Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

AIPAC's Political Shift

39:30 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Host Rachel Abrams opens by noting that AIPAC has spent a record amount in this year's midterms, mostly in Democratic primaries, to oust or support candidates based on a changing definition of what it means to support Israel.0:11
  • Jonathan Mahler says the 2015 Iran nuclear deal was the first rupture: Netanyahu addressed Congress against Obama's deal, America's and Israel's interests diverged, and AIPAC chose Israel.7:50
  • After the squad's election in 2018 and Jamal Bowman and Cori Bush in 2020, AIPAC abandoned small member donations and created its own super PAC, the United Democracy Project, before the 2022 midterms.13:30
  • In the 2024 cycle it spent $120 million and defeated both Cori Bush and Jamal Bowman, after having endorsed more than 100 candidates in 2022 who backed Trump's effort to overturn the 2020 election.19:35
  • In 2026 AIPAC is targeting moderates — Tom Malinowski in New Jersey (over $2.3 million, and the seat went to a candidate further left) and Daniel Biss in Illinois, who campaigned against AIPAC and won — and is now spending close to $30 million in Michigan for Haley Stevens against Abdul El-Sayed.32:59

Brief overview

AIPAC's own choices turned support for Israel into a litmus test now splitting Democrats.

  1. AIPAC became a proxy for Israel itselfMahler says debating AIPAC is now how Americans debate U.S. support for Israel, and also how they debate big money in politics.
  2. 2015 forced a choice AIPAC never had to makeWhen Obama's Iran deal split American and Israeli interests, AIPAC lined up with Israel against the president.
  3. Targeting moderates is backfiringMalinowski's seat went to a candidate further left on Israel, and Daniel Biss won by running as the anti-AIPAC candidate.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
How much is AIPAC spending in Michigan's Democratic Senate primary?

Approaching $30 million, more than AIPAC has ever spent on a single race. It backs Haley Stevens, a moderate, blue-collar, pro-manufacturing Democrat who embraces AIPAC though she is not Jewish, against Abdul El-Sayed, son of Egyptian immigrants, far to the left, who calls Gaza a genocide and opposes U.S. aid.

Answered around 32:54
What is AIPAC's litmus test for being pro-Israel?

AIPAC has created a basic litmus test: if you question unconditional American military support for Israel, you are not pro-Israel enough. That standard now catches moderate Democrats who consider themselves supporters of Israel, which is why AIPAC has targeted them in 2026 and become even more polarizing.

Answered around 25:49
What happened when AIPAC targeted Tom Malinowski in New Jersey?

AIPAC's super PAC spent over $2.3 million to defeat him, with ads not about Israel but about COVID-related stock trading and ICE funding. Malinowski, who had a perfect pro-Israel voting record and refused to call Gaza genocide, lost, but so did AIPAC's candidate: a progressive further left on Israel won.

Answered around 27:21
How did Daniel Biss turn AIPAC's opposition into a campaign strategy?

Biss polled his Illinois district and found 51% viewed AIPAC unfavorably against only 17% favorably. Armed with that, he campaigned as the anti-AIPAC candidate, leaning into his Jewish identity and his grandparents who survived the Holocaust, and he won the Democratic primary in the 9th District.

Answered around 31:10
How much did AIPAC spend in 2024, and what did it win?

AIPAC spent $120 million in the 2024 election cycle, a staggering amount, and racked up two big wins by defeating Cori Bush and Jamal Bowman, both members of the squad. Both called out AIPAC explicitly in their concession speeches, one saying, AIPAC, I'm coming to tear your kingdom down.

Answered around 19:43
Why did AIPAC create its own super PAC?

Before the 2022 midterms AIPAC created a super PAC called the United Democracy Project, a name that does not communicate it is pro-Israel. Member donations capped by law at roughly a few thousand dollars were no longer enough against the squad, and post-Citizens United super PACs allow unlimited sums into congressional races.

Answered around 13:30
What happened in 2015 between AIPAC, Israel and the United States?

Obama's nuclear deal with Iran made the two countries' interests diverge for the first time. Republicans invited Netanyahu to address a joint session of Congress without consulting the White House, and he argued against the deal there. AIPAC had to choose between Israel and the president, and it chose Israel.

Answered around 7:50
How did House Democrats vote on U.S. military aid to Israel?

About 100 Democrats, almost half of all House Democrats, voted a couple of weeks ago to end U.S. military aid to Israel. The effort failed, only one Republican supported it, so the aid continues. But the size of that Democratic vote was unprecedented, unheard of in earlier decades.

Answered around 2:31
When was AIPAC founded, and what was its original mission?

AIPAC was founded a few years after the state of Israel was created in 1948, to defend, protect and strengthen the U.S.-Israel relationship on both sides of the aisle. In its earliest incarnation it mirrored Israel's own labor Zionist, socialist politics, and it was truly a bipartisan, unifying group.

Answered around 4:18
Does AIPAC actually give more than other single-issue super PACs?

AIPAC is definitely up there, but it gives comparable amounts to the crypto lobby and the AI lobby, and there has been some backlash against those PACs in recent election cycles too. AIPAC nonetheless gets the majority of the heat, far more criticism than plenty of other advocacy groups.

Answered around 24:33
Key Quote

“I mean, that was for decades unheard of. That was political suicide for a politician.”

— Jonathan Mahler, AIPAC's Political Shift, at 1:51▶ listen at 1:51
Key Quote

“They split. And AIPAC had to line up with one side or the other, and they lined up with Israel.”

— Jonathan Mahler, AIPAC's Political Shift, at 10:37▶ listen at 10:37
Key Quote

“I think there is no question that AIPAC is wielding a lot of influence in American politics, like full stop.”

— Jonathan Mahler, AIPAC's Political Shift, at 21:53▶ listen at 21:53
Key Quote

“if you question unconditional American military support for Israel, you are not pro-Israel enough.”

— Jonathan Mahler, AIPAC's Political Shift, at 25:54▶ listen at 25:54
Key Quote

“This is the first time they've gone after someone who has mainstream views on Israel,”

— Tom Malinowski, AIPAC's Political Shift, at 28:17▶ listen at 28:17
Key Quote

“They're calling me anti-Israel because I don't think starvation should be used as a weapon of war.”

— Daniel Biss, AIPAC's Political Shift, at 31:40▶ listen at 31:40

Cite this

“AIPAC's Political Shift.” https://nyt.simplecastaudio.com/03d8b493-87fc-4bd1-931f-8a8e9b945d8a/episodes/d711b719-1b63-4c22-ab8b-974f247e9b82/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_c14f671533f35c433de60ec1bed706d6_37922846.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/aipac-s-political-shift.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?