Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Flu Vaccine Mandate Removed

1:41:43 recording · AUTO · 4 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Rich Condit presents a Washington Post article reporting that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has ended the annual flu vaccine mandate for the U.S. military, billing it as an effort to "restore freedom and strength to our joint force."4:19
  • The panel sets that against George Washington mandating variolation of the Continental Army in 1777 and the 1965 court ruling in United States versus Chadwell, and calls the new policy strictly ideological, noting that until the mid-20th century disease killed more soldiers in every war than enemy action.5:31
  • The first paper, a four-author Nature study by Nolan Kamitaki, David Tang, Stephen McCarroll and Po Ru Lo, screened almost a million samples — 490,000 UK Biobank blood samples plus 12,519 SPARC saliva samples — against 31 common viruses, finding viral DNA rare in blood but abundant in saliva, higher in men, and varying with age, time of day and winter versus summer.12:07
  • Genome-wide association on those loads found 82 loci, with MHC the strongest signal for six of seven viruses, a Duffy-null variant explaining 28% and 48% of African versus European ancestry differences for EBV and HHV-7, and 181 disease associations in which EBV DNA load looks causal for Hodgkin's lymphoma but not for MS or lupus.40:34
  • The second paper, in Nature Microbiology from a largely Qingdao-based team, ties an emerging eye disease (POVAL) in 70 enrolled patients to covert mortality nodavirus from farmed shrimp and krill, with 100% PCR positivity in cases, infection reproduced in mice and cell culture, and the virus detected worldwide, highest in Antarctica at 35%.47:28

Brief overview

TWIV 1317 covers the military flu mandate, the human DNA virome, and a shrimp virus infecting eyes.

  1. Military vaccine mandates go back over two centuriesWashington ordered variolation of the Continental Army in 1777, and a 1965 court refused religious exemption for Marines.
  2. Viral DNA load tracks genes, age, sex and seasonAcross ~900,000 genomes, 82 loci associated with load, MHC dominated, men carried more, and EBV reads rose 1.3-fold in winter.
  3. A shrimp virus is the first aquatic zoonosis causing human diseaseCMNV was found in 100% of POVAL eye-disease patients, with puncture wounds from handling fish and shrimp the highest-risk exposure.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What is POVAL, the new eye disease linked to an aquatic virus?

Persistent ocular hypertension with viral anterior uveitis: recurrent uveitis plus intraocular pressure that does not respond to medical treatment. Of 70 enrolled patients, 82% had more than one uveitis episode and 51% peaked above 45 millimetres of mercury; 62% relapsed during two-year follow-up. High pressure is glaucoma, so vision degrades.

Answered around 55:15
How do people catch the aquatic virus CMNV?

Interviews with the 70 patients found 50% were home-based aquatic animal handlers, 15% ate raw aquatic products and 15% were close contacts of high-risk people. Unprotected processing was the top exposure mode at 54%, eating raw 17%. Puncture wounds from fish or shrimp appendages carried the highest risk; incubation ran 3 to 12 months, averaging six.

Answered around 1:02:59
How often is the virus found in seafood that was tested?

They found virus in 54% of fish, 28% of shrimp, 61% of crabs, 58% of mollusks, 47% of cephalopods and 33% of other species including spoon worms, at loads of 9,000 to 60,000 copies per gram. In situ hybridization confirmed infection in major edible tissues.

Answered around 1:05:56
Can anything reduce the risk for people who handle seafood?

The authors suggest that people who handle dissected aquatic animals daily without adequate protection, or eat raw aquatic animals daily, are at highest risk, and that a simple measure such as wearing gloves during processing and handling could markedly reduce it. The hosts note gloves do nothing about eating it raw.

Answered around 1:16:53
Where in the world has this virus been found?

A survey of 523 aquaculture and wild aquatic animal samples from Asia, the Americas, Europe, Antarctica and Africa found it everywhere. Highest positivity was Antarctica at 35%, then Africa 20%, the Americas 16% and Asia 16%. Of 428 samples with identified origins, 27% of farmed and 32% of wild animals were positive.

Answered around 1:12:18
Does this aquatic virus really infect mammals?

Mice infected intraocularly lost appetite by day two and lost body weight; by day 28 intraocular pressure was 26% higher than controls, IgM and IgG rose, and cornea, iris and retina showed vacuolization with strong virus-positive signals. Human corneal epithelial cells and Vero monkey kidney cells died, with intracellular particles seen by electron microscopy.

Answered around 1:09:22
What changed about flu vaccination for the US military?

Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth declared flu vaccines will no longer be mandated for the military. Under the new policy soldiers may take the vaccine if they believe it is in their best interest, billed as an effort to restore freedom and strength to the joint force, because body, faith and convictions are not negotiable.

Answered around 4:28
Why do service members get vaccines that civilians do not?

They travel to places all over the world where they may be exposed to those microbes, may be in harm's way of things being released, and live in very close quarters in barracks, which makes vaccination more important. Flu lays people low, and until the mid-20th century disease caused far more casualties than enemy action.

Answered around 7:23
How big was the study of viruses in human blood and saliva?

They mined existing whole genome sequencing rather than sequencing anything: 490,000 blood samples in the UK Biobank and 12,519 saliva samples in SPARC, the Simons Foundation autism database, almost a million samples. Reads were aligned against 31 common viruses, 27 DNA viruses and four retroviruses.

Answered around 15:29
Which human genes influence how much viral DNA a person carries?

They found variation at 82 loci associated with viral DNA load in blood, including 45 loci for EBV and three for HHV-6B. For six of the seven viruses, all but HHV-6B, the MHC region held the strongest associations, unsurprising because MHC presents antigens to T cells and is the most variable part of the human genome.

Answered around 31:13
Key Quote

“We are so not surprised.”

— Brianne Barker, Flu Vaccine Mandate Removed, at 32:01▶ listen at 32:01
Key Quote

“Bioinformatics is a good way to make a living.”

— Vincent Racaniello, Flu Vaccine Mandate Removed, at 45:29▶ listen at 45:29
Key Quote

“I would be interested to know if it replicates in cats.”

— Brianne Barker, Flu Vaccine Mandate Removed, at 1:10:08▶ listen at 1:10:08
Key Quote

“They say in the discussion, no virus originating from aquatic animals has been shown to infect humans and directly cause disease up until today.”

— Vincent Racaniello, Flu Vaccine Mandate Removed, at 1:13:54▶ listen at 1:13:54

Cite this

“Flu Vaccine Mandate Removed.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twiv/TWiV1317.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/flu-vaccine-mandate-removed.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?