Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

ASTMH Conference Highlights

1:03:53 recording · AUTO · 4 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Vincent Racaniello records TWiP episode 269 live from the American Society for Tropical Medicine and Hygiene meeting in Toronto with Daniel Griffin and Christina Naula, and their guest Martin Grobisch, Professor of Tropical Medicine at the University of Amsterdam.0:28
  • Grobisch traces his start to the early 80s, when as a conscientious objector he served 18 months in a German accident and emergency department instead of the military, enjoyed it, and went on to medical school in Gießen and Bonn, a house job in Ayr in Scotland, infectious diseases training at the Charité and a Masters at the London School under David Warhol.12:36
  • An advertisement in the Lancet took him to the University of the Witwatersrand as the country's first chair of infectious diseases from 2005 for five years, in hospitals where 1,500 internal medicine beds at Chris Hani Baragwanath were all HIV-TB co-infected, and after the Tugela Ferry outbreak killed 52 or 53 patients in about two weeks he was told to bring MDR and XDR-TB under control with no gu23:50
  • Since the 2015 Ebola outbreak in Sierra Leone he has built the Masanga Medical Research Center on the premises of the former Masanga Leprosy Hospital, deliberately intertwined with a 120-bed clinical service, and his group's MAPHESTU fever study admitted about 900 patients in a year, 760 eligible, with almost 40% of admissions malaria and ulcer patients making up 20% of the hospital population.33:54
  • On malaria vaccines he argues they are an important adjuvant tool for the end game but useless where nets, prompt diagnosis and artemisinin combination therapy are not already in place, and he judges that COVID hit Africa less hard than feared for reasons still poorly understood.50:00

Brief overview

A tropical medicine career built across Germany, Scotland, Johannesburg and Sierra Leone, shaped by drug resistance and outbreaks.

  1. Vaccines only add to working malaria controlGrobisch says they make no difference where nets, prompt diagnosis and ACT are not implemented properly.
  2. Drug-resistant TB outran the guidelines in 2005After Tugela Ferry there were no MDR/XDR-TB treatment guidelines and no novel drugs on the horizon.
  3. Research units belong inside the hospitalUnlike most African centres, Masanga's research unit was built intertwined with clinical services, so he now sits on the hospital board.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What do MDR and XDR mean in tuberculosis?

TB stands for tuberculosis; MDR is multi-drug resistance, meaning the two backbone drugs, INH and rifampicin, no longer work, leaving a wide mix of non-working drug patterns. XDR meant essentially nothing worked. In 2005-2006 there were no treatment guidelines and no novel drugs on the horizon; the old ones were toxic or ineffective.

Answered around 30:18
What was the Tugela Ferry outbreak?

Tugela Ferry is a small town in rural KwaZulu-Natal. Around 2005 or 2006 local colleagues noticed that 52 or 53 HIV-TB co-infected patients died within roughly two weeks. All of them had MDR tuberculosis, some even XDR. The Ministry of Health then told the head of internal medicine at Wits to bring it under control.

Answered around 28:10
Can malaria vaccines control malaria on their own?

No. Martin Grobisch calls them a very important adjuvant tool, needed to get into the end game, but of no use where basic control tools are not thoroughly implemented, such as areas of civil strife with disrupted services. First restore impregnated nets, prompt diagnosis, artemisinin combination therapy and intermittent preventive treatment; only then do vaccines add.

Answered around 50:05
What causes fever severe enough for hospital admission in Masanga?

The MAPHESTU study, the Masanga fever study, looked systematically at causes of fever bad enough to lead to admission. About 900 patients required admission in one year, of whom 760 were eligible for inclusion, and 30 to 40 percent, almost 40 percent, were malaria. Overall malaria accounts for 50 to 60 percent of febrile disease.

Answered around 44:40
How did they keep a hospital open during the Ebola outbreak?

They fenced the hospital completely off so even a mouse could not enter, put everybody through one very small gate, and treated every human entering the premises, workforce included, as a suspect Ebola patient until proven otherwise, with two tests. Testing was at a treatment centre 50 kilometres down the dirt road; morning admissions had results by midday.

Answered around 36:06
After malaria, what fills the beds at that hospital?

Diarrhoea is expected and does come next, but the astonishing finding is a lot of severe soft tissue infections and ulcers, not necessarily attributable to the entities you would think of, or Borrelia, which account for only a minority of cases. Some begin as injuries, some are spontaneous. Ulcer patients make up 20 percent of the hospital population.

Answered around 45:52
Why was HIV treatment resisted in South Africa in the mid-2000s?

This was the time of Thabo Mbeki and his health minister Manto Shabalala-Simang, who had different views on fighting HIV; at a conference in Montreal or Toronto they were still exhibiting lime juice and beetroot as a remedy. Antiretrovirals were expensive, motivating cheaper, completely ineffective alternatives such as vitamins and lime juice.

Answered around 26:16
Was COVID really milder in Africa, or just underreported?

Grobisch thinks it is multifaceted but is very sure the absolute dimension of the problem was less than expected: a far younger population, more life taking place outside, proximity to the equator, while BCG, from their own trials, is not protective. Across his network of 15 to 20 research centres, senior colleagues found it less bad than feared.

Answered around 52:53
What is the Masanga hospital like today?

The front door still says Masanga Leprosy Hospital, but leprosy has not been seen for many years, only an occasional suspect case. It has grown into a very special facility with 120 beds, a well-functioning laboratory, the only one in the country able to do bacterial resistance testing, and very specialised surgical services.

Answered around 43:34
What is the Dutch tropical doctor training track?

Grobisch describes an educational track he only knows from the Netherlands, which is not a specialisation. It lasts two years and is a hands-on practical guide towards working in tropical countries: one year of surgery, nine months of paediatrics or obstetrics and gynaecology, and a three-month course. Many NGOs recognise these doctors well.

Answered around 34:15
Key Quote

“You know, this is not where you go for the big bucks and the fame.”

— Daniel Griffin, ASTMH Conference Highlights, at 4:00▶ listen at 4:00
Key Quote

“I really enjoyed it and it changed my path in life.”

— Martin Grobisch, ASTMH Conference Highlights, at 16:37▶ listen at 16:37
Key Quote

“It's just that a whole country grinds to a halt and there is basically no healthcare available any longer.”

— Martin Grobisch, ASTMH Conference Highlights, at 36:01▶ listen at 36:01
Key Quote

“they are not of any use in areas where the basic malaria control tools are not implemented thoroughly and properly.”

— Martin Grobisch, ASTMH Conference Highlights, at 50:15▶ listen at 50:15

Cite this

“ASTMH Conference Highlights.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twip/TWiP269.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/astmh-conference-highlights.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?