Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Australia Water Market

37:12 recording · EN · 8 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Planet Money Summer School opens a seven-continent, eight-week world tour hosted by Robert Smith, starting in New Zealand and Australia with Australian economist Justin Wolfers of the University of Michigan as guide.0:58
  • Wolfers argues other countries are laboratories where the same economic principles meet different rules, demographics and leadership, and that the rules of the game decide who benefits from an exchange.3:03
  • The first case study, from a 2021 Indicator episode by Stacey Bannock-Smith and Darian Woods, covers Australia's water market, where anyone — even non-landowners — can trade water; Neil Hughes of the Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics and Sciences measures benefits in the southern basin at about 12% of the value of water rights, roughly $117 million a year.8:57
  • Sheep and cropping farmer Carly Marriott saw temporary water jump from $100 a megalitre to $1,000 a megalitre, blamed investors she called water flippers, and drove her family five hours to protest at Parliament in Canberra, prompting a government review whose three lessons were regulation, rules that reflect a changing climate, and widely shared information.10:10
  • The second case study, from Karen Duffin and Sarah Gonzalez in 2018, tells how New Zealand's Arthur Grimes invented inflation targeting — zero to two by 92 — and Don Brash forced inflation down from 9% while unemployment passed 11 percent, a transparency-and-credibility trick the Fed adopted when Ben Bernanke named a 2 percent goal on January 25th, 2012.21:11

Brief overview

Australia's water market and New Zealand's inflation target show how rules and credibility reallocate scarce resources.

  1. Markets move water to its most valuable useTrading in the southern basin added about $117 million a year, roughly 12% more produce, meat and wool from the same water.
  2. A bigger pie is not a bigger sliceWolfers calls it one of the deepest lessons in economics: efficiency creates winners and losers, and the promised re-slicing never happens.
  3. Credibility and transparency can beat inflationMultiple equilibria means expectations become reality, so a central bank everyone believes can pull an economy into the virtuous cycle.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
How does Australia's water market work?

The government sets aside water it reckons can be sustainably taken from the dams and puts it on the open market for the highest bidder. Anyone can buy and sell water; farmer Carly Marriott logs into a water exchange on her phone, and trading is as easy as using an app like Venmo or Robinhood.

Answered around 7:44
How much has water trading been worth to Australian farming?

Neil Hughes of the Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics and Sciences found that in the southern basin, benefits are about 12% of the value of water rights, roughly $117 million a year. That is like 12% more produce, meat and wool from the same water, with bigger gains in drought years.

Answered around 9:16
Why were Australian farmers angry about the water market in 2019?

Water prices spiked. Carly Marriott saw water jump from $100 a megalitre to $1,000 a megalitre. Unlike the US, where water markets are generally tied to land, in Australia you do not need land to trade water, and investors could instantly buy up every megalitre when it came onto the website and hold it.

Answered around 10:21
What did the government review recommend for Australia's water markets?

Three lessons: regulate water markets as vigilantly as finance, with rules on conflicts of interest and insider trading; make sure the rules reflect a rapidly changing climate; and share information widely, because institutional investors have an advantage with forecasts, models and fast internet connections over farmers on slow connections.

Answered around 12:27
Why not just let farmers use the water they need without a market?

Justin Wolfers says that works only if there is more than enough water. The problem is scarcity: if the bloke upstream uses what he needs, less is left downstream, and without a market the water has no value to him, so he may as well use it all. This is the tragedy of the commons.

Answered around 14:09
Do speculators help or hurt a market like water?

Wolfers says speculators can make markets more efficient by buying when prices are low and selling when high, adding demand or supply when it is scarce. But they can also fuel a speculative bubble where prices divorce from reality, as in the 2006 American real estate bubble, though it did not seem to happen in Australia's water market.

Answered around 15:46
Who invented inflation targeting and how did it come about?

Arthur Grimes, former chief economist at New Zealand's central bank and a jazz saxophonist. Sent around the world around 1985-86, he saw central banks targeting money supply, employment or interest rates, all aimed at low inflation, so he proposed targeting inflation directly. The term was only invented after New Zealand did it.

Answered around 23:11
Why did New Zealand choose a zero to two percent inflation target?

Inflation was 9%, and Grimes proposed a range: zero to two by 1992. Zero percent means absolute price stability, while 1% inflation does not affect well-being, so New Zealand economists treated 1% as neutral. Grimes added plus or minus 1% wiggle room, giving zero to two.

Answered around 23:50
What did bringing New Zealand's inflation down cost?

Don Brash restricted money in banks' vaults and asked workers and businesses to act as if inflation were already 2%. Nobody believed him; workers kept demanding raises, companies laid people off, and unemployment went past 11%, one in nine people. The target was reached by 1991, but unemployment stayed high for years.

Answered around 27:06
How can expectations alone lower inflation, according to Justin Wolfers?

Through multiple equilibria: many outcomes are possible. If people believe inflation will be low, businesses expect competitors and input costs not to rise and keep prices down, a virtuous cycle; expecting high inflation creates a vicious cycle. Getting everyone to believe the good one requires credibility and transparency, and can cut inflation without a recession.

Answered around 31:00
Key Quote

“The truth is, Robert, I was not ready, wait for it, koalified to teach that one.”

— Justin Wolfers, Australia Water Market, at 2:35▶ listen at 2:35
Key Quote

“It rains. That's it. God decides.”

— Justin Wolfers, Australia Water Market, at 5:11▶ listen at 5:11
Key Quote

“From $100 a megalitre to $1,000 a megalitre.”

— Carly Marriott, Australia Water Market, at 10:21▶ listen at 10:21
Key Quote

“We dragged our kids five hours in the middle of summer to protest.”

— Carly Marriott, Australia Water Market, at 11:16▶ listen at 11:16
Key Quote

“Economic efficiency is saying the size of the pie got bigger. It's not promising your slice got bigger.”

— Justin Wolfers, Australia Water Market, at 17:31▶ listen at 17:31
Key Quote

“There was no such thing as inflation targeting at the time.”

— Arthur Grimes, Australia Water Market, at 23:42▶ listen at 23:42

Cite this

“Australia Water Market.” https://npr.simplecastaudio.com/43b5acee-463e-4612-95ad-d2596d9dd337/episodes/4586ba03-099f-4572-bec4-373256ae6223/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_7c08927c1cb1671eb9d9998acfeb5f6a_35714690.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/australia-water-market.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?