A 23-year-old Michigan mother vanished after a 911 call, and the man with her was never identified.
Law enforcement later identified her as 23-year-old Brittany Wallace Shank. On November 30, 2018 she turned up barefoot, coatless and scratched at John's back door off Fawn River Road outside Sturgis, Michigan, then walked away before deputies arrived. She has never been seen again, and why she left has never been determined.
Answered around 2:42Barely at all. The car had veered off the fog-covered road into what the report calls a ditch, though most people describe a very shallow divot, and it was still drivable. John saw only small cuts on her feet and arms, injuries the hosts say a crash like that cannot explain.
Answered around 5:07She went to John's farmhouse to use the phone, not specifically to call 911. She first tried her grandma Vicky, and either that call didn't go through or Vicky didn't answer. She handed the phone to John quickly and wouldn't give dispatch her name or address; the call came in around 8:50 p.m.
Answered around 8:52The hosts think she was never looking for first responders — she had called her grandma for a ride — and left once she realized deputies were on their way. She had a warrant out for larceny at the time, so she may not have wanted police coming out there at all.
Answered around 9:22Nobody ever got his name. From descriptions at grandma's house he was a thin white man in his early to mid-20s, between about 5'6" and 5'8", with short blonde hair and thick mutton-chop sideburns — like Elvis, as grandma put it — wearing a yellow sweatsuit-type outfit with some black on it.
Answered around 12:10Sheldon was her on-and-off boyfriend and owned the car she was driving. When officers came by around 10:30 p.m. or later to say the car had been impounded, he was home and told them he hadn't been with Brittany at all: she had borrowed his car and he had no clue who she was with.
Answered around 7:37Eight days after the night she walked off into the cold, her dad Greg Wallace reported her missing to the St. Joseph County Sheriff's Office. Until then family and Sheldon assumed she was laying low — embarrassed about the car, or avoiding the larceny warrant — and would simply turn back up.
Answered around 10:10No. Investigators assumed at first that this was a woman who didn't want to be found rather than foul play, so it was never processed and Sheldon just collected it from impound. He says the inside was trashed — glove box open, Brittany's purse dumped out, belongings scattered everywhere.
Answered around 26:51It is a receipt for twenty dollars of gas at the Marathon station on Fawn River Road, time-stamped 6:11 p.m. on November 30 and appearing to carry Britt's account information. Investigators never got the physical copy, only photos Ashley took, which she says she found in her recovered stolen car.
Answered around 40:37Ashley told investigators she and Brittany were sisters, which isn't true, and family say she wasn't nearly as close as she presented while constantly inserting herself into the investigation. She admits accessing one of Britt's Facebook accounts, messages between them disappeared, and she is Eric Shank's alibi for that night.
Answered around 28:38“Because since Brittany slipped into the darkness that November night back in 2018, she has never been seen again.”
“Listen, I don't know where the cuts come from, but I don't think it was from the crash because there is really no crash.”
“How is this even remotely acceptable for an investigation?”
“I think somebody out there really does know exactly what happened to Britney Wallace Shank that day, November 30th, 2018.”
“Brittany Wallace Shank Disappearance.” https://rsv.simplecastaudio.com/ec74d48c-cbf1-4764-923e-7d584dce50fa/episodes/26ccbdcd-f1aa-4adc-92b9-8a27fdbce384/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_3cd97aed4812cf91bea2cd8af86d9f2b_72110531.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/brittany-wallace-shank-disappearance.html.