoo replacing Sesko was a huge athletic downgrade, Mazraoui over Dorgu and Amad another, and Lisandro Martinez locked in at centre-back with Shaw moved to left back another again. Casemiro was replaced by Andre Santos, and Tielemans is a downgrade on Mainoo, creating vulnerability in the press and at set pieces.

Answered around 35:09
Why is Carrick's win rate so much better than Amorim's?

He believes Amorim had some misfortune and Carrick has had a great deal of fortune, and is almost certain Carrick's win rate comes down substantially. That does not make Amorim the better manager: the underlying numbers can be sliced by open play, set pieces and availability periods until the story changes.

Answered around 28:50
Is Bruno Fernandes the reason United struggle to break down low blocks?

No. The host says Bruno is not the problem at all, and it was not a major problem under Amorim, where he played a more constricted role. Last season Bruno performed at an insanely high level in big matches when put in position to succeed. Against Hull, United lacked the width and depth to get him near the box.

Answered around 45:12
Should United fans be worried about this result?

Mostly no, because he does not expect losing to likely relegation-zone teams to be this season's standard. But the match exposed the failure modes: weakness in defensive transition without Carlos Baleba, difficulty against deep blocks without Sesko and Amad Diallo, no way to pressure opponents when trailing, and a set-piece deficit.

Answered around 49:59
Key Quote

“I think there was a lot of hysteria online about what this result meant.”

— Kees van Hemmen, #168: United Lose to Hull City, at 2:38
Key Quote

“And United sort of fall back into their old patterns.”

— Kees van Hemmen, #168: United Lose to Hull City, at 7:50
Key Quote

“So I don't think it's time to push the panic button.”

— Kees van Hemmen, #168: United Lose to Hull City, at 22:15
Key Quote

“I am going to lend some grace here because it's one match.”

— Kees van Hemmen, #168: United Lose to Hull City, at 33:53
Key Quote

“The 11 that got fielded in this match is not very athletic.”

— Kees van Hemmen, #168: United Lose to Hull City, at 37:49
Key Quote

“I don't think Carrick is dealing with rot.”

— Kees van Hemmen, #168: United Lose to Hull City, at 41:51

Cite this

“#168: United Lose to Hull City.” https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/168-united-lose-to-hull-city/id1638036302. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/168-united-lose-to-hull-city.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?