Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

A Small Difference

37:55 recording · EN · 1 speaker

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • The episode opens by reading the introduction to Raymond Plank's memoir A Small Difference, written in his 90th year, in which he says the purpose is to open the window of his life so readers can reach a fuller measure of their own capacities.0:00
  • Plank traces his values to two cornerstones: his father telling him at about age 10 to try to make a very small difference on behalf of others, and a postcard his mother wrote days before dying of a blood clot at 47, when Plank was 15.0:54
  • After selling eggs, firewood and syrup as a boy and flying 40 bomber missions in his early 20s, Plank chose self-employment over a large company and founded Apache Corporation with $250,000 in 1954, a stake worth $50 billion by mid-2008.2:34
  • Apache's first real product was a tax-efficient drilling vehicle: on a $200,000 investment the investor deducted 80%, or $160,000, against tax brackets above 90%, so the out-of-pocket cost was roughly $56,000, and 27.5% of later royalty income was excluded through the depletion allowance.18:09
  • Plank later assembled a mini-conglomerate of 58 businesses, then reversed course in the 1970s back to a focused oil and gas company, and in 2011 saw land bought between 1970 and 1977 revalued by drilling techniques other people invented.28:49

Brief overview

Raymond Plank built Apache from $250,000 to $50 billion by taking risk others avoided.

  1. Risk chosen on purpose, not by accidentHe refused the large company, wanted a smaller, riskier initiative, and Apache's first company history was titled Journey into Risk Country.
  2. An edge nobody else in the industry hadHis technical oil knowledge was virtually non-existent, but his financial and tax knowledge had few competitive peers, and that gap was the opening.
  3. Never emotionally attached to a prior decisionHe built a 58-business conglomerate, then sold virtually everything to return Apache to a focused energy company when oil improved.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
How did Apache Corporation start, and how large did it become?

Apache Corporation had a very modest beginning, founded with just $250,000 in 1954. By mid-2008 that $250,000 had become $50 billion. Plank deliberately chose self-employment over a large company, saying he wanted a smaller, riskier initiative rather than the security of working for someone else's firm.

Answered around 2:34
Why did wealthy investors put money into Apache's drilling programs?

Suppose an investor puts $200,000 into an Apache drilling program. He gets an immediate deduction of 80%, or $160,000; in a bracket above 90% that is worth about $144,000, so the $200,000 check really cost roughly $56,000 out of pocket, with upside if oil was found.

Answered around 18:09
What was the depletion allowance and what did it do for oil income?

Oil royalties carried a depletion allowance. Congress let owners of producing properties treat part of the income as a return of the oil being depleted underground, so 27.5% could be excluded. On $200,000 of production, $55,000 was tax-free and only the remaining $145,000 was taxed.

Answered around 19:00
What edge did Raymond Plank actually have when he founded Apache?

When Apache was founded his knowledge of the technical aspects of oil and gas was virtually non-existent, while his financial and tax-related knowledge may have had few competitive peers. He then hired the domain people, made them his companions on field visits, and learned by osmosis and interest.

Answered around 20:05
Why would major oil companies sell producing wells to Apache?

The major integrated companies sold as they sought cost reduction and cash redeployment in their quest for larger reserves; once fields are developed they turn to new virgin opportunities worldwide and limit exploration spending as fields deplete. Plank said Apache was like pigs following cows through a cornfield.

Answered around 35:40
Why did Apache turn itself into a conglomerate, then reverse course?

In the late 1950s Oklahoma and Texas oil allowables were cut by up to 90%, and so were Apache's revenues. The offensive strategy was to acquire entrepreneurial businesses in exchange for stock; they ended up owning 58 of them, in agriculture, plastics, telephones, steel, auto parts, ranching, utilities and lumber.

Answered around 26:15
What went wrong between Plank and his co-founder?

A schism widened between Truman Anderson and Plank; arguments grew so loud that staff cowered as they threw a wastebasket or smashed an ashtray. Plank's horizons were long-term, Truman wanted personal fortune and fame. Seeking to rid Apache of Plank, Truman bugged the offices, board and conference rooms.

Answered around 20:58
What did Plank's father tell him that shaped his values?

At perhaps the age of 10, on a walk, his dad dropped his hand, put an arm around his shoulder and said: son, over my life I've found it very useful to try to make a very small difference on behalf of others. They never discussed the topic again.

Answered around 0:54
How did Plank's mother die, and how old was he?

She died at 47 of a blood clot to the brain following a routine appendectomy, only hours before he was to drive his father to the hospital to bring her home. He was 15. Northwestern Hospital called at 3 a.m.; he could not write in his diary for six months.

Answered around 2:02
Did Plank regret how he balanced work and family?

He says one trade-off in his pursuits was his family, who needed and warranted more of his time, love, attention and support, and that he short-changed a fine wife and mother. Yet he is not the type ruefully to reminisce: for life is to live, learn and grow.

Answered around 33:11
Key Quote

“son, over my life, I've found it very useful to try to make a very small difference on behalf of others.”

— A Small Difference, at 0:59▶ listen at 0:59
Key Quote

“without courage, all virtue is fragile.”

— A Small Difference, at 10:54▶ listen at 10:54
Key Quote

“We did not feel qualified. We proceeded nonetheless.”

— A Small Difference, at 15:21▶ listen at 15:21
Key Quote

“My time horizons for Apache were long-term. Truman was impatient in his personal drive to become a high roller.”

— A Small Difference, at 21:16▶ listen at 21:16
Key Quote

“Ego can quickly outstrip one's competence and fat heads get flattened.”

— A Small Difference, at 22:07▶ listen at 22:07
Key Quote

“One who thinks solely of self is soon forgotten. Those who care about others live on.”

— A Small Difference, at 33:54▶ listen at 33:54

Cite this

“A Small Difference.” https://dcs-spotify.megaphone.fm/DSLLC1260176282.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/a-small-difference.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?