A Catholic's seven-premise argument for an unmoved mover stalls on one unproven claim: God lacks potency.
He presents seven premises and one conclusion, argued from natural reason alone rather than supernatural revelation. Starting from act and potency, he moves through motion, movers, chains of motion and the impossibility of infinite regress to an unmoved mover that is pure act, which he says matches the classical definition of God.
Potency is a real capacity for something to be other than it is; act is the fulfilment of that potency. His example is a lighter not currently producing a flame but able to. Striking it actualises the flame, going from non-being to being, and that is act.
Motion is something being reduced from potency to actuality, not locomotion. He says not to confuse it with throwing an object or a car moving on the highway. Motion here means going from non-being to being, so the lighter gaining a flame counts even though nothing travels.
Premise five says these chains cannot regress to infinity, so there must be a first mover. His example is a train where each boxcar pulls the one behind it: without an engine at the front, the train never moves at all. Motion likewise needs a first unmoved mover.
Because it is the foundation of the whole chain. If it had potency, something before it would have had to actualise that potency, and that earlier thing would be the first chain instead. Since nothing precedes it, only actuality remains, which is where actus purus, pure act, comes from.
With no potency there is only act, one hundred percent act. Something fully actual has no capacity to be any way other than it is, and he says that can only be met by maximum fulfilment of every possible act: knowledge, goodness, lovingness, and any power ascribed to God.
That anybody could use the argument. She says you can swap the being for the universe, evolution, the Big Bang, the tooth fairy or Harry Styles and the premises stay unchanged. A Muslim, a Hindu or a Buddhist could run it too, so it proves no particular God.
He says it is not, and that she misused the term. God of the gaps fills a gap in scientific knowledge with God, like Greeks saying the sun rises because of God. He argues his reasoning leads directly to a first unmoved mover and its attributes, filling in nothing.
She says everything from trillionths of a second after the expansion is evidenced: the singularity and expansion happened 13.8 billion years ago from density and heat, shown by red shifting and the cosmic microwave background. What came immediately before, she refuses to guess, expecting a natural process.
He says she agrees with his premises but thinks they apply to all worldviews. She accepts that, except for calling the first thing a being, a noun she would swap out. Both accept something without potency precedes the singularity; she calls it a natural process, he calls it God.
“Potency is going to be a real capacity for something to be other than it is.”
“We don't know what happened before God of the Gap, so it must be God.”
“I defined God in the beginning as an act whose purest being, and you just admitted that an act whose purest being exists.”
“First-Time Debate with Atheist.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WxpM81Dqvbs. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/first-time-debate-with-atheist.html.