Aaron Manke's book Exhumed argues the New England vampire panic was fear and logic, not barbarism.
Manke tells Mercy Brown's story at the very beginning, in the error-filled form people usually meet it. The final 20 percent of the book returns to her, while the first 80 percent gathers the other stories he collected while making Lore, the ones explaining why her post-death treatment seemed acceptable.
Answered around 5:02They were surrounded by disease, especially tuberculosis in the late 19th century. Scientists in Europe had identified its cause shortly before Mercy's mother died in the early 1880s, but that news never reached their farming village outside Newport, Rhode Island. An invisible thing robbing loved ones sounded exactly like a vampire.
Answered around 7:32Hattie was the only Brown sibling to survive, living until 1954. Edwin died, then Jenny and 25-year-old Annie in 1895, and youngest sister Myra in 1899, all of consumption. Hattie knew her mother and sisters had been exhumed, and lived to see I Love Lucy, The Ed Sullivan Show and American Bandstand premiere.
Answered around 48:17A tool of folklore built from a human hand, often one cut from a thief. It was drained of blood, dried and pickled, then either fitted with wicks or dipped in wax so the fingers burn. A thief carrying one kept a household asleep; hung at home, it warded off evil.
Answered around 15:52It rests on the idea that like is connected to like, and that things which touched something carry its power. People say walnuts are good for your brain because an opened walnut resembles one; herbs named bloodwort and similar were named after body parts they supposedly treated. God wrote purpose into appearance.
Answered around 16:13Also called trial by blood, it belonged to a family of ordeals rooted in Christian theology. Suspects were brought to touch a murder victim; if the killer touched it, a sewn-up wound would bleed fresh or the flesh would bruise, never for the innocent. Results were used in court.
Answered around 25:48Blood was believed to be the connective tissue gluing the soul to the body, which gave it special power. That is why epilepsy recurs in the book: for roughly 2,000 years a seizure was read as soul and body separating, the person quasi-dead, needing fresh blood to bind them again.
Answered around 28:43In early Serbian folklore the likely revenants were alcoholics, the irreligious, the social outcasts who did bad things. Such people were not buried in a shroud and coffin at proper depth but thrown in wrapped in cloth, so they decomposed differently. Opened graves then showed bodies doing something unusual.
Answered around 31:14Folklore comes from fear, and much of the United States was settled in relative safety. New England in the early 1600s sat on the edge of the known world. Settlers fighting Native Americans in what is now Maine fled back to Salem wounded and grieving; mixed faiths and cultures compounded it.
Answered around 44:08He wanted to be a novelist and self-published thrillers woven with New England folklore, collecting far more real stories than he could use. To grow an email list of about 60 people he planned a free PDF, judged it unreadable on tiny phones, recorded it instead, and a friend said: podcast.
Answered around 33:22“It sounds barbaric, but when you actually dig into it, it's really human.”
“So all you need is a handful of moments where it seems to have worked for people to say, see?”
“Well, blood meant something to people in previous eras.”
“I hope we always are a very hopeful species.”
“Exhumed: The Mercy Brown Story.” https://stitcher.simplecastaudio.com/d4d5c1a0-121c-450d-8aed-1ebd2f4dddf0/episodes/8386c3e1-8743-4f23-94bf-3e6c7af2905d/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_1379aa4311a9ab996deb07635facb581_96892414.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/exhumed-the-mercy-brown-story.html.