Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

1894: Rat in the Drum

58:24 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • In episode 566 of Geschichten aus der Geschichte, Richard opens in 1894 at Clark University in Worcester, Massachusetts, where physiologist C.C. Stewart put a wild rat in a rotating drum to measure how alcohol, food and air pressure changed how far it ran, then swapped it for an albino rat.5:07
  • He argues a rat only becomes a pest once people claim ownership, quoting science journalist Bethany Brookshire and Austrian literature scholar Karin Wozonek, who cites an estimate that rats pollute ten times more food than they eat, while the Karni Mata temple in Rajasthan shows thousands of rats fed and protected instead.7:29
  • In 19th-century New York horse manure and uncollected waste fed the brown wandering rat, Rattus norvegicus, until the city began around 1900 to collect garbage and remove dead horses, pushing the rats into sewers, cellars and walls.14:22
  • Also in 1894 plague broke out in Hong Kong, where Alexandre Yersin isolated the pathogen later named Yersinia pestis; Masanori Ogata in 1897 and Paul-Louis Simond in 1898 showed fleas carry it between rats, and authorities in Bombay and San Francisco began trapping, dissecting and mapping rats, blaming Chinatown after a dead man was found there on 6 March 1900.20:41
  • Back at the drum, the laboratory rat was standardized through Hugo Krampe's documented pairings, Henry Herbert Donaldson at the Wistar Institute from 1906 and Helen Dean King's inbred lines that stood at the 38th generation by 1920, producing what sociologist Michael Lynch calls the analytic rat alongside the naturalistic one.31:50

Brief overview

Rats became pests and lab models only because humans defined ownership, disease and standardized breeding around them.

  1. A pest is made by ownershipThe grain store is insurance for people and a mountain of food for the rat; the boundary between them is human.
  2. Poison alone never clears a cityRat catcher Bobby Corrigan's answer is closed waste, sealed cellars and repaired buildings, because a poisoned rat just makes room for the next.
  3. The lab rat is a manufactured productKnown age, feed and lineage turned the albino rat into a comparable measurement, from Krampe's records to King's 38 generations.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Why is a rat only called a pest once it reaches our stores?

Because someone first has to draw a line between what belongs to him and an animal that can use the same food just as well. Without that line the rat is simply eating. Science journalist Bethany Brookshire puts it as: pests are a problem as old as ownership.

Answered around 8:14
Why is poison alone not enough to get rid of rats?

A rat needs food, water and a place to hide, so open rubbish, broken pipes and damaged buildings supply everything. American rat researcher and pest killer Bobby Corrigan says to close off the waste, seal access to cellars, sewers and pipes, and repair buildings; otherwise a poisoned rat only makes room for the next.

Answered around 17:45
Why are slow blood-clotting poisons used against rats instead of arsenic?

Viennese pest controller Christoph Kosem describes how rats examine new food cautiously and take only a little; if one gets sick and survives, it refuses that bait afterwards. Fast poisons like arsenic or strychnine act so quickly that the other rats see it, so delayed blood-clotting poisons are used instead.

Answered around 18:14
How was it shown that fleas carry the plague between rats?

In 1897 the Japanese bacteriologist Masanori Ogata brought fleas from plague-infected rats together with experimental animals. A year later the French doctor Paul-Louis Simond hung a healthy rat in a small cage above a plague-sick one, separated by a fine grid. The sick rat died, its body cooled, the fleas left it, and the healthy rat fell ill.

Answered around 21:57
What happened in San Francisco's Chinatown on 6 March 1900?

A dead man, later identified as Chick Chin, was found in a cellar; a doctor noticed strongly swollen lymph nodes and sent a sample to the quarantine station on Angel Island, where Joseph J. Kinyun worked. The city locked Chinatown down, while politicians, newspapers and business people claimed there was no plague at all.

Answered around 26:04
Which rat does the Hameln rat-catcher story actually get wrong?

The good swimmer is the brown wandering rat, Rattus norvegicus, and it only comes to Europe in the 18th century. The Grimm brothers write the tale down in 1816, but the Hameln rat motif itself is about 250 years older, so the rat meant is the house rat, Rattus rattus, a bad swimmer.

Answered around 12:46
Where are rats fed and protected rather than hunted?

In the northern Indian state of Rajasthan there is the Karni Mata temple, where thousands of rats live. People feed them, protect them and walk among them, and food is still eaten there after a rat has eaten from it, which shows how much people decide how the same animal is treated.

Answered around 10:09
Why did Stewart put an albino rat into his rotating drum?

The wild rat has properties that are useful in the wild but exhausting in a laboratory: she is fast, she bites and she flees as soon as the opportunity arises, showing little understanding for a physiologist who wants nice measurements. So Stewart changed one more condition, the rat itself.

Answered around 5:49
How did the standardized laboratory rat come about?

In Philadelphia albino rats were bred in large numbers for experiments, led by the neurologist Henry Herbert Donaldson, who moved to the Wistar Institute of Anatomy and Biology in 1906. The rats were kept by fixed rules, weighed, killed and examined, so that age, food and housing were known and curves emerged from many bodies.

Answered around 35:41
How much do the experimenter's expectations change a rat's results?

In a 1963 experiment by the psychologists Robert Rosenthal and Kermit Fode, students received ordinary Sprague-Dawley rats. Half were told their animals were especially good in the maze, half especially bad, although the groups were put together at random. The supposedly clever rats still needed less time, because those students handled them more kindly and encouragingly.

Answered around 42:39
Key Quote

“Pests are a problem as old as ownership.”

— Richard, 1894: Rat in the Drum, at 8:20▶ listen at 8:20
Key Quote

“If that is not done, then it is also useless to poison a rat, because it then simply makes room for the next rat.”

— Richard, 1894: Rat in the Drum, at 18:07▶ listen at 18:07
Key Quote

“Plague fake is part of plot to plunder.”

— Richard, 1894: Rat in the Drum, at 29:23▶ listen at 29:23
Key Quote

“The standardized laboratory rat becomes something like a highly developed factory product.”

— Richard, 1894: Rat in the Drum, at 38:16▶ listen at 38:16

Cite this

“1894: Rat in the Drum.” https://adswizz.podigee-cdn.net/version/1785306440/media/podcast_47771_geschichten_aus_der_geschichte_episode_2552061_gag566_die_doppelte_ratte.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/1894-rat-in-the-drum.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?