Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

A Case of Identity

45:19 recording · AUTO · 4 speakers

Listen to the original

Executive Summary AI
  • Sitting by the fire in his Baker Street lodgings, Sherlock Holmes argues to Watson that life is infinitely stranger than anything the mind of man could invent, and wins the point with the Dundas separation case, where a teetotal husband ended every meal by hurling his false teeth at his wife.
  • Miss Mary Sutherland, a short-sighted typewritist living at 31 Lyon Place, Camberwell, comes to Baker Street with a hundred a year of her own from two thousand five hundred pounds of New Zealand stock paying four and a half percent, and offers all of it to learn what became of Mr. Hosmer Angel.
  • She describes a shy, whispering, tinted-spectacled suitor she met at the gas-fitter's ball while her stepfather Mr. Windebank was in France, who wrote only typewritten letters to the Leadenhall Street post-office and then vanished from a four-wheeler on the way to St. Saviour's church on the Friday of their wedding.
  • The next evening Holmes confronts James Windebank and lays out the chain of events: a man who married a woman much older than himself for her money, who stood to lose a hundred a year if the daughter married, and who therefore disguised himself as Hosmer Angel to keep off other suitors and bind her with vows.
  • Holmes says no law can touch the scoundrel, and after Windebank sneers and runs from the house, he explains the proof: the two men were never together, the whiskers, glasses and voice all hinted at disguise, the typewriter's slurred E's and tailless R's matched both sets of letters, and Westhouse and Marbank confirmed the description fitted their employee James Windebank.

Brief overview

Holmes proves that Mary Sutherland's vanished fiancé Hosmer Angel was her stepfather in disguise.

  1. The stepfather invented the fiancé to keep the incomeMary's marriage would have cost the household the hundred a year she handed over while living at home.
  2. A typewriter is as individual as handwritingSlurred E's, a tailless R and fourteen other defects tied Windebank's note to Hosmer Angel's four letters.
  3. Small details decide the case, not impressionsSleeve marks, the dint of a pince-nez, odd half-buttoned boots and violet ink on a torn glove told Holmes everything before she spoke.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Who was Hosmer Angel really?

Holmes says the stepfather, James Windebank, disguised himself with the connivance and assistance of his wife: tinted glasses over his keen grey eyes, a moustache and bushy whiskers masking the face, his clear voice sunk into an insinuating whisper. Made doubly secure by the girl's short sight, he appeared as Mr. Hosmer Angel and kept off other lovers by making love himself.

Why did the stepfather invent a suitor for his stepdaughter?

Holmes explains that the man married a woman much older than himself for her money and enjoyed the use of the daughter's money while she lived with them. It was a considerable sum for people in their position, and her marriage would mean the loss of a hundred a year, so it was worth an effort to preserve it.

How did Hosmer Angel vanish on the wedding morning?

He came for them in a hansom, put mother and daughter into it and stepped himself into a four-wheeler, the only other cab in the street. They reached St. Saviour's first; when the four-wheeler drove up and the cabman got down, there was no one inside, though he had seen him get in with his own eyes.

What gave the typewritten letters away?

Holmes remarks that a typewriter has quite as much individuality as a man's handwriting, and no two write exactly alike. In Windebank's own note every E was slurred and the tail of the R defective, with fourteen other characteristics; the four letters from the missing man, signature included, showed all of them too.

How did Holmes verify that Windebank was Hosmer Angel?

Having spotted his man, corroboration was easy. He knew the firm the man worked for, took the printed description and eliminated everything that could be the result of disguise — the whiskers, the glasses, the voice — and sent it on. Westhouse and Marbank of Fenchurch Street replied that it tallied in every respect with their employee James Windebank.

Could Windebank be punished for what he did?

Holmes says there was never any mystery, and the only drawback is that no law can touch the scoundrel. Windebank stammers that it is not actionable, then warns Holmes that keeping the door locked lays him open to an action for assault and illegal constraint. Holmes reaches for a hunting-crop and the man runs down the road.

How did Holmes know his visitor was a typist with short sight?

Her sleeves were plush, a most useful material for showing traces, and the double line a little above the wrist, where the typewritist presses against the table, was beautifully defined; a hand sewing machine marks only the left arm. Seeing the dint of a pince-nez at either side of her nose, he added short sight.

How did Holmes know she had rushed out of the house?

Though the boots she wore were not unlike each other, they were really odd ones, the one having a slightly decorated toe-cap, and they were only half-buttoned, at the first, third and fifth. Holmes says it is no great deduction that a young lady otherwise neatly dressed, in odd boots, came away in a hurry.

What money did Mary Sutherland have of her own?

Her income is quite separate from her father's plumbing business and was left her by her Uncle Ned in Auckland: two thousand five hundred pounds in New Zealand stock paying four and a half percent, a hundred a year, of which she can only touch the interest. Mr. Windebank draws it every quarter and pays it over to her mother.

Why does Holmes refuse to tell Miss Sutherland the truth?

Because, he says, if he tells her she will not believe him. He recalls the old Persian saying that there is danger for him who taketh the tiger-cub, and danger also for whoso snatches a delusion from a woman, adding that there is as much sense in Hafiz as knowledge of the world.

Key Quote

“Life is infinitely stranger than anything which the mind of man could invent.”

— Sherlock Holmes, A Case of Identity, at 0:50▶ listen at 0:50
Key Quote

“Depend upon it. There is nothing so unnatural as the commonplace.”

— Sherlock Holmes, A Case of Identity, at 2:12▶ listen at 2:12
Key Quote

“I would give it all to know what has become of Mr. Hosmer Angel.”

— Miss Mary Sutherland, A Case of Identity, at 8:46▶ listen at 8:46
Key Quote

“It has long been an axiom of mine that the little things are infinitely the most important.”

— Sherlock Holmes, A Case of Identity, at 16:06▶ listen at 16:06
Key Quote

“I can never bring you to realize the importance of sleeves, the suggestiveness of thumbnails, or the great issues that may hang from a boot-lace.”

— Sherlock Holmes, A Case of Identity, at 24:06▶ listen at 24:06
Key Quote

“Never trust to general impressions, my boy, but concentrate yourself upon details.”

— Sherlock Holmes, A Case of Identity, at 25:17▶ listen at 25:17

Cite this

“A Case of Identity.” https://www.archive.org/download/adventures_holmes/adventureholmes_03_doyle_64kb.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/a-case-of-identity.html.

Transcript

0:00 THE ADVENTURES OF SHERLOCK HOMES Ontario, October, 2006.
0:31 The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle Adventure No. 3 A Case of Identity
0:36 My dear fellow, said Sherlock Holmes, as we sat on either side of the fire in his lodgings at Baker
0:44 Street, life is infinitely stranger than anything which the mind of man could invent. as we sat on either side of the fire in his lodgings at Baker Street.
0:50 Life is infinitely stranger than anything which the mind of man could invent.
0:55 We would not dare to conceive the things which are really mere commonplaces of existence.
0:59 If we could fly out of that window hand in hand,
1:03 hover over this great city, gently remove the roofs,
1:07 and peep in at the queer things which are going on, the strange coincidences, the plannings, the cross-purposes, the wonderful chains of events
1:14 working through generations, and leading to the most ultra results, it would make all fiction,
1:21 with its conventionalities and foreseen conclusions, most stale and unprofitable.
1:29 And yet I am not convinced of it, I answered. The cases which come to light in the papers are,
1:36 as a rule, bald enough, and vulgar enough. We have in our police reports realism pushed to its extreme limits, and yet the result is,
1:48 it must be confessed, neither fascinating nor artistic.
1:53 A certain selection and discretion must be used in producing a realistic effect,
1:59 remarked Holmes. This is wanting in the police report, where more stress is laid, perhaps, upon the platitudes of
2:06 the magistrate than upon the details, which to an observer contain the vital essence of the whole
2:12 matter. Depend upon it. There is nothing so unnatural as the commonplace. I smiled and shook
2:20 my head. I can quite understand your thinking so, I said. Of course, in your position
2:28 of unofficial advisor and helper to everybody who is absolutely puzzled, throughout three continents
2:35 you are brought in contact with all that is strange and bizarre. But here, I picked up the
2:42 morning paper from the ground. Let us put it to a practical test.
2:47 Here is the first heading upon which I come.
2:50 A Husband's Cruelty to His Wife
2:53 There is half a column of print, but I know, without reading it, that it is all perfectly
2:59 familiar to me. There is, of course, the other woman, the drink, the push, the blow, the bruise,
3:06 "'the sympathetic sister or landlady.
3:09 "'The crudest of writers could invent nothing more crude.'
3:14 "'Indeed, your example is an unfortunate one for your argument,' said Holmes,
3:19 "'taking the paper and glancing his eye down it.
3:22 "'This is the Dundas separation case, and, as it happens, I was
3:27 engaged in clearing up some small points in connection with it. The husband was a teetotaler,
3:33 and there was no other woman, and the conduct complained of was that he had drifted into the
3:39 habit of winding up every meal by taking out his false teeth and hurling them at his wife which you will allow is not an action likely to occur to the imagination of the average story-teller
3:52 take a pinch of snuff doctor and acknowledge that i have scored over you in your example he held out his snuff-box of old gold with a great amethyst in the centre of the lid. Its splendour was in such
4:07 contrast to his homely ways and simple life that I could not help commenting upon it.
4:13 "'Ah,' said he, "'I forgot that I had not seen you for some weeks. It is a little souvenir from
4:19 the King of Bohemia, in return for my assistance in the case of the Irene Adler papers.
4:26 "'And the ring?' I asked, glancing at a remarkable brilliant which sparkled upon his finger.
4:32 "'It was from the reigning family of Holland, though the matter in which I served them was

Showing the first 40 of 393 lines.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?