Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

All in with Ryan Cohen

1:03:02 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Ryan Cohen dropped a ready-to-launch online jewelry business for pet food because it was consumable and recurring, and built Chewy by copying Amazon's supply chain while keeping the neighborhood pet store's product knowledge; he sold it in 2017 for $3.35 billion.3:07
  • GameStop began as a passive investment under 5%, and when the CEO offered him a single board seat to fend off another activist he declined, kept accumulating through COVID, crossed 5% and filed a 13D rather than a 13G.13:16
  • His first GameStop strategy was to apply everything he learned at Chewy, hiring e-commerce people from Chewy and Amazon under a CEO he hired, and it took him just over a year to see it was wrong; as CEO he switched to maniacal cost cutting, the pre-owned business and collectibles.19:36
  • For eBay he names three areas: pulling $2 billion of costs out of a business spending 2.4 billion on sales and marketing for no user growth, live commerce with a $400 billion TAM where eBay Live is invisible, and a new marketplace providing liquidity for in-game digital items, using GameStop's 1,600 stores as creator studios and fulfillment nodes.44:38
  • The eBay board rejected the offer citing financing uncertainty and has not engaged, while Cohen is putting 500 million of his own money into a 50% cash, 50% stock deal and says he will not go away.50:05

Brief overview

Ryan Cohen wants to buy eBay and run it himself, betting his own capital against entrenched management.

  1. Will over skill when hiringA customer service leader came from an old people's home and kept reapplying after being rejected as unqualified; she ended up being incredible, and Cohen built the team from people as relentless as h
  2. Chewy's playbook did not transfer to GameStopMaking GameStop more like Chewy was the wrong strategy; cost cutting and collectibles replaced it, and collectibles are now 42% of revenue, $350 million, with Q1 revenue of $835 million, up 14% year o
  3. eBay is a marketplace he would not stock himselfHe would not take in first-hand inventory or go head to head against Amazon; the value is cost cuts, live commerce and digital in-game collectibles, sold to sellers whose pain points eBay has stopped

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What is Ryan Cohen offering eBay shareholders for the company?

The offer is 50% cash and 50% stock, at a premium to where he bought in. He argues eBay holders keep owning eBay, because the combined company's near- and medium-term earnings come from eBay, except now with someone highly incentivized to maximize shareholder value running it.

Answered around 52:43
What would Cohen do differently if he ran eBay?

Three areas. First, immediately improving earnings by pulling $2 billion of costs out, including the $2.4 billion spent on sales and marketing for essentially no user growth. Then two growth vectors he cares about: live commerce, and a marketplace for digital in-game items.

Answered around 44:38
How big is the live commerce opportunity he sees for eBay?

He puts the live commerce TAM around $400 billion, growing quickly in the US and very popular in Asia. eBay has the users and brands, but the platform and back end are poor, creators aren't on it, and sellers wait on an application process.

Answered around 46:12
What is the digital collectibles idea he had not discussed publicly?

eBay leads physical collectibles; he would extend that to in-game digital items — skins, weapons, things people accumulate in AAA titles — building a marketplace that provides liquidity for them. Unlike NFTs these have real utility, nobody offers it, and the addressable market could exceed eBay's physical marketplace.

Answered around 47:56
Why did eBay's board reject the bid, and how does Cohen answer?

Their rejection letter cited financing uncertainty. He replies that the financing comes off eBay's own balance sheet, so if he can't get it, eBay can't either. He says there has been essentially no engagement: they point to high-priced advisors, then don't schedule the meetings.

Answered around 50:05
How has eBay's business performed since COVID?

Every important metric is down: GMV down, active users down by 30 million, operating earnings down, revenue essentially break-even and up only a few points, while operating expenses rose to over half of revenues for a business that carries no inventory. Sellers rely on third-party tools.

Answered around 40:30
How much of his own money is Cohen putting into the eBay deal?

He is putting $500 million of his own money into the transaction, not yet filed at the time of recording. He says he has never pulled a penny out of GameStop and has invested heavily in it, unlike a board and management team that buy no stock themselves.

Answered around 56:47
What are GameStop's latest reported numbers?

Collectibles are 42% of revenue, $350 million. Q1 revenue was $835 million, up 14% year over year. SG&A was cut from $228 million to $202 million. The company holds $9.7 billion in cash and $333 million in free cash flow, and the board authorized a share repurchase.

Answered around 26:45
What strategy did Cohen get wrong at GameStop before fixing it?

He arrived biased by Chewy, hired e-commerce people from Chewy and Amazon, and tried to make GameStop more like Chewy; it took him just over a year to see that was really stupid. As CEO he switched to maniacal cost cutting, ran retail well, and built collectibles.

Answered around 19:36
What does Cohen look for when hiring people?

Will over skill. He describes a woman who came from working in an old people's home, was turned down repeatedly as unqualified on paper, kept applying, and ended up incredible running customer service. He hires diehards who go all in, as psychotic as he is.

Answered around 9:45
Key Quote

“If our suppliers are telling us they never want to speak to us again, it means we're getting the right price.”

— Ryan Cohen, All in with Ryan Cohen, at 8:52▶ listen at 8:52
Key Quote

“I look for will over skill.”

— Ryan Cohen, All in with Ryan Cohen, at 9:45▶ listen at 9:45
Key Quote

“I was on the toilet.”

— Ryan Cohen, All in with Ryan Cohen, at 30:44▶ listen at 30:44
Key Quote

“So why does everyone want us to fail?”

— Ryan Cohen, All in with Ryan Cohen, at 57:43▶ listen at 57:43

Cite this

“All in with Ryan Cohen.” https://content.libsyn.com/p/b/f/b/bfb6719268130bb6/ALLIN-INTV_Cohen_Ch.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/all-in-with-ryan-cohen.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?