Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Berlin Diamond Heist Mystery

54:55 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Three masked men slid through a skylight into a fancy Berlin department store and took $6.5 million in fine jewelry and watches, leaving behind one glove holding a single bead of sweat whose DNA matched two 27-year-old brothers, identical twins H and A, both with records for theft and fraud.1:28
  • Because prosecutors could not prove beyond a reasonable doubt which twin or whether both took part, both were released within the week, with the court stating it could deduce at least one brother was involved but not which one, leaving the heist unsolved.3:26
  • A normal crime DNA test scans about 20 fixed markers, while telling identical twins apart means sequencing the whole 3 billion base genome at ultra high depth to find roughly eight typos, something only a handful of labs can do at a cost of hundreds of thousands up to seven figures, and it is easily thrown out in court.4:16
  • In Ohio, 64-year-old Denise was found by her brother Daryl in her bed, ripped pajamas, an angel figurine on the blanket over her face, cleaning chemicals and Pepto-Bismol poured on her, and the DNA under her nails traced to 13-year-old identical twins Hunter and Levi Cart from across the street.5:31
  • Cheek swabs came back a match for both twins, so investigators maneuvered the family to the station without detaining them, questioned the boys in separate rooms while Becca demanded a lawyer and had her phone taken, heard Levi's long account of being scratched at 2:30 a.m. by the cat Marshmallow, heard Hunter volunteer his brother's trauma and research into sociopaths, and then learned Levi has c21:06

Brief overview

Identical twin DNA can stall justice, in a Berlin jewelry heist and in an Ohio murder.

  1. Identical twins can break a DNA caseShared nuclear DNA meant the Berlin glove pointed at two brothers and convicted neither.
  2. Telling twins apart costs a fortuneFull genome sequencing to find about eight typos runs into six or seven figures at a handful of labs.
  3. The same wall stands in OhioHunter and Levi Cart both matched the DNA in Denise's bed, so investigators had to separate them by story, not by lab.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Why did both Cart twins become suspects in Denise's murder?

Investigators took cheek swabs from both 13-year-old twins and the DNA came back a match for both. Because they are identical twins they share the same STR markers, so police could not tell whether one or both were guilty, only that a match was found in Denise's bed.

Answered around 21:06
Did police ever catch the Berlin jewelry heist thieves?

No. DNA from the glove matched two 27-year-old identical twin brothers, H and A, but prosecutors could not prove beyond a reasonable doubt which twin, or whether both, took part. Within the week both were released before trial, the court saying it could not determine which one. The heist goes unsolved.

Answered around 3:26
Why can't a standard DNA test tell identical twins apart?

A normal crime DNA test scans about 20 fixed markers, because that is how different everyone's DNA is, and that already takes multiple days. Identical twins develop from a single fertilized egg that splits into two embryos, so they share the same nuclear DNA and the same markers at those spots.

Answered around 3:57
How different is the DNA of two identical twins?

A sequencing expert compares the genome to a 3 billion letter code that has to be copied as a body grows, with typos happening during the copying. Identical twins have the same DNA except, on average, about eight typos across that whole 3 billion genome, plus a few cells that split and evolve differently.

Answered around 4:38
What would it cost to work out which twin left the DNA?

Sequencing the entire three billion base genome at ultra high depth costs taxpayers hundreds of thousands of dollars, maybe up to the seven figure mark, and only a handful of labs in the world can run it. Even then it is often thrown out in court or used to confuse the jury.

Answered around 5:04
How much was stolen in the Berlin department store heist?

Three masked men slid down a rope through the skylight of a fancy Berlin department store after midnight and took $6.5 million worth of fine jewelry and watches. The doors were impenetrable, and the store ran motion detectors and an extensive security system across the entire place.

Answered around 1:28
What evidence did the Berlin thieves leave behind?

They left behind a singular glove, and inside it a singular bead of sweat: DNA evidence. Authorities ran the DNA and got a hit that linked back to two people with criminal records for theft and fraud, identical twin brothers aged 27. That glove was all the evidence police had, nothing else.

Answered around 1:37
Who found Denise, and what did the scene look like?

Her brother Daryl found her. They had Sunday lunch plans, she was not picking up, and he messaged at 11:11 a.m. Within the hour he came over and the unlocked front door pushed open when he knocked. She lay on her bed, pajamas ripped, blood between her legs, blankets over her face.

Answered around 9:01
How did Levi explain the scratches on his face?

Levi said the family cat Marshmallow, who normally sleeps with his mom, was lying on his chest around 2 or 2:30 in the morning. He was freaked out, tried to touch him, and the cat scratched his arms, neck and face, cutting his nose with an uncut claw. Five stitches.

Answered around 29:48
What condition might make Levi incapable of the attack?

Investigators found out Levi has cerebral palsy, a group of movement and posture disorders coming from injury to the parts of the brain that control the muscles, not the muscles themselves. Many people with it play intense sports; for others it is severely limiting. Police did not know where Levi fell on that scale.

Answered around 53:21
Key Quote

“They take $6.5 million worth of fine jewelry and watches.”

— Berlin Diamond Heist Mystery, at 1:28▶ listen at 1:28
Key Quote

“I want to get us our lawyer.”

— Berlin Diamond Heist Mystery, at 26:28▶ listen at 26:28
Key Quote

“Do you guys think he's a suspect possibly or am I crazy?”

— Berlin Diamond Heist Mystery, at 40:38▶ listen at 40:38

Cite this

“Berlin Diamond Heist Mystery.” https://stitcher.simplecastaudio.com/ca05dec2-017c-4888-bda3-ab746f266395/episodes/18c9d989-b117-4458-94e6-8c643fd09aa5/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_6a95ce504b8c9e4446ee49854f83a99b_52879888.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/berlin-diamond-heist-mystery.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?