Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Bottle Conjurer's Hoax

52:03 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Tim Harford interviews historian Maddy Pelling about her book Hoax, Truth and Lies in the Age of Enlightenment, arguing the supposedly rational 18th century was a chaotic, post-truth age that bred hoaxers.5:06
  • Her opening example is the bottle conjurer: hundreds paid to see a man climb into a wine bottle at the Haymarket Theatre, nobody came, a thrown candle set the curtain alight and soldiers had to quell the riot.8:25
  • Mary Bateman, born in 1768 near Thirsk, moved to Leeds, worked as a dressmaker's assistant and sold charms and ill wishes; in 1803 she announced the apocalypse, writing 'Crist is coming' in vinegar on boiled eggs she reinserted into her hens and charged people to watch being laid.22:10
  • She stripped Rebecca and William Perigo of nearly everything they owned for a fictitious witch, Miss Blythe of Scarborough, then had them bake a pie laced with arsenic; Rebecca died over days with her tongue swollen black, and William survived on one bitter mouthful.25:12
  • William kept the letters she told him to burn, Mary was convicted at York, pleaded the belly unsuccessfully, fed her baby a final time and was hanged, after which anatomist William Hay dissected her over three days and her bones stayed on display in Leeds until 2015.29:51

Brief overview

Historian Maddy Pelling shows how Enlightenment-era hoaxer Mary Bateman read people's hopes, then robbed and poisoned them.

  1. Hoaxers sell hope, not tricksPelling argues scammers find what is missing in people's lives and promise exactly that.
  2. Private manipulation escapes detection longestMary avoided showing her power off, so an impersonal, fast-growing Leeds never joined the dots.
  3. Cost and authority signal false legitimacyA listener's aunt paid $15,000 for a PC scrolling coloured text because the price made it credible.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
How did Mary Bateman kill Rebecca Perigo?

Claiming the answer came from Miss Blythe, Mary told the Perigos to bake a pie with a powder she supplied, eat all of it, then eat honey to sweeten it. Rebecca managed a few mouthfuls, William one. Within minutes both were writhing; Rebecca died over days, her tongue swollen and black.

Answered around 24:48
How was Mary Bateman finally caught?

Once recovered, William Perigo arranged to meet her on a Leeds canal with two constables hiding nearby. She denied poisoning and tried to sell him more 'magical powder'. When arrested she claimed he was selling her arsenic. The vial was arsenic, and her house held goods taken from multiple victims.

Answered around 26:26
Who was Mary Bateman and where did she come from?

She was born in 1768 in a small village outside Thirsk, North Yorkshire, to farming parents. At the village's annual fair she saw magic tricks and fortune telling, which sparked her lifelong habit of reading people, seeing what they want and giving it to them as manipulation.

Answered around 10:16
How did the Miss Blythe hoax drain the Perigos' possessions?

Mary posed as intermediary for an invented Miss Blythe of Scarborough, a supposedly more powerful witch. The Perigos handed over a petticoat, gold coins, cheese, a leg of ham, even a new bed with bedding, for months, giving almost everything they had, yet Rebecca was never cured.

Answered around 23:33
What happened when Mary Bateman was sentenced to death?

Sentenced to hang, she pleaded the belly, claiming she was pregnant. The judge closed the courthouse doors and asked female volunteers from the crowd to inspect her in a side room. They reported no sign of pregnancy, so she could go to the gallows, though nobody knows if she truly was.

Answered around 29:51
What happened to Mary Bateman's body after her execution?

Her body went to the Leeds anatomy school, where anatomist William Hay dissected her over three days as a show, holding up her womb and heart. She was boiled down and her bones were displayed at what became the Thackray Museum until 2015. Spectators touched her remains, fearing her revenge.

Answered around 32:33
Did Mary Bateman poison the Kitchen sisters?

Mary was solely responsible for preparing food for the two spinster sisters, who died in quick succession, followed by their mother after eating in the household. Disease was rife in crowded Leeds, but given her later crimes, Pelling thinks there is a very good chance she poisoned them; a contemporary doctor agreed.

Answered around 21:17
What was the bottle conjurer hoax?

A man advertised he would appear at London's Haymarket Theatre, drink a wine bottle's contents, climb inside the ordinary bottle, sing and tell fortunes. Hundreds paid, but nobody came. The crowd rioted, a lit candle set the curtain ablaze, soldiers were called, and the conjurer's identity was never discovered.

Answered around 7:14
What was Mary Bateman's apocalypse egg hoax?

In 1803 she announced the apocalypse was coming. She boiled her hens' eggs, wrote on them in vinegar, misspelling Christ as 'Chris is coming', reinserted them into the chickens and charged people to watch them laid. People paid in droves, yet when no apocalypse came she was not exposed.

Answered around 22:10
What makes a scammer's story so convincing to victims?

Pelling says it offers hope: something good you cannot get elsewhere, available only through this one person. Scammers spot what is missing in people's lives and offer exactly that, with a pretence of expertise and authority, and the sense that something costing enough, like Stuart's aunt's $15,000 healing box, must be legitimate.

Answered around 39:22
Key Quote

“Do you think she killed them?”

— Tim Harford, Bottle Conjurer's Hoax, at 21:07▶ listen at 21:07
Key Quote

“I think there is a very good chance that she has poisoned these sisters.”

— Maddy Pelling, Bottle Conjurer's Hoax, at 21:21▶ listen at 21:21
Key Quote

“She announces to the city that the apocalypse is coming.”

— Maddy Pelling, Bottle Conjurer's Hoax, at 22:10▶ listen at 22:10
Key Quote

“I think it's got to be that it offers people hope, right?”

— Maddy Pelling, Bottle Conjurer's Hoax, at 39:22▶ listen at 39:22

Cite this

“Bottle Conjurer's Hoax.” https://28243.mc.tritondigital.com:443/OMNY_CAUTIONARYTALESWITHTIMHARFORD_PODCAST_P/media-session/d7c5ea47-2b2a-407b-a2a3-f6e5f675a59f/d/clips/e73c998e-6e60-432f-8610-ae210140c5b1/c0ae8c6e-22f0-4e9b-ac1c-ae390037ac53/f1feb573-07b2-4dbe-92d6-b4970118d34a/audio/direct/t1785470609/Arsenic_and_Lace_The_Trial_of_the_Yorkshire_Witch_-_with_Maddy_Pelling.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/bottle-conjurer-s-hoax.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?