Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Brownstone Restoration Business

22:43 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Sam spends a day with Mark O'Brien, a brownstone restorer he found on Instagram, to open up his real numbers and decide whether he'd trade places with him.0:09
  • At 94 Bank Street, a 180-year-old West Village house, Mark says he paid five-five, is closer to six all-in, and expects to sell for 17, after two and a half years just waiting on landmark permits.3:05
  • Mark got into real estate out of desperation, over-leveraged with two and a half kids in Greenwich, Connecticut, on first deals where you buy for a million, build for a million and sell for three.9:17
  • The Fort Greene house is 4,500 square feet: 2.8 to buy, about 2 million to build, 6.2 on the sale over three years, roughly $500,000 a year, which Mark calls pretty slim.18:57
  • Sam scores the business 8 out of 30 (money 3, machine 3, moat 2) and the lifestyle 21 out of 30 (pride 9, people 7, freedom 5), for a total of 29.21:53

Brief overview

Mark O'Brien restores New York brownstones for thin margins: huge pride, modest money, a Sam score of 29.

  1. Permits, not construction, are the real costTwo and a half years of architects, engineers and soil bearing tests on Bank Street before work could start — "time will kill every deal."
  2. Leverage built the business and could break itMark borrowed against his own house to buy the next one and calls himself a big believer in other people's money, while admitting it's a great way to go broke.
  3. Great pride, thin moneySam rates pride a nine but the money a three: roughly $500,000 a year on the Fort Greene deal, and a bad year can lose money.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What are the numbers on the Fort Greene brownstone?

Mark paid $2.8 million to buy it and is putting in about $2 million to build it, so $4.8 million in. He expects to sell for $6.2 million, and that is over three years. Sam works it out to something like $500,000 a year, and calls it pretty slim.

Answered around 18:57
How much is the West Village house costing him?

94 Bank Street, a 180-year-old house he is living in while restoring, cost five-five. At this stage he says he will have to invest closer to six more, and he believes he can sell it for 17. He bought it because, unusually for him, it was already cute.

Answered around 3:05
Is restoring brownstones actually a good business and life?

Sam scores money a three: maybe $500,000 to a million a year on a good year, losing money on a bad one, for a lot of work. Machine gets three, moat two, so business is eight of thirty. Lifestyle gets nine for pride, seven for people, five for freedom: 21. Total 29.

Answered around 19:44
How did Mark get into real estate in the first place?

Desperation. He was freaking out, with two and a half kids, living in a house in Greenwich, Connecticut that he had no right to, the kind of thing he would have had somebody else fix. He was completely over-leveraged, took it on himself, it worked, and that is how he has lived since.

Answered around 6:06
What did his first restoration project make him?

Back then the math was buy for a million, build for a million, sell for three. His own first house cost $800,000 and he built it for about $800,000, making crazy mistakes along the way, then sold it for around two-three in less than a year. On the next one he made a million.

Answered around 9:17
Why do these projects take so many years?

The Bank Street house is landmarked and he has been waiting two and a half years just for permits. The time goes to architects, engineers, soil bearing tests, breaking up the cellar foundation, and proving where his footing sits against the neighbour's. As he puts it, time will kill every deal, and often does.

Answered around 4:13
How many brownstones has Mark restored so far?

94 Bank Street is his third big brownstone restoration, after 62 Green Avenue in Fort Greene and 428 Vanderbilt. He also has other projects he does not own, in Crown Heights and one on Jane Street, where he acts as the owner's rep and runs the project for someone else.

Answered around 8:36
What does he change in every house he restores?

Three things: he goes onto the roof, finishes the cellar, and widens the staircase, adding a bulkhead up top so light comes down the middle. He also rips the plaster off to expose brick that is 140 years old, and grinds back original floors he finds under plastic vinyl instead of tiling over them.

Answered around 12:00
Why does he bother finishing the cellar?

Because it is basically free square footage. Under FAR, floor area ratio, a basement below grade is not counted, so the space costs him nothing against the allowance. He still has to put baseboard on, finish the floor and spruce it up so it feels like real space rather than a rubble-walled cellar.

Answered around 13:27
Who buys a restored brownstone like this?

In Fort Greene, Mark says he gets a lot of creatives. Not so much actors these days, more people in social media or running some kind of media business. Sam jokes that he may end up buying a six-million-dollar home in Brooklyn himself. The house is 4,500 square feet, around the corner from Spike Lee.

Answered around 13:54
Key Quote

“So look, I usually buy things that have rats in the cellar and holes in the roof and water damage everywhere, mold and problems.”

— Mark O'Brien, Brownstone Restoration Business, at 2:47▶ listen at 2:47
Key Quote

“What was that thing that made you get into real estate? And I said, desperation.”

— Mark O'Brien, Brownstone Restoration Business, at 6:12▶ listen at 6:12
Key Quote

“I was freaking out. I had two and a half kids.”

— Mark O'Brien, Brownstone Restoration Business, at 6:17▶ listen at 6:17
Key Quote

“It was, it was, I was completely over leveraged.”

— Mark O'Brien, Brownstone Restoration Business, at 6:46▶ listen at 6:46
Key Quote

“But it's a great way to go broke and get yourself in a lot of trouble.”

— Mark O'Brien, Brownstone Restoration Business, at 6:54▶ listen at 6:54
Key Quote

“And this is basically free square footage.”

— Mark O'Brien, Brownstone Restoration Business, at 13:27▶ listen at 13:27

Cite this

“Brownstone Restoration Business.” https://dcs-cached.megaphone.fm/HS6226616717.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/brownstone-restoration-business.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?