Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

An Honor to Be Nominated

37:55 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Escape Pod episode 1034, hosted by Merle Lafferty, presents "An Honor to be Nominated" by Jacob Sinemeyer, an English teacher and speculative fiction author based in Perth, Western Australia, narrated by Eli Hirschman.0:52
  • In the story, Klemk Utha arrives unnoticed at the Planetary Terraforming Awards for the 346 billionth galactic cycle, nominated for his obscure planet Earth among 6,000 nominees, seated seventy rows back beside the aquatics' tank.4:23
  • His former partner Lomitar, now Fieldstar Productions' favourite for his focus-grouped world Folotoro, admits he pulled strings with Berglund to scrape up the minimum nominations just to lure Klemk there and offer him a job.15:51
  • The Board, short a presenter after Pirkenstrub was savaged by his own quetzadillo, drags a drunk Klemk onstage to hand Lomitar the Most Innovative Planet Award; Klemk instead announces his own name and Earth, preaches making strange, niche work, and leaps off the stage as the Kifuk close in.26:06
  • Afterwards Lafferty reflects on awards season, the Hugo scandals of the last twelve years, Chris M. Barkley suing for his trophy, and closes with Jack Benny's line about not deserving the award or his arthritis.32:51

Brief overview

An overlooked indie terraformer hijacks a rigged awards show, turning humiliation into a case for weird art.

  1. Recognition rarely reaches work outside the systemKlemk's independent, volunteer-built Earth was never a contender against studio-made, focus-grouped worlds like Folotoro.
  2. A nomination can be a trap, not a complimentLomitar admits he bought the minimum nominations so Klemk would show up and take a job offer.
  3. Strange work is worth making anywayKlemk tells the ballroom to be weird and do something only you can do, because a reaction means someone cares.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Who wrote and narrated "An Honor to be Nominated"?

Escape Pod episode 1034 presents "An Honor to be Nominated" by Jacob Sinemeyer, an English teacher and speculative fiction author based in Perth, Western Australia, who put his creative writing degree to work in 2025. Merle Lafferty hosts and co-edits; the story is narrated by Eli Hirschman.

Answered around 0:52
Why does Klemk believe his nomination for Earth is a mistake?

Nominations need votes in the trillions, and Earth isn't a contender: not aesthetic enough for the transcendence, not violent enough for the brutalists since the dinosaurs were wiped out, and too short on symmetry and prime numbers for the mathematics. That leaves the penguins, which Klemk genuinely loves.

Answered around 11:43
How did Klemk actually get his nomination?

Lomitar admits he pulled strings, asking Berglund to send side blasts to heavily populated hive mind dimensions, scraping up just the minimum nominations needed to score Klemk an invite. He did it because Klemk stopped returning his calls, and a message left with one of Klemk's terraformers never reached him.

Answered around 15:51
What does Lomitar offer Klemk at his table?

Lomitar calls it a chance to bury the hatchet and asks Klemk to come work for him, like old times, ditching that mud ball. Klemk refuses, saying he enjoys his work and won't bow to the studio or leech off more talented people; Lomitar storms off calling him a stuck-up cephalopod.

Answered around 16:18
Why is Klemk asked to present an award?

Erok, a Kifuk messenger from the Board of Selections, says they are short a presenter: Birkenstrub was set to give an award but his pet quetzadillo broke free and savaged him, and reattaching his limbs and head will take most of a day. Klemk's name was recommended by someone on Spork and Berglund's team.

Answered around 19:46
What does Klemk announce when he opens the envelope?

The chit reads Lomitar, Folotaro, but Klemk's mouth moves without him and he says his own name, Klemk Utha, and Earth. He is instantly sober. Lomitar's running lights turn furious crimson, Spork and Berglin frown, and polite applause and burbling follow before Klemk grins and says that's me.

Answered around 26:32
What is Klemk's message in his acceptance speech?

A planet doesn't have to appeal to everybody; it can be strange, niche or confusing, with avians that don't fly, air breathers that swim and crystalline lattices ignorant of higher mathematics. Be weird, do something only you can do, don't play it safe: even hatred means somebody feels something about your work.

Answered around 28:01
How does Transgalactic News explain what happened at the ceremony?

It reports a technical malfunction: a misprinted envelope meant the honor was mistakenly and temporarily issued to the wrong recipient, and Lomitar, the real winner of Most Innovative Planet, could not accept in person due to impact damage to his exoskeleton. Earth is then flooded with geoengineering flybys threatening its penguin supply.

Answered around 30:46
What inspired Jacob Sinemeyer to write this story?

In Douglas Adams' The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, the self-effacing terraformer Slartibartfast tells Arthur Dent he won an award for his work on Norway's fjords. The author always wondered what that awards ceremony looked like, and whether it was as overblown and self-important as the Oscars.

Answered around 31:58
What recent scandals have hit science fiction awards?

Gamergate's fringes leaked over, bringing the sad puppies who believed readers weren't really enjoying books by queer people, people of color or feminists and so fixed the ballot. A corrupt Hugo administration three years ago dropped people from the ballot and kept their trophies; Chris M. Barkley went to court and won.

Answered around 34:43
Key Quote

“What's your world called? Earth. They blinked. Never heard of it.”

— Eli Hirschman, An Honor to Be Nominated, at 8:01▶ listen at 8:01
Key Quote

“Klemk Utha, he said. Earth! He was suddenly, painfully, appallingly sober.”

— Eli Hirschman, An Honor to Be Nominated, at 26:32▶ listen at 26:32
Key Quote

“So be weird, Klimt cried to the darkness. Do something only you can do. Don't play it safe.”

— Eli Hirschman, An Honor to Be Nominated, at 29:40▶ listen at 29:40
Key Quote

“I always wondered what that awards ceremony looked like, and if it was as overblown and self-important as the Oscars.”

— Merle Lafferty, An Honor to Be Nominated, at 31:58▶ listen at 31:58
Key Quote

“Awards can be amazing. We all agree also that we don't work for that. That's not why we create.”

— Merle Lafferty, An Honor to Be Nominated, at 35:36▶ listen at 35:36
Key Quote

“I don't deserve this award, but I have arthritis, and I don't deserve that either.”

— Merle Lafferty, An Honor to Be Nominated, at 36:28▶ listen at 36:28

Cite this

“An Honor to Be Nominated.” https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/traffic.libsyn.com/escapepod/Escape_Pod_1034-AnHonourToBeNominated.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/an-honor-to-be-nominated.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?