Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

From Unvaccinated Child to Immunologist

1:05:56 recording · AUTO · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Cindy Leifer opens a special Immune booster recorded 23 July 2025 with Liz Marnick, who went from unvaccinated child to a career in immunology and science communication.0:00
  • Liz explains her mother decided against vaccines when Liz, her first child, was born, and that she was homeschooled on a religious curriculum that taught a literal seventh-day creation, no evolution and nothing about the immune system until she returned to public school in 11th grade.4:03
  • She fell in love with science in a chemistry class, joined a genetics lab studying graft versus host disease as an undergraduate, and finally got vaccinated at a travel clinic right before leaving for graduate school, bringing a friend along because she was nervous.6:08
  • Years later her mother told her the decision traced back to a pediatrician who answered her questions with "you vaccinate your kids because I told you to" and then threw the family out of the practice in the 1980s.14:21
  • After roughly 14 years of conversations, her mother said she could understand why a measles vaccine would be valuable after hearing about immune amnesia, the first positive thing Liz had ever heard her say about a vaccine.46:06

Brief overview

An unvaccinated, homeschooled child became an immunologist who changes minds with empathy, patience and story, not facts.

  1. Relationships opened the door, not data aloneLiz says friendships with people outside her church made her realize you can be a good person and believe differently, which let her question everything she had been taught.
  2. Changing a mind can take fourteen yearsShe counts 14 years of conversations with her mother before hearing a single positive word about a vaccine.
  3. Lead with empathy and curiosityInstead of citing safety data, she asks a worried parent what they have heard and why they are worried, because someone made to feel stupid will not engage.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
When did Liz Marnick first realize she had not been vaccinated?

Not until college. She was raised very religious and homeschooled, in a church where some families vaccinated and some did not; it was her mother's own decision, made when Liz, her first child, was born. As a teenager she simply believed her mother that vaccines were dangerous.

Answered around 3:39
Why did her mother decide not to vaccinate her?

Someone gave her mother a book blaming vaccines for something; neither of them remembers its title. Anxious and a first-time mother, she brought her questions to the pediatrician, who told her you vaccinate your kids because I told you to and would not answer. She left, and the practice threw them out.

Answered around 13:57
How did she go about getting vaccinated as an adult?

It was winter or spring right before she graduated college, ahead of graduate school. Her PCP was an adult doctor who did not stock the vaccines, and there was no catch-up schedule then, so she was sent to the travel clinic at the local academic hospital and sat for hours while they worked out the order. She brought someone to sit with her.

Answered around 8:43
How long did it take to shift her mother's view on vaccines?

Fourteen years, since she moved to Maine to start her PhD, through telling her mother about her own vaccines a year late, vaccinating both children, and enrolling her son in a COVID-19 trial. Only in the last year and a half, after hearing that measles erases prior immune memory, did her mother say a vaccine would be valuable.

Answered around 44:58
How does she talk with parents who are worried about vaccines?

She leads with empathy and curiosity rather than data. Instead of asking why would you do that, the data shows it is safe, which puts up a wall, she says it is hard being a parent right now and asks what they have heard and what worries them, then affirms their identity as a parent.

Answered around 56:05
What is her job now?

Director of science education and outreach at the institution where she did her postdoc, which invited her back when it heard she was on the job market. She reaches K through 12 students in rural Maine, plus undergraduates, graduate students and the public, still collaborates on research, and runs education research studies on her own programs.

Answered around 32:31
What did she research during her PhD in immunology?

She joined an autoimmune lab whose two projects covered IgG antibodies and their placental transfer, and follicular helper T cells with germinal center B cells. Hers traced how CD4 T cells normally differentiate into TFH cells and how that process is altered in mouse models of autoimmune disease, mainly lupus plus rheumatoid arthritis.

Answered around 19:20
Why did she switch from mice to C. elegans?

After about eleven years of mouse work across her undergraduate years and PhD, she chose the educational path over the research track. Mice are not practical at mostly teaching-focused schools, so she switched her model organism to C. elegans, microscopic nematode roundworms found in dirt that have no adaptive immune system but share a surprising amount with humans.

Answered around 23:19
How does a worm remember bacteria without B cells or T cells?

Through germ granules, clusters of RNA and protein sitting on the nucleus that block the nuclear pore complex and filter every RNA passing through. They make small RNAs, a big part of worm immunity: after exposure to a bacterium the worm makes tiny RNA molecules that help destroy it and passes them down to its offspring.

Answered around 26:17
Why should the public care about NIH-funded research on tiny worms?

She compares it to building a house: basic research is the foundation you need before walls and a roof. You cannot better treat autoimmune disease without first understanding how the immune system works, or help neurons that fail to communicate without knowing how neurons talk. Worms carry the same germ granules and proteins we do.

Answered around 41:31
Key Quote

“At the end of the day, my mom thought she was making a decision to protect me.”

— Liz Marnick, From Unvaccinated Child to Immunologist, at 11:09▶ listen at 11:09
Key Quote

“But it took 14 years to get to that point.”

— Liz Marnick, From Unvaccinated Child to Immunologist, at 47:57▶ listen at 47:57
Key Quote

“But I do like to tell people that anytime you can plant a positive seed, we don't know what will happen to that seed.”

— Liz Marnick, From Unvaccinated Child to Immunologist, at 48:06▶ listen at 48:06
Key Quote

“I think part of that is scientists speak a different language.”

— Cindy Leifer, From Unvaccinated Child to Immunologist, at 49:52▶ listen at 49:52

Cite this

“From Unvaccinated Child to Immunologist.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/immune/ImmuneBooster017.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/from-unvaccinated-child-to-immunologist.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?