Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

16th Year Celebration with TWIM Guests

53:15 recording · AUTO · 6 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • On TWIM's 16th-anniversary episode, recorded February 5th, 2026, Vincent Racaniello, Michael Schmidt, Michelle Swanson and Petra Levin host Nancy Bury of Iowa State University and Maggie Sharman of Washington University.0:47
  • Nancy explains the project began in spring 2020, when COVID cancelled the internships of half a dozen of her juniors and faculty were struggling to move science-literacy work online, so she turned TWIM episodes into annotation work and later brought in Becky Seipelt-Thiemann, Gwen Knapp and Amaya Garcia-Costas as co-leaders, aligning everything to Vision and Change and the ASM curriculum guideline13:09
  • Maggie ran it with her spring 2025 microbiology lab class, twelve groups of four who each picked a podcast, wrote consensus annotations tied to ASM fundamental statements, rewrote two figure legends in plain language and drafted questions and learning objectives — though she admits twelve groups was more than she could debrief properly.20:09
  • Nancy reports initial grant-funded assessment data showing statistically significant gains (around p = 0.002) in content knowledge on the Microbiology Concept Inventory and in every subcategory of a validated science reading motivation survey, with the research article about a third written.40:42
  • Roughly 51 fellows were trained to run the process with their students across community colleges, R1s and primarily undergraduate institutions, 99 TWIM episodes are already annotated, and the free open-access e-book is titled Podcast Annotation and Resources in Microbiology.44:53

Brief overview

A COVID-era stopgap became a published TWIM annotation e-book that measurably raises students' science literacy.

  1. A cancelled-internship problem became a national resourceNancy Bury had students with no summer 2020 internship and faculty with no online science-literacy materials, and solved one problem with the other.
  2. Annotation forces students to translate the scienceGroups rewrote figure legends and built their own learning objectives, which Petra called translating the science into English rather than repeating jargon.
  3. The gains are measured, not just feltBoth content knowledge and reading motivation rose with statistical significance around 0.002 on validated instruments across interns and classroom users.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What is the new teaching resource, and who published it?

Iowa State University published an e-book called Podcast Annotation and Resources in Microbiology. Its description says it contains a set of science literacy resources and exercises based on the podcast This Week in Microbiology. It is open access, so anyone can download it free; a link goes in the show notes.

Answered around 12:30
Why was the podcast annotation project started in the first place?

It began with a COVID problem in spring 2020. Around April, half a dozen juniors emailed Nancy that their internships were cancelled, losing high-impact practices like reading primary literature. At the same time faculty struggled to move science literacy online. She decided one problem could solve the other, starting that summer.

Answered around 13:09
Is there evidence that annotating podcasts actually helps students?

There is initial data. One specific aim of the grant was assessing impact. Using the Microbiology Concept Inventory, whose questions are tested and aligned to ASM guidelines, they saw statistically significant increases in content knowledge, around 0.002. A validated, published science reading motivation survey showed significant increases in all subcategories.

Answered around 40:42
How do students actually carry out a podcast annotation assignment?

Groups of four, chosen by the students, work from templates stating what the book wanted. They listen to a whole podcast, individually write down important concepts and techniques, link them to ASM fundamental statements and Vision and Change statements, then meet as a group to debate and narrow everything down.

Answered around 21:41
Why assign a podcast instead of just having students read the paper?

Reading the paper alone misses the modeling of hosts collaborating, which Michelle notes is central to science. When Nancy earlier assigned TWIM episodes and asked what was most interesting, roughly 40% of responses were about the hosts' interaction, not the paper, surprising students that science comes from actual people.

Answered around 29:23
How can a lecture-based professor start using this without a big change?

Start small. Consider just a single figure reading exercise; Nancy has uploaded a few to Canvas as extra credit. The legend students write carries the experimental design and question, so the follow-up questions can be multiple choice. Even with 300 students, ten minutes of class time debriefs it.

Answered around 34:49
How is the e-book organized for an instructor picking it up?

Instructors scan the table of contents, choose a topic such as evolution, and see the TWIM episodes listed. A chapter opens with what students found most interesting, summarizes methods and results, then links to Vision and Change, ASM fundamental statements, learning objectives, techniques with timestamps, multiple choice questions and figure reading exercises.

Answered around 42:20
Which class did Maggie use this in, and why that one?

She chose her spring 2025 micro lab, a somewhat non-traditional fit. The students are primarily seniors and majors who already construct figures, write figure legends and methodologies for lab reports, and most had already been exposed to primary literature in other upper level courses. She was trained alongside them.

Answered around 20:09
Has this been used beyond Iowa State, at other kinds of institutions?

Roughly 51 fellows were trained in how to train their students in annotation, and basically all of them had students take part. Community college faculty used the process in their very first year, and one fellow used it in a senior seminar and with his graduate students.

Answered around 44:53
How many episodes are already annotated, and who did that work?

Ninety-nine episodes of TWIM have already been annotated, so there is rich variety to choose from. Undergraduates did much of it: Michelle recently met Grace Gutman, an undergraduate at the University of Iowa, who worked on annotation and now has a couple of publications on her CV.

Answered around 44:16
Key Quote

“This begins our 16th year of TWIM.”

— Michael Schmidt, 16th Year Celebration with TWIM Guests, at 0:47▶ listen at 0:47
Key Quote

“So a little bit of a jack-of-all-trades, master of none.”

— Nancy Bury, 16th Year Celebration with TWIM Guests, at 4:06▶ listen at 4:06
Key Quote

“I potentially, if I'm going to be frank, bit off a little bit more than I could chew.”

— Maggie Sharman, 16th Year Celebration with TWIM Guests, at 26:28▶ listen at 26:28
Key Quote

“But it was over and over and over again. So they were really surprised that science comes from actual people.”

— Nancy Bury, 16th Year Celebration with TWIM Guests, at 30:30▶ listen at 30:30
Key Quote

“And I argue back, you're not. If the students are developing the ability to critically think, it's golden.”

— Nancy Bury, 16th Year Celebration with TWIM Guests, at 32:58▶ listen at 32:58
Key Quote

“But I think that for me, the big aha moment was watching the just natural discussion start and the confidence build.”

— Maggie Sharman, 16th Year Celebration with TWIM Guests, at 40:00▶ listen at 40:00

Cite this

“16th Year Celebration with TWIM Guests.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twimshow/TWiM350.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/16th-year-celebration-with-twim-guests.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?