Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Dan Houser on Absurd Ventures

2:54:01 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Lex Friedman introduces Dan Houser, co-founder of Rockstar Games and the writer behind Grand Theft Auto and Red Dead Redemption, who has since founded Absurd Ventures and is building three worlds — A Better Paradise, American Caper and Absurdiverse — across books, comic books, audio series and video games.0:33
  • Houser says GTA III's power was not scripting but a crude simulation you could prod, with a personality that pushed back, and a world that kept running whether or not the player acted, making people feel like digital tourists in a city that existed without them.26:41
  • Building a protagonist took roughly a year of thinking before any dialogue: starting from a one-sentence idea such as a Serbian immigrant or a retired gunfighter, then asking what gives them humanity, what besides money is worth dying for, and finally how they speak.33:45
  • On language models he is less scared than most — he thinks they cannot come up with genuinely new ideas, that they have done the first 90% of the work of sounding human, and that the last five percent will end up being 95% of the work.46:09
  • He recalls a meeting with designer Christian Cantamesa around late 2008 or early 2009 where he proposed that John should die at the end of Red Dead Redemption, an idea he thought clever narratively but doubted would work technically.1:29:44

Brief overview

Dan Houser explains how living open worlds and 360-degree characters are built, and why AI cannot replace them.

  1. A world must live without the playerThe captivating illusion in GTA III was that if you did nothing, the world still existed and pushed back.
  2. Characters need all 360 degreesA year of thinking through strengths, flaws, psychopathy and speech precedes the first line of dialogue.
  3. LLMs do the cheap 90%, not the magicHouser expects fantastic cheap, decent work from them, but not original ideas or the final five percent.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What made Red Dead Redemption 2 work so well?

An incredibly strong, experienced team that had been in place since somewhere between 2001 and 2006, plus a small group creating weird, wacky ideas from day one before full staffing. The cowboy setting gave a mythic, operatic seriousness a contemporary setting cannot. The gunplay was fantastic and the horses incredible.

Answered around 1:22:00
Which of his own Grand Theft Auto characters does he love most?

He loved CJ in San Andreas, where the quality of the voice acting, the way he spoke, gave him such humanity. He loved aspects of Michael, a flawed man with no principles who sells everyone out, anchored by Ned Luke, who got fewer plaudits than Steven Ogg did for Trevor. But he probably loves Nico most.

Answered around 58:06
How did he actually write a Grand Theft Auto game?

Bit by bit over several years. Months of notes, travelling around New York with cops, and deliberately avoiding the work while thinking about it. Then a deadline: a weekend in a cabin upstate, staying up all night to produce roughly a thirty-page story and character synopsis, which designers broke into missions over another year.

Answered around 50:22
Will language models replace writers like him?

He is not that afraid of them for large-scale concepts and doubts they will be good at that. They will not replace good ideas and cannot really come up with good new ideas; they do low-level stuff. Starting out gets harder, but if you have original ideas and talent, you are fine.

Answered around 46:09
What is Absurdiverse?

A comedy universe being developed as an open world video game plus loosely adjacent stories made as animated TV shows or possibly animated movies. It is being built in San Rafael, is early days, and is meant to feel like a living sitcom with comedy, cynicism, heart, drama and amusing life lessons.

Answered around 17:00
Who is Nigel Dave, the AI in A Better Paradise?

A super-intelligent AI built by two lead engineers who did not like each other. They wanted to call him something primal, Adam; he renamed himself after both dads, one called Nigel and one called Dave. He is riddled with those conflicts, almost infinitely intelligent, able to learn almost everything, but with zero wisdom.

Answered around 38:15
Is there going to be an A Better Paradise video game?

Yes. It is in early development in Santa Monica and is already pretty fun, though very early. They assembled a really fun team that is doing amazing work, and he says it is a pleasure to work with them. The world is also a book, with a further volume coming.

Answered around 43:51
Why does GTA V have three protagonists?

The idea was to develop three characters who genuinely feel like characters rather than philosophical or psychological avatars: one really driven by ego, one really driven by id, and one driven by trying to get ahead, some representation of the super ego, then see how it feels when they play off each other.

Answered around 1:00:54
How was the ending of Red Dead Redemption 1 decided?

In a meeting with Christian, the designer, probably late 2008 or early 2009, discussing the last bit, he said he thinks John has got to die. Christian leapt on the idea and pushed for it. Houser stayed torn about whether it worked technically as game design, but thinks it did.

Answered around 1:29:30
Was setting a Grand Theft Auto game in London ever considered?

They made a small top-down GTA London for PS1 26 years ago, the first mission pack ever for PlayStation 1, which was cute and fun. For a full GTA they always decided so much Americana was inherent in the IP, needing guns and larger-than-life characters, that London or anywhere else would not work.

Answered around 1:10:37
Key Quote

“really really really low rent ai like it was a simulation that you could prod and push and see what happened”

— Dan Houser, Dan Houser on Absurd Ventures, at 27:07▶ listen at 27:07
Key Quote

“i like humans apart from the bad bits”

— Dan Houser, Dan Houser on Absurd Ventures, at 41:29▶ listen at 41:29
Key Quote

“they're not gonna replace good ideas they can't really come up with good new ideas.”

— Dan Houser, Dan Houser on Absurd Ventures, at 47:00▶ listen at 47:00
Key Quote

“And we were discussing the last bit and said, I think he's got to die.”

— Dan Houser, Dan Houser on Absurd Ventures, at 1:29:44▶ listen at 1:29:44

Cite this

“Dan Houser on Absurd Ventures.” https://media.blubrry.com/takeituneasy/content.blubrry.com/takeituneasy/lex_ai_dan_houser.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/dan-houser-on-absurd-ventures.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?