Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Agustín Fuentes — This Species Moment

51:06 recording · AUTO · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Anthropologist Agustin Fuentes tells Krista Tippett that 2020 is a multi-species moment, because humans navigate it in partnership with another species, the virus SARS-CoV-2, inside a world humans largely made.5:20
  • He lays out the human niche: our niche is social through and through, the resting default state of the brain is the social one, and a fish is born expecting water while a human is born expecting culture, which is why pandemic distancing damages bodies and minds, not just moods.10:24
  • He rejects the competition-versus-cooperation binary as a false dichotomy, arguing that for humans the best cooperators make the best competitors, and that on average those who spent all their time hitting people over the head did not do very well.20:21
  • Applying that to economics, he and Tippett discuss his line that we willingly accept losses as often as gains in exchanges, because for most humans exchanges are about making and keeping social connections rather than profit, which undercuts the rational-actor basis of modern economic theory.26:32
  • He closes on wisdom as the capacity to take knowledge and experience and do something with it, ties it to hope and to the elders COVID-19 is harming, and proposes love economics aimed at reducing inequity and suffering rather than maximising financial benefit.40:38

Brief overview

Fuentes argues humans are deeply social, cooperative ecosystems, and that rethinking evolution could reshape economies, trust and care.

  1. The human niche is social through and throughFuentes says humans are never really alone: even at rest the brain's default state is the social one, and our bodies, hormones and guts are tied to being with others.
  2. Cooperation and competition are not oppositesHe calls the split a false dichotomy and says that for humans the best cooperators make the best competitors, with the data from primates and human evolution behind it.
  3. Trust is predictability, reliability and compassionRather than convincing people to have faith in you, trust is demonstrated behaviour, and he points to political debate in New Zealand as one imperfect attempt at it.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What is the human niche?

A niche describes how an organism makes a living in the world and its relationship to that world. The human niche is social through and through. Humans are never really alone: even sitting by ourselves our thoughts are filled with others, and the brain's resting default state is the same one that turns on for social interaction.

Answered around 10:27
What does it mean that our bodies are ecosystems?

Scholars call it the holobiont: organisms are cells made of our own DNA and proteins plus thousands, tens of thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands of other organisms and their DNA simultaneously. These holobionts move around shedding, sharing, overlapping, fusing. Suck out everything clearly human and a strong outline of the body remains.

Answered around 8:04
Is evolution really survival of the fittest?

No. Evolution is not about bigger, badder or more beautiful winning the day, does not stop at a perfect solution and is not goal directed. Read Darwin and Wallace and it was never about the biggest teeth or fastest runners, never just winners and losers. It is small tweaks, moves and shifts, mostly structurally boring.

Answered around 14:49
Are competition and cooperation opposites?

That binary is a false dichotomy; the two are not in opposition. For humans, the best cooperators make the best competitors. Collaboration and cooperation are central to social mammals, extremely important for primates and most important for humans. We did hit each other over the head, but those who spent all their time doing it did not do well.

Answered around 20:13
Why is missing hugs a physical problem, not just an emotional one?

Fuentes's great fear is that people ignore the psychophysiological, more precisely neuroendocrinological, effects: the hormone physiology and brain impacts of distancing. Our bodies and minds are damaged by not being around and not touching other people, so even though distancing matters for overall health, we must find some way to keep social.

Answered around 12:05
What would evolutionary biology add to medical training?

Most of medicine is built on a failure model: something is broken, go in and fix it. An evolutionary focus asks first what the patterns, processes and range of variation in a system are, and how systems can be modified to function well together. He is not knocking medical technology, but doctors' assumptions about bodies and lives.

Answered around 16:21
How do we rebuild trust in society?

Trust is not convincing people to put their faith in you. It is demonstrating predictability, reliability and compassion, and we know how to do that. If politicians and our social and community structures put those forward instead of economic interests, we would be in a different place. He points to New Zealand's political debates as one imperfect attempt.

Answered around 32:23
How does an anthropologist define love?

Discard the watered down, overused Hallmark card version. Love is a deep, whole investment in another or others, in ideas, in commitments: taking the human capacity for bonding and attachment and applying it wholly and forcefully. Romantic, familial and other forms follow, and love lies centrally in the work of activists who gave their lives for change.

Answered around 43:37
What is wisdom, and how is it connected to hope?

Wisdom is the capacity to take knowledge and experience and do something with it, something that offers the opportunity for change. Fuentes connects it to hope: that deep perspective gives humans the ability to imagine possible futures that are better despite what is materially going on around them, and to strive for them.

Answered around 40:38
What can I do day to day to counter the narrative of disarray?

Acknowledge the times you receive a nod, a smile, an act of compassion, and when you give them, congratulate yourself or revel in it a little. We usually blow these off. Being involved matters too, because then you feel connected, and if you can, spend quiet time alone relaxing. It affects your health and how you see the world.

Answered around 37:41
Key Quote

“The psychologist Michael Tomasello says this great phrase, fish is born expecting water, a human is born expecting culture.”

— Agustin Fuentes, Agustín Fuentes — This Species Moment, at 11:26
Key Quote

“our bodies and our minds are being damaged by not being around other people, not touching other people.”

— Agustin Fuentes, Agustín Fuentes — This Species Moment, at 12:29
Key Quote

“It's just on average, those who spent all their time hitting people over the head didn't do very well.”

— Agustin Fuentes, Agustín Fuentes — This Species Moment, at 21:20
Key Quote

“It's demonstrating predictability, reliability, and compassion. And we know how to do that.”

— Agustin Fuentes, Agustín Fuentes — This Species Moment, at 32:30

Cite this

“Agustín Fuentes — This Species Moment.” https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/agust%C3%ADn-fuentes-this-species-moment/id150892556. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/agustin-fuentes-this-species-moment.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?