Benjamin Rosario was dismembered in Bridgeport in 1994, and his unsolved case still points closest to home.
On August 3rd, 1994, a trash bag was flagged in the middle of Seaview Avenue in Bridgeport's East End. Patrol officer Ernie Nandori expected a discarded Halloween toy, but found a full human foot still attached to the rest of the leg. Reporter Dan Tepfer heard the call on the police scanner and rushed out.
Answered around 2:27Officer Nandori recognized dark jeans in the bag, airbrushed with a star and the letters S.D., from a missing person report he had taken the day before from Benjamin's wife Nellie and stepson Broderick. After more bags were found, Benjamin was officially identified through fingerprints.
Answered around 4:27Around 10 p.m. on Monday, August 1st, Benjamin headed to Side Effects, a bar a few blocks away that he frequented. Witnesses confirmed he was there and saw him leave between 11 and 11:30 p.m. with a Hispanic man in his mid-30s, whose identity police know but would not reveal.
Answered around 5:56On August 4th, investigators found another trash bag under an overpass about a two-minute walk away. The next day, an off-duty police officer fishing at Pleasure Beach, in an area closed to the public, smelled decomposition and found four trash bags in the undergrowth, each containing human remains.
Answered around 7:01Four other men were dismembered between 1992 and 1994, later linked to Richard Rogers, who targeted men at gay bars. Benjamin's case differed: the cuts were not methodical, his family said he was not gay, and Rogers, a white man in his early 40s, did not match the man Benjamin left with. Police never questioned Rogers.
Answered around 13:47McCrary saw no medical knowledge in the dismemberment: the killer chopped through the bones instead of disarticulating at the joints, the least efficient way. The bar, Benjamin's home and all the dump sites, including Pleasure Beach, were within walking distance, which made him think the killer was local.
Answered around 12:27Henry, who lived with Benjamin and Nellie, told reporter Dan Tepfer he was glad Benjamin was dead and that he never should have married his aunt. He goes by the nickname Swords, and the jeans found with the remains belonged to him. He moved to Florida weeks to months after the murder.
Answered around 18:25On a first call, Henry confirmed his name but asked for a Spanish translator. When reporter Laura called back with translator Stephanie, the man denied knowing Benjamin or Henry Robles, said he had a different name he would not give, and hung up. Detective Holtz has not been able to speak with him either.
Answered around 20:55Police asked about Jamaican gang violence in the East End, but Nellie said he got along with everybody. There were rumors of abuse in the home by Nellie or Benjamin, a search of stepson Broderick's home recovered a trash bag with nothing usable, and a tip that Benjamin was a building superintendent was denied by his grandson.
Answered around 16:21Detective Holtz plans to have the remaining evidence retested for DNA and prints, especially the pants. No foreign DNA was found the first time, and the only foreign print belonged to the off-duty officer at Pleasure Beach. Tips can go to the Bridgeport Police Department at 203-576-TIPS.
Answered around 27:59“I was thinking that it was going to be a toy that was sticking out of the bag, something from Halloween.”
“This guy, whoever it is, chopped through the bones, which is the least efficient and the most difficult way to achieve the dismemberment.”
“In homicides, there's a 70 to 80 percent chance there's a known relationship between the victim and offender.”
“And right then I knew something was going on here. He certainly was not unhappy that Benjamin Rosario was dead.”
“Matter of fact, he went on and on about how much he hated him. He definitely was an angry person.”
“And he just kept saying, I don't know those two people.”
“Benjamin Rosario Murder Mystery.” https://rsv.simplecastaudio.com/665829b1-6a18-4a6b-ba95-2d6c5caf4f0f/episodes/ebfa5e40-9cc8-46f8-8e3a-b455fdb0354f/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_4952b24928ba7a127581a26f810cd132_29846917.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/benjamin-rosario-murder-mystery.html.