A 1993 Indianapolis murder went unsolved for 31 years until one untrained sergeant's genealogy work named Dana Shepard.
Dana Shepard, who lived in Carmen's apartment complex. Four months after police served a warrant for his swabs and fingerprints, his DNA matched the DNA in Carmen's case, and on August 30, 2024, thirty-one years after her death, he was arrested in Missouri on charges of murder and rape with deadly force.
Answered around 38:19Less than a week before jury selection, he took a plea deal. On January 23, 2026, he pled guilty to one count of murder and was sentenced to 45 years at the Indiana Department of Corrections. The second murder charge and the rape with a deadly weapon charge were dropped.
Answered around 45:47Carmen had 60 stab wounds to her head, face, body and genitalia, and the attack was so violent that the wounds to her head penetrated her skull. Neighbours had heard her screaming 'get off me' between crying and banging noises for about 30 minutes before one set of footsteps left.
Answered around 5:41After Season of Justice funded 15 hours of genealogical research and an upload to another database in 2020, Parabon contacted Carter on June 2, 2023 saying they may have found a close relative: a great niece once removed who had uploaded her DNA to 23andMe. Analyst Meera Patel took it from there.
Answered around 35:40Both Shepard brothers were on the list of people living in Carmen's apartment complex at the time of her murder. Captain Carter and Meera Patel walked it: about 30 seconds from their apartment to hers, connected by a common area that includes the laundry room. That complex was the only known connection.
Answered around 36:34An Indianapolis officer with zero cold case or homicide training, who started as a state revenue agent, then domestic violence, then nuisance abatement. After he solved Amy Weidner's case in his spare time, an IMPD officer who went to high school with Carmen asked him to look into hers, and he dove in.
Answered around 19:05He raised over $1,200 in seven hours on GoFundMe, needing only $996. Almost as quickly, IMPD made him send every donation back and removed him from Carmen's case, then handed him a 10-day suspension, his first discipline ever. Officials said people should stay in their lanes.
Answered around 28:00When results came back in 2015, the cold case sergeant told Carter their killer was a European female, which is impossible because the original profile came from a semen sample. The city had sent the wrong sample, likely Carmen's own DNA. Officials then refused to pay for a repeat.
Answered around 26:05Still unknown. News outlets over the years published that Carmen was likely stabbed with a screwdriver or a pocket knife, and investigators said the wounds were consistent with something small and pointed, but the actual weapon has never been found, and neither object turned up in her apartment or anywhere else.
Answered around 5:55The bill Carmen's sister Pam championed. It passed the Indiana State Senate unanimously and was signed into law by the governor in March, establishing a framework for private funding of advanced DNA testing in all cases that have gone unsolved for five or more years, requestable by families.
Answered around 47:26“if we can do it for a horse, surely we could do it for Carmen.”
“the only person that's ever made any progress is Bill Carter.”
“We were coming a lot closer just as she was taken from us.”
“Carmen Van Huss Murder Case.” https://rsv.simplecastaudio.com/ec74d48c-cbf1-4764-923e-7d584dce50fa/episodes/fd5770c4-3094-4b1a-991c-a061a5e458cc/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_a8d422edce2264c2ccc17c541b5f2258_47294623.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/carmen-van-huss-murder-case.html.