Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Abandoned Car in Adirondacks

42:42 recording · EN · 1 speaker

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • In July 1973 Pat Cadell reported that his Harvard classmate and business partner Danny Porter, 23, and Danny's girlfriend Susan Petz, 21, never returned from a camping weekend in the Adirondacks, and Danny's leased 1972 BMW was found abandoned off State Route 8 in Weavertown, New York.2:01
  • On Friday morning Danny's own friends, not the police, found his body about 25 feet from the road; he had died of fatal hemorrhaging and shock from four stab wounds to the chest on Saturday, July 14th, while Sue had vanished.7:10
  • On Sunday, July 29th, near Speculator, a middle-aged man in a fedora with a rifle tied four campers to trees and stabbed 18-year-old Phil Domblewski to death, and Dave Freeman, Carol Malinowski and Nick Fiorello escaped to raise the alarm.14:02
  • An abandoned car at a roadblock identified the gunman as 37-year-old Robert Garrow Sr. of Syracuse, a man with convictions for attempted robbery, burglary, grand larceny and sex crimes, who was caught on August 9th after being shot by a Department of Environmental Conservation officer.21:04
  • Garrow confessed to his attorneys Frank Armani and his co-counsel that he had killed Danny Porter, Phil Domblewski, Sue Petz and 16-year-old Alicia Hauck, and the lawyers found and photographed Sue's body in a Mineville mine shaft but said nothing, a silence that surfaced at his 1974 trial, where jurors convicted him of Phil's murder and he was sentenced to 25 years to life.31:12

Brief overview

Robert Garrow Sr. killed four young people in 1973, and his lawyers kept the bodies secret.

  1. Early reports were dismissed as not urgentA trooper told Pat Cadell to wait before calling back, and troopers who found the locked BMW assumed the owner would return for it.
  2. Attorney-client privilege hid two victims' bodiesArmani and his co-counsel located Sue Petz and Alicia Hauck's remains but could not report them without Robert's consent, and stayed silent into 1974.
  3. Local knowledge kept the manhunt running for daysGarrow grew up in Mineville, moved at night and broke into vacant properties, stretching the largest and most costly manhunt in New York State history to 11 days.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
How did Danny Porter die, and when was he killed?

Danny Porter, 23, died of fatal hemorrhaging and shock from four stab wounds to his chest. Based on his body and clothing, he was killed on Saturday, July 14th, 1973, six days before his friends found him resting against a tree about 25 feet from the road where his BMW was abandoned.

Answered around 8:29
What happened to the four friends camping near Speculator in July 1973?

On July 29th, a gunman in a fedora marched Dave Freeman, Carol Malinowski, Nick Fiorello and Phil Domblewski into the woods and made them tie each other to trees about 40 feet apart. He then stabbed 18-year-old Phil in the chest several times; Phil bled to death from wounds to a lung.

Answered around 16:14
How did the surviving campers escape and get help?

Dave, Nick and Carol freed themselves. Nick drove to Wells, climbed a restaurant roof and shouted for help. Dave pretended to help the gunman track Nick, buying time. Carol slipped her bindings, found Phil dead, and flagged down a passing car that took her to Speculator to alert police.

Answered around 17:05
How did police identify Robert Garrow as the suspect?

After a chase from a roadblock near State Route 8, the gunman abandoned his car in the woods. It belonged to Robert Garrow Sr., a 37-year-old from Syracuse with a criminal history dating to the late 1950s. His license photo matched the composite sketch, and the survivors confirmed he was their kidnapper.

Answered around 20:59
What was Robert Garrow's criminal record before the 1973 murders?

In 1961 he was convicted of sexually assaulting a teenage girl and battering her boyfriend, sentenced to 20 years but served seven. He confessed to kidnapping and assaulting two young girls but was never prosecuted. He also had convictions for attempted robbery, burglary and grand larceny, plus 1972 and 1973 arrests.

Answered around 23:02
How long did the manhunt last and how was Garrow caught?

Called the largest and costliest manhunt in New York State history at the time, it ended on August 9th, about 11 days after he fled. A Department of Environmental Conservation officer spotted him in the woods and shot him, badly injuring his left arm. He spent 41 days hospitalized under guard.

Answered around 27:02
Where were Sue Petz's and Alicia Hauck's bodies found?

Garrow drew his lawyers a map. Sue Petz was in a mine shaft vent hole at the foot of a mountain in Mineville, his hometown, preserved by cold air. Sixteen-year-old Alicia Hauck lay in brush behind a maintenance shed at a Syracuse park and cemetery; she had been sexually assaulted and strangled.

Answered around 31:44
Why didn't Garrow's attorneys tell police where the bodies were?

Frank Armani and his co-counsel were bound by attorney-client privilege and their duty to keep their client's secrets. Garrow had not given explicit permission to share his confession, and reporting or leaking the locations could make a conviction difficult and possibly violate his constitutional rights. They stayed silent for months.

Answered around 32:18
What was the verdict in Garrow's trial for Phil Domblewski's murder?

The trial was held in Hamilton County in late spring 1974, with an insanity defense. Garrow testified for two and a half days and admitted other killings. Jurors deliberated only a few hours, found him guilty and he got 25 years to life. In March 1975 he pleaded guilty to the other murders.

Answered around 38:27
How did Robert Garrow die?

In early September 1978 he escaped a minimum security prison after a fellow inmate's wife supplied a gun that his son smuggled in. He had used a wheelchair for years, apparently faking an injury. Authorities caught him a few days later; in a gunfight he was shot several times and died at the scene.

Answered around 39:19
Key Quote

“That term, Forever Wild, could also be an appropriate name for the aspects of the human predator in today's episode.”

— Delia D'Ambra, Abandoned Car in Adirondacks, at 0:47▶ listen at 0:47
Key Quote

“In other words, where Danny's car had been found was conveniently out of sight of others.”

— Delia D'Ambra, Abandoned Car in Adirondacks, at 6:31▶ listen at 6:31
Key Quote

“don't try anything or I'll blow a hole in you. I've killed before and I'll kill again”

— Delia D'Ambra, Abandoned Car in Adirondacks, at 16:01▶ listen at 16:01
Key Quote

“But they didn't say a thing.”

— Delia D'Ambra, Abandoned Car in Adirondacks, at 33:35▶ listen at 33:35
Key Quote

“the Department of Corrections should give Garrow the Actor of the Year award. You know he was a great actor.”

— Frank Armani, Abandoned Car in Adirondacks, at 39:47▶ listen at 39:47
Key Quote

“The Syracuse University students he terrorized. None of those people should be forgotten.”

— Delia D'Ambra, Abandoned Car in Adirondacks, at 41:44▶ listen at 41:44

Cite this

“Abandoned Car in Adirondacks.” https://rsv.simplecastaudio.com/47d1cb4c-1747-47f1-9ed0-4043dcc16a09/episodes/29a09e79-9aaa-482b-8cdd-170c183c4f2c/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_c9e6a27367e9964c69dc1f2b913fa393_40989292.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/abandoned-car-in-adirondacks.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?