Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Dire Wolf De-Extinction Update

1:27:04 recording · AUTO · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Nels Elde takes the dire wolf de-extinction headlines apart using the one thing on the record, a Colossal Biosciences preprint on the ancestry and evolution of the extinct dire wolf, with Beth Shapiro as senior author and George R.R. Martin among the authors.8:50
  • What Colossal actually did was make 20 genetic changes to 14 genes in the gray wolf genome, using endothelial progenitor cells from gray wolf blood rather than tissue, which Nels calls the real technical advance since Dolly the sheep.23:46
  • Roughly 45 engineered ova were used per animal, embryos were carried by hound-mix surrogates and delivered by C-section, giving Romulus and Remus on October 1st, 2024 and the female Khaleesi on January 30th, all on a 2,000-acre private preserve in an undisclosed US location.28:59
  • Against the gray wolf template the two ancient genomes, one about 13,000 years old from a Cincinnati Museum Center tooth and one about 72,000 years old from an Idaho Museum of Natural History skull, show nearly 15 million differences, so 20 edits do not make a dire wolf.52:11
  • Nels closes on the criticism: paleoecologists Nick Rawlence and Michael Knapp note the pups would have to function in an ecosystem that no longer exists, and the de-extinction story is being used politically while the Endangered Species Act is weakened and NIH indirect costs are cut to 15%.1:02:55

Brief overview

Colossal's "dire wolves" are gray wolves with 20 edits, not a de-extinct species.

  1. Twenty edits, not a restored genomeThe gray wolf and dire wolf genomes differ by almost 15 million changes; Colossal made 20 in 14 genes.
  2. The real advance is blood-cell cloningEndothelial progenitor cells from a blood draw replace invasive tissue sampling used since Dolly, which matters for livestock and endangered species.
  3. De-extinction PR is cover for weaker protectionThe Interior Department embraced the story while habitat destruction is being reclassified as not harming endangered species.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What did Colossal actually do to create the dire wolf pups?

They made 20 genetic changes to 14 genes in the gray wolf genome. They took gray wolf blood cells, edited them, transferred the edited nuclei into denucleated donor eggs, and the resulting embryos were carried to term by large surrogate dogs rather than by wolves.

Answered around 23:46
Is the result genuinely a dire wolf?

No. Measured against the gray wolf genome the team counted almost 15 million differences: 13.5 million single nucleotide variants, nearly 400,000 insertions and more than half a million deletions. Colossal changed 20 of them across 14 genes, so this is a genetically modified gray wolf.

Answered around 52:11
How many pups were born, and what are they called?

Three. Roughly 45 engineered ova went into each ultimate wolf, and embryos were placed in two surrogate hound mixes chosen mainly for health and size. Romulus and Remus, both males, were born October 1st, 2024, and Khaleesi, a female, came from a second clutch around January 30th.

Answered around 28:36
Was ancient dire wolf DNA spliced into the gray wolf genome?

No ancient dire wolf DNA was spliced in; this isn't Jurassic Park. They used the mutations they were able to sequence and annotate from the dire wolf genomes as a guide, then made the edits themselves, probably with a CRISPR-Cas9 system and a guide RNA carrying the changes.

Answered around 26:16
What is the biggest genuine technical advance in this work?

Starting from blood. They collected endothelial progenitor cells from gray wolf blood, cells that would otherwise line blood vessels, and reprogrammed them. Cloning Dolly the sheep 30 years ago needed more invasive tissue sampling, so a simple blood sample lowers the barrier for cloning other animals.

Answered around 24:51
Where did the dire wolf DNA samples come from?

Two museum specimens: an incisor tooth from the Cincinnati Museum Center, the younger sample at about 13,000 years old, and a piece of skull from the Idaho Museum of Natural History. The tooth gave almost 3 billion reads and about 3.5x coverage, the skull over 33 billion reads and almost 13x.

Answered around 40:27
What are dire wolves most closely related to?

Geneticists previously suggested the dire wolf was closest to animals like African jackals. This analysis argues instead that two-thirds of the genome comes mainly from gray wolf, coyote and the dhole, the red wolf found in Southeast Asia, which is why gray wolf made sense as the template.

Answered around 35:08
Why did the dire wolf go extinct in the first place?

The best idea is that much of its prey went first: the megafauna, the large prey species, went extinct before the dire wolf. Gray wolves then moved into a lot of those niches and were able to out-compete the dire wolves, so restoring the animal would also mean restoring the megafauna.

Answered around 1:03:33
What do scientists say is wrong with calling this de-extinction?

Paleoecologist Nick Rawlence and ecologist Michael Knapp argue the pups would have to function like dire wolves in an ecosystem that no longer exists, and nobody is teaching them to behave like one. They live a wolf resort lifestyle on a preserve, fed a nutrient-rich diet, not hunting.

Answered around 1:02:26
How does this connect to the Endangered Species Act?

Conservationists find the Interior Secretary's enthusiasm unreassuring, because the administration is at the same time trying to redefine part of the Endangered Species Act so that destroying protected habitat no longer counts as harm under the proposed rule changes.

Answered around 1:06:52
Key Quote

“Or should we let evolution stay where it was?”

— Vincent, Dire Wolf De-Extinction Update, at 16:38▶ listen at 16:38
Key Quote

“And so this is a genetically modified gray wolf that we're looking at.”

— Nels, Dire Wolf De-Extinction Update, at 17:33▶ listen at 17:33
Key Quote

“So no ancient dire wolf DNA was actually spliced into the gray wolf genome.”

— Nels, Dire Wolf De-Extinction Update, at 26:16▶ listen at 26:16
Key Quote

“Who's going to teach these pups to behave like a dire wolf.”

— Nels, Dire Wolf De-Extinction Update, at 1:02:55▶ listen at 1:02:55

Cite this

“Dire Wolf De-Extinction Update.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twievo/TWiEVO113.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/dire-wolf-de-extinction-update.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?