Chanel's lawsuit against The RealReal is a fight over who gets to declare a luxury item authentic.
In 2018 Chanel found seven allegedly fake Chanel bags sold on The RealReal and sued, accusing it of trademark infringement, counterfeiting, false advertising and unfair competition. Chanel argued that only Chanel itself can know what is genuine Chanel, and sought monetary damages plus an end to The RealReal selling anything with Chanel on it.
Answered around 14:46Fashion lawyer Julie Zerbo says Chanel alleged, first, that The RealReal sold counterfeit bags; second, that using Chanel's trademarked logo on its site confused customers and implied a relationship between the companies; and third, that if some bags were fake, the claim of 100% the real thing was false advertising.
Answered around 15:57In March 2020 the judge did not fully dismiss the case. He ruled The RealReal can use the Chanel trademark within reason when selling Chanel products, and the first sale doctrine protects reselling. But if Chanel proves the seven bags are counterfeit, the claim of 100% the real thing would be literally false.
Answered around 19:37Graham Wetzbarger, The RealReal's first chief authenticator from 2013, breaks it into four pillars: the materials used, the construction techniques and how it is put together, the hardware components, and the brand identifiers. He checks materials by touch and even smell, since fakes often smell of plastic and glue.
Answered around 8:11Since 1984 Chanel bags carry a discreet serial number under a small leather tab. Graham looks less at the numbers than how they look: font, placement, style and layout are always perfect when genuine and hardly ever when counterfeit. Genuine labels have small flecks of glitter; fakes often lack it or use chunky craft glitter.
Answered around 11:22No. Only people inside the house of Chanel have access to its serial number database, and Chanel does not share it with the public. Graham jokes that if he called headquarters they would say no, which is why he developed the four pillars of authentication instead of simply looking numbers up.
Answered around 12:46After the preliminary ruling, The RealReal filed an antitrust counterclaim, calling the case a Trojan horse to smother the resale market. It alleges Chanel pushed landlords to deny it leases near Chanel stores, got Neiman Marcus and Saks to end consignment programs with it, and got Women's Wear Daily not to run its ads.
Answered around 20:51A red mini Chanel top-handle bag similar to one in the Soho window was listed at $6,600 new. On The RealReal an almost identical bag went for $5,000, and others for about $3,200, about $2,000, and one for $1,325. Graham estimates his own mini flap would sell for about $2,000 there.
Answered around 2:35Responses range from hostile to friendly. Balenciaga, Burberry and Stella McCartney partnered with resellers like The RealReal; Gucci's parent bought a 5% stake in Vestiaire Collection; Rolex certifies and buys back old watches; Cartier and Prada in Europe back digital product passports. Others file lawsuits or send letters threatening them.
Answered around 23:03The case is still underway eight years after it began, and Julie Zerbo says it might even go to trial. Chanel says it is just policing its trademark rights, while Zerbo argues the resale market is now too big and robust to smother.
Answered around 22:44“No, I had sticker shock. I was like, what have I done?”
“eBay is fraught with fakes.”
“You can't run a business where consumers can't trust what they're buying.”
“They are hardly ever perfect when counterfeit.”
“your expert authenticators are not experts at authenticating our products.”
“And the RealReal's position is that is just flat out wrong.”
“Chanel Bag Price Guess.” https://npr.simplecastaudio.com/43b5acee-463e-4612-95ad-d2596d9dd337/episodes/a5a22e7a-4cac-46c1-b29b-d5dbebba9027/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_12c58c0509a5c97de42e7533d9053267_24619126.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/chanel-bag-price-guess.html.