Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Farming Automation and Weed Control Solutions

19:43 recording · AUTO · 3 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • In part two of this AusVeg Veglog episode, Campbell Cooney turns from autonomous harvesting to weed control, focusing on two Western Growers Association projects: the Laser Weeder from Carbon Robotics and the Eco-Robotics spot sprayer.1:57
  • Ben Pallone says Braga Fresh spent an average of $900 an acre on hand weeding before laser weeding and got down to $500 an acre after Carbon Robotics, a $300 an acre saving, and moved 22 hand weeders into harvest crews where they earn more.3:17
  • For conventional onions the economics differ: an Eco-Robotics machine at $300,000 to 320k US pays itself off fast by cutting broadcast herbicide by 80 to 90%, and Eco has put over 300 machines into the US since its Fira USA debut in 2023.5:00
  • Walt Dufflock describes chemistry vanishing faster than alternatives arrive — the EPA pulled Dactyl with no grandfather clause, ordering growers to ship stock back under stiff penalties, despite congressional language requiring a comparable product on efficacy and economics first.8:40
  • Pallone argues Australia is the better test bed — expensive, scarce and variable labour plus European-style bulk cut-and-pack harvesting that suits automation — which is why WGA has partnered with Hort Innovation and QDPI on the VegMec project, with Walt Dufflock targeting a billion dollars of automation revenue by 2030 and $5 billion as the level that takes 20 to 25% of labour off the table.10:58

Brief overview

Weeding robots already cut grower costs sharply, and disappearing chemistry plus Australia's labour gap will accelerate adoption.

  1. Laser weeding nearly halved one grower's weeding billBraga Fresh went from $900 an acre for hand weeding to $500 an acre after Carbon Robotics, and redeployed 22 workers to harvest crews.
  2. No silver bullet — different machines, different value propositionsCarbon and Eco-Robotics both weed, but for conventional onions the case is herbicide reduction of 80 to 90% on a $300,000 machine, not laser precision.
  3. Automation capital framed as rural economic infrastructureWalt Dufflock argues $5 billion in automation revenue would create 250,000 people years of work over a 10-year window and beat mining and timber on every job metric.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
How much did laser weeding save Braga Fresh on hand weeding costs?

Before using Carbon Robotics' laser weeder, Braga Fresh spent an average of $900 an acre on hand weeding labour; afterwards it got down to $500 an acre. The case study also says it moved 22 hand weeders into a harvest crew, where they earn more and no longer weed on their hands and knees.

Answered around 3:17
Why do growers of high-density salad crops rely so heavily on hand weeding?

Crops like onions, salads, arugula and spinach are grown at high density and harvested mechanically with a bandsaw machine that cuts everything onto a conveyor. Growers are penalised if weeds and 'trash' end up in the salad mix, so they always send hand labour out to pull weeds on their hands and knees.

Answered around 2:29
How quickly can an Ecorobotics precision sprayer pay for itself?

Ben Pallone says the machine costs about $300,000 to $320,000 US and can cut herbicide use by 80 to 90% compared with broadcast application. For crops normally broadcast-sprayed, the herbicide reduction pays the machine off very quickly. Ecorobotics has over 300 machines in the US since debuting at Fira USA in 2023.

Answered around 5:00
How are Ecorobotics and Nika Robotics competing on price?

With Ecorobotics a grower buys the machine for about $300K and pays a monthly software-as-a-service fee on top. Nika Robotics offers similar technology as a one-time purchase that includes lettuce and onions, charging only when growers add other crops. Pallone says this competition is driving cost competitiveness and hopes it spreads to UVC light and laser weeding.

Answered around 14:46
What was unusual about the EPA's ban on the herbicide Dactyl?

Previously a banned product had a grandfather clause letting growers use up existing inventory. For Dactyl, a pre-emergent herbicide, the EPA said it was gone immediately and growers had to send stock in their sheds back to the manufacturer. Stiff fines applied to anyone caught shipping it elsewhere, such as to an international buyer.

Answered around 8:22
Wasn't a replacement product required before Dactyl could be banned?

Walt Dufflock says US congressional language meant a product should not be banned until a comparable product in efficacy and economics was available at scale. Nothing came close to Dactyl's results on either measure, but the ban went ahead anyway, which he describes as going past the science to political science.

Answered around 9:18
What alternatives are growers using to reduce chemical use?

Dufflock lists biological alternatives to pesticides and herbicides, genetics that provide resistance, regenerative agriculture keeping soil healthy, precision spraying such as Ecorobotics and Verdant, and new UV lighting technology from groups like Trick Robotics and Saga. Cutting input use by 80 to 90% also saves money on buying the chemistry itself.

Answered around 6:43
Why could Australia be a better test bed for automated harvesting than the US?

Pallone splits labour into cost, availability and quality; the US mainly has a cost problem, while Australia faces all three. Australia also harvests European-style, bulk cutting into bins and packing in a shed or cool room, which suits automation better than US in-field cutting, packing and bagging. QDPI can validate the technology for growers.

Answered around 10:52
When do the Western Growers team expect automated harvesting to take off?

Ben Pallone guesses that within six to eight years there will be a lot of automated harvesting going, or at least early adoption. Today he sees weeding and precision spraying robots such as Verdant, Ecorobotics and Nika Robotics already facing strong market competition, with cost competition in harvesting likely coming some years later.

Answered around 14:19
What would $5 billion in agricultural automation revenue deliver?

Dufflock says there is a clear line of sight to $1 billion in automation revenue by 2030. At $5 billion, 20 to 25% of labour would be automated, creating about $3 billion of opportunities in systems integration, data analytics and manufacturing, plus AI, and 250,000 people-years of work over a 10-year window.

Answered around 16:03
Key Quote

“They said, Dactyl is gone. It's out of your toolkit growers and you can no longer use the rest of it in your shed.”

— Walt Dufflock, Farming Automation and Weed Control Solutions, at 8:40
Key Quote

“Well, hopefully in 10 years, I won't have a job.”

— Ben Pallone, Farming Automation and Weed Control Solutions, at 14:01
Key Quote

“But as Ben and I say, well, that just means we've got 75 percent left to do.”

— Walt Dufflock, Farming Automation and Weed Control Solutions, at 18:50

Cite this

“Farming Automation and Weed Control Solutions.” https://www.buzzsprout.com/2234586/episodes/19578574-r-d-part-2-farming-automation-and-technology-a-discussing-with-the-usa-s-western-growers-association. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/farming-automation-and-weed-control-solutions.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?