Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Belief and the Absurd

59:49 recording · EN · 6 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Host David Bogert opens episode 313 of the unbelievable podcast, the first of four best-of specials drawn from seven years of archive, with the most beautiful religious conversations at its centre.1:00
  • Cabaretier Arjen Lubach, invited for the very first episode because research showed more than half of the Dutch no longer call themselves religious, calls faith the permission of the unproven and compares debating believers to a tennis opponent who grills the ball in a tosti-iron.1:52
  • Herman Vinkers argues the opposite, that Catholicism is not a course you reason your way into but a heritage, and defends the church through his great-grandfather Jan Finkers, who spent his life among the Indians in South Venezuela.12:50
  • Writer and musician Aafke Romeijn, raised in what she calls an atheist nest, says religion is an attractive alternative to a dull and dry worldview, and asks why someone who dyes her hair blue would not dare take that step.18:38
  • The episode closes with poet Lieke Marsman, who died of a rare cancer on June 3, describing how while walking through the rainy Veluwe forests she felt a power with her that she still knows was real.49:33

Brief overview

A best-of episode showing how Dutch believers and atheists have grown milder toward each other's worldviews.

  1. Atheists have grown milder, not louderLubach, Tim Hofman and others moved from mocking believers to caring only that religion does not block equality.
  2. The absurd divides and unitesLubach rejects faith because it is absurd; Vinkers believes because it is, credo quia absurdum.
  3. Searching can replace findingTyphoon says the search gets made holy because finding brings responsibility and forces a choice.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Why does Arjen Lubach think faith has no place in public debate?

Lubach says believing closes the door by allowing things you cannot prove, so nobody can end an argument with "because I believe that". Without it the discussion about human rights or the relationship between man and woman stays clean, although he admits such a world sounds boring.

Answered around 2:09
Why does Herman Finkers see the absurd as a reason to believe?

Finkers calls art, humour and religion his small trinity: each finds a way to deal with the unruly. A joke makes the impossible possible; religion does the same with a theological system, God before whom there was nothing and Mary as his mother. Credo quia absurdum.

Answered around 6:22
Why does Herman Finkers stay a member of the Catholic Church?

Finkers says the hypocrites and the abusers do not belong in the church and it is not theirs, it belongs to us all. He thinks of anonymous religious workers in slums and of his great-grandfather Jan Finkers, who lived among the Indians in South Venezuela, making them less afraid.

Answered around 9:34
What is apatheism and how does it differ from atheism?

Stefan Paes, borrowing the term from American researcher Phil Zuckerman, says an atheist still finds not believing difficult and wants to debate believers, so God stays a theoretical concept to be against. An apatheist has no antenna at all; Paes compares it to how Dutch people watch cricket.

Answered around 13:59
What fascinates Aafke Romeijn about the church after an atheist upbringing?

Romeijn says she is very sensitive to rituals and symbols; even people marching in uniform can make her cry, though she dislikes the military. In church she feels small and humble in a pleasant way, especially with music, and she loves stories where fact and fiction cannot be separated.

Answered around 16:54
How has Tim Hofman's view of believers changed since 2013?

Hofman says if you Google him you find him in 2013 calling Christians stupid; now he finds that irrelevant. His concern is that a mainstream religion does not stand in the way of equality. He blames oppression on people, the soldiers on earth, not on Jesus, an incredibly left-wing nice man.

Answered around 22:07
What does Typhoon mean by the search being made holy?

Typhoon wrote the line "I was addicted to searching" and says the search becomes holy because we are afraid to find something: finding brings responsibility and choices, and once you know you can no longer pretend you don't. Endless options feel safe; his own choice unlocked a world he hadn't seen.

Answered around 31:48
Why does Ernst-Jan Pfauth envy people who can believe?

Pfauth gives two reasons: believers can always direct their gratitude to someone, and their meaning is limited, lying in surrender to God. His own focus on performing, popularity and quality of work satisfied him, yet felt like something that would never be enough, never enough Twitter followers or podcast listeners.

Answered around 35:30
What does Pascal advise someone who cannot simply decide to believe?

Rick Peels explains that Pascal explicitly recognised you cannot switch belief on one morning. His advice is to give it a go: go to mass, say those prayers, live as if God exists and see whether it stands. The proof of the pudding is in the eating.

Answered around 44:50
What did Lieke Marsman experience during her walk on the Veluwe?

After hearing she would not get better, Marsman went to the Veluwe for a week with her then girlfriend during Covid; it rained all week and was a personal low point. Walking through the forests she suddenly felt a power with her that answered her heavy feeling rather than solving her problems.

Answered around 49:33
Key Quote

“You close the door for allowing things that you cannot prove.”

— Arjen Lubach, Belief and the Absurd, at 2:09▶ listen at 2:09
Key Quote

“Why would I not take this step, say?”

— Aafke Romeijn, Belief and the Absurd, at 21:15▶ listen at 21:15
Key Quote

“But I think it's the easy way to not do it like Jesus.”

— Tim Hofman, Belief and the Absurd, at 27:08▶ listen at 27:08
Key Quote

“And that's when I knew, for me this is so real.”

— Typhoon, Belief and the Absurd, at 31:12▶ listen at 31:12

Cite this

“Belief and the Absurd.” https://podcast.npo.nl/file/de-ongelooflijke-podcast/143924/geloven-in-god-arjen-lubach-herman-finkers-lieke-marsman-typhoon-ea-the-best-of-ongelooflijke.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/belief-and-the-absurd.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?