Journalist Karen Howe argues AI companies are empires, and that collective action can break them.
She draws four parallels with empires of old: they lay claim to resources not their own, like personal data and creators' intellectual property; they exploit huge amounts of labor; they monopolize knowledge production by funding most AI research; and they justify their actions as a moral, civilizing mission that promises utopia.
Answered around 12:42Through the outsourcing firm Sama, Alex Cairo and colleagues labeled some of the internet's worst text, including violence and child abuse, to train a content moderation filter for OpenAI's GPT models. They were paid between $1.46 and $3.74 an hour, and Alex describes nightmares and fear of people afterwards.
Answered around 10:28Between 2019 and 2023 OpenAI scaled its GPT models over 10,000 times in data and compute. To do it, Howe found, it lowered data quality standards: GPT-2 used curated articles, while by GPT-4 it was pirating books and transcribing YouTube videos against YouTube's terms of service.
Answered around 17:11Scaling compute drives mineral extraction, energy and fresh water use, utility price hikes and grid strain. A UN report found four leading companies raised emissions 150% since 2020, and Bloomberg found two-thirds of data centers go into water-stressed areas, including in Canada. Amazon sought a 48% water increase in drought-hit northern Spain.
Answered around 36:26Howe says no. Research synthesized by Sarah Hooker, formerly chief scientist at Cohere, shows ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini capabilities can be built with far fewer resources, and DeepSeek and other open source models have done so at a fraction of the cost. She argues scaling costs innovation rather than bringing it.
Answered around 38:58Large generative models are the rockets: rarely fit for purpose. Bicycles are small, task-specific systems for well-scoped computational problems. Her example is DeepMind's AlphaFold, which predicts protein folding from amino acid sequences, trains on curated data instead of the internet, needs no content moderation, and won the 2024 Nobel Prize for Chemistry.
Answered around 44:34In 2019 the activist group Mosaicat found Google planned a data center in Cerritos that could use more fresh water than residents during a mega drought. By knocking on doors and educating the community and government, they stalled it for five years; Google agreed not to use fresh water, and Chile created a consultation roundtable.
Answered around 46:48The New Zealand Te Reo Maori radio station scoped a small speech recognition tool to transcribe its archive for language learners. It asked the community for consent first, explained what data it needed and how it would be protected, gathered enough donated data within days, and kept asking the community whether the tool met their needs.
Answered around 49:16Canada's AI minister told Sam Altman OpenAI must report threats directly to the RCMP, not just the FBI, and OpenAI agreed to establish direct contact with an RCMP unit and include Canadian experts in law and mental health. Howe says this adds surveillance without changing how the technology is designed.
Answered around 21:30Howe doubts it. New York Times reporting showed Anthropic had already greenlit one lawful mechanism for surveilling Americans, and CEO Dario Amodei told CBS the company had no problem in principle with fully autonomous weapons and had offered to build them; it only objected to using the current version.
Answered around 31:44“I really want these companies to be held accountable.”
“Oh, my mental state was very bad.”
“Even I'll tell my brother, okay, just come here, sit with me like for five hours before I go to sleep.”
“So I would actually argue that the scaling approach is not bringing us innovation, it's costing us innovation.”
“But history has always shown us, when people rise, empires fall.”
“People should fight like hell to make sure that's not taken away.”
“Empire of AI.” https://26133.mc.tritondigital.com:443/CBC_IDEAS_P/media-session/ac610270-e0b9-4762-bf76-531b6befa986/ideas/ideas-4PDNjyEb-20260325.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/empire-of-ai.html.