Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Don Lincoln on Physics and Discovery

3:01:52 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Don Lincoln tells the history of physics as a history of unifications, starting around 1650 when celestial gravity and terrestrial gravity were still two separate things until Newton saw the moon as falling and missing the Earth.10:34
  • In the 1860s James Clerk Maxwell gathered fifty years of experiments into the laws of electromagnetism, showing that a lightning bolt and a refrigerator magnet are the same thing, and that the waves the equations predict travel at the speed of light.13:26
  • In 1967 Sheldon Glashow, Abdus Salam and Steven Weinberg unified electromagnetism and the weak nuclear force into the electroweak force, with the 1964 Higgs field explaining why the photon is massless while the W and Z particles are heavy and the weak force is short-range.43:22
  • Lincoln describes hunting the Higgs at Fermilab's Tevatron, where two days before CERN's July 4th, 2012 announcement his team could only say the Higgs must lie between about 120 and 145, while the LHC had ten times the collisions per second and three and a half times the energy.1:10:16
  • On a theory of everything he is pessimistic, since the unification scale is a quadrillion times higher than today's accelerators, and argues that practical progress means chasing what we cannot explain now, such as dark matter, dark energy and whatever is smaller than quarks.1:34:13

Brief overview

Physics advances by unification, and Don Lincoln argues the theory of everything remains centuries of measurement away.

  1. Unification is the engine of physicsGravity, then electromagnetism, then the electroweak force: each step showed two phenomena were one.
  2. An idea without a measurement is worthlessLincoln likes the vibrating-string concept but will not believe it until an experiment validates it.
  3. The theory of everything is very far offThe unification scale is a quadrillion times above today's accelerators, which gain a factor of seven every twenty years.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What is the Higgs field and how does it give particles mass?

A field was postulated, distinct from the electroweak field, that permeates all of space. Some particles carry what you could call a Higgs charge and interact with it, and those get mass; the ones that do not interact, like the photon, stay massless. The Higgs boson is that field's vibration.

Answered around 46:09
Who unified electromagnetism and the weak nuclear force, and in what year?

In 1964 three groups, six individuals, wrote the papers on the Higgs field, but the unification itself came in 1967, when Sheldon Glashow, Abdus Salam and Steven Weinberg showed that electromagnetism and the weak nuclear force merge at high energies into a single electroweak force.

Answered around 43:10
When did particles in the universe first get mass?

At very high energies the strength of the Higgs field is zero, so nothing has mass and the weak force particles travel at the speed of light like the photon. As the universe cooled after the Big Bang, at 10 to the minus 12 seconds the Higgs field turned on and particles got mass.

Answered around 50:14
Why is the Higgs boson called the God particle?

The name comes from a book by Leon Lederman, who ran Fermilab. In the book he jokes it should be the goddamn particle, because it caused so much trouble to find. Lincoln, who talked with him, says the publisher chose God particle to sell more copies, and reporters picked it up.

Answered around 1:18:49
How far away is a theory of everything?

A very long time, is the prediction. It took 200 years to go from unifying gravity to unifying electromagnetism, and 100 more to the electroweak force. The unification scale is of order 10 to the 15, a quadrillion times higher than today's accelerators, which gain a factor of seven every 20 years.

Answered around 1:23:52
Why does Don Lincoln doubt superstring theory?

Not because people are not smart, but because something new is going to happen in between. From chemistry you would never have predicted nuclear physics; people calculated the sun should be only 10 million years old. Predicting a quadrillion times beyond what we can measure is, he says, the pinnacle of arrogance.

Answered around 1:34:57
How does the LHC choose which collisions to record?

Fast electronics called triggers take the 40 million possible pictures per second and flag about a hundred thousand with interesting configurations. Those pass to commercial processors running quick, optimised analysis code, which accept about a thousand collisions per second. Those are recorded and handed to graduate students to pick through.

Answered around 1:08:50
How much more powerful is the LHC than Fermilab's Tevatron?

About seven times more energy per collision and about 100 times more collisions per second. The 1995 top quark discovery paper Lincoln co-authored had 38 candidates, roughly half of them background, after six months to a year of collecting data. At the LHC they make a top quark every second.

Answered around 1:01:52
How do experiments show the speed of light is the same for everyone?

Particle physicists collide two things and surround the collision point with a detector. Some subatomic particles decay into light, and that light arrives at the speed of light. When the parent particle is itself coming out at 95 or 97 percent of light speed, the photons still travel at the same speed.

Answered around 28:02
What did Newton unify with his law of universal gravity?

Around 1650 there were two things: celestial gravity, the stars and planets marching across the sky, and terrestrial gravity, what happens when you trip and fall. Newton thought maybe the moon is falling but missing the Earth, and realised the two were one and the same. That is why the law is universal.

Answered around 10:34
Key Quote

“So forgetting all of the mathematical symbols, you have electricity side equals a magnetism side, electricity equals magnetism.”

— Don Lincoln, Don Lincoln on Physics and Discovery, at 13:53▶ listen at 13:53
Key Quote

“Society has to figure out how we wish to apply that or not apply that.”

— Don Lincoln, Don Lincoln on Physics and Discovery, at 22:47▶ listen at 22:47
Key Quote

“Just to take a small tangent, how weird is it in the full ranking of weirdness that is physics?”

— Lex Friedman, Don Lincoln on Physics and Discovery, at 29:46▶ listen at 29:46
Key Quote

“So even if you think superstrings is true, you shouldn't believe it because it hasn't been tested.”

— Don Lincoln, Don Lincoln on Physics and Discovery, at 1:26:06▶ listen at 1:26:06

Cite this

“Don Lincoln on Physics and Discovery.” https://media.blubrry.com/takeituneasy/ins.blubrry.com/takeituneasy/lex_ai_don_lincoln.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/don-lincoln-on-physics-and-discovery.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?