Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Gene Copy Number Amplification & NIH Funding Crisis

1:26:51 recording · AUTO · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Vincent Racaniello and Nels Elde host Twevo episode 111, live-streamed on February 19th, 2025, with listeners joining from Salt Lake City, Tucson, San Francisco, the UK and Mexico City.0:00
  • Vincent opens on the new administration firing people at NSF and NIH and cutting budgets with no consideration, and Nels upgrades his earlier hurricane analogy from a Category 2 to a Category 4.0:53
  • Nels gives a concrete example of the misinformation around the cuts: a saving announced as $8 billion was really $8 million on one line item already appropriated by Congress, an error by a factor of a thousand.16:53
  • They then turn to an eLife paper from David Gresham's lab at NYU, "Template Switching During DNA Replication as a Prevalent Source of Adaptive Gene Amplification", which limits glutamine in chemostats for 137 generations and watches the GAP1 amino acid permease gene amplify, with LTRs and an ARS origin deleted in different strains.35:20
  • The result is that copy number rises in every strain, to roughly two to six copies, with the replication-based ODIRA mechanism outstripping recombination, new Ty retrotransposons reappearing in about 900 events, and the ARS deletion only delaying the adaptation by about 15 generations.57:28

Brief overview

Reckless federal cuts threaten American science, while new yeast work shows gene amplification always finds a route.

  1. Probation firings hit decades-long federal staffNels explains that "probational status" often just means under one or two years in a current job, so someone at NIH for three decades who was just promoted got swept up in the blanket firings.
  2. Claimed savings overstated by a thousandfoldA cut publicised as $8 billion was actually $8 million on a single programme line item that Congress had already appropriated.
  3. Yeast amplify GAP1 through backup mechanismsRemoving the LTRs or the nearby ARS did not stop amplification: new retrotransposons moved in and a more distant origin took over, costing only about 15 extra generations.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What happened to GAP1 copy number when the LTRs or ARS were deleted?

In every case, copy number variation still happened and GAP1 gained copies. Without the LTRs, new Ty retrotransposons moved through the genome and recreated them. Without the nearby ARS, a more distant replication origin still drove amplification. Yeast found backup mechanisms whether one element, the other, or both were removed.

Answered around 52:55
How quickly did GAP1 amplification arise in the evolving yeast populations?

Around generation 50 was the transition point in all strains, wild type and mutants, when GAP1 went from one copy to two or more. Genomes with extra copies then increased about 15% per generation. Deleting the ARS only delayed this by about 15 generations. By the end, cells carried about two to six copies.

Answered around 56:35
What does the GAP1 gene do, and why would more copies help yeast?

GAP1 encodes an amino acid permease, a transporter moving amino acids from outside the cell to inside. The researchers limited glutamine in the media. With more copies of the transporter, a cell competing against others can bring in more of the scarce glutamine, like having more bridges across the membrane.

Answered around 45:43
Which mechanism produced most of the gene amplifications, replication or recombination?

The replication-based mechanism, ODIRA or origin-dependent inverted repeat amplification, outcompeted recombination and probably accounted for more than half of events. It is diagnosed by triplications in which the middle copy is flipped. Retrotransposons were also highly active, with about 900 events seen across replicates in a month or two.

Answered around 57:37
How was the yeast evolution experiment set up and run?

They used chemostats, automated devices where fresh media flows in and cells are pulled out, keeping population size and nutrients constant. The experiment ran for 137 generations, roughly a month or two, with five to eight replicates per strain because some chemostats fail. Strains were wild type or mutants lacking LTRs, ARS, or both.

Answered around 50:40
How did the researchers use green fluorescent protein to track amplification?

They placed a GFP gene, borrowed from jellyfish, right next to GAP1, so each GAP1 copy increase also increased GFP and cells got greener. An instrument reading green quickly showed when adaptation occurred. However, Vincent notes GAP1 sometimes amplified without GFP, and other amplifications elsewhere also improved glutamine uptake.

Answered around 59:06
What is the gene accordion model of evolution?

The genome expands in copy number, sampling mutations across all the extra genes. If one copy gains a point mutation that improves the protein's quality, the array can collapse back down, keeping that improved copy and paying less cost for a large genome. Nels's lab saw this in poxviruses facing host immune defenses.

Answered around 1:03:57
What is the broader adaptive value of copy number variations?

Most CNVs are sloppy or harmful, but more copies can give an immediate quantity benefit, such as bacteria amplifying an exporter that pumps out antibiotics. Longer term, per Ohno's hypothesis discussed in episode 103, a duplicate can diverge and evolve new functions, as seen in paralog gene families like receptors expressed in different tissues.

Answered around 1:11:44
What would changing NIH funding to block grants to states mean?

After the 15% indirect rate, another Project 2025 idea is block grants to states instead of federal NIH funding. Each of 50 state legislatures or agencies would need to set up its own distribution process, replacing competitive study sections. Nels calls it inefficient; Vincent predicts it will all be favoritism.

Answered around 28:20
Can RNA viruses also undergo copy number variation?

Yes. It depends on the virus; coronaviruses, with large genomes, have more room for it. In RNA viruses it may be more transient, perhaps two copies briefly rather than the 20 copies seen in a poxvirus genome. Vincent adds that coronavirus template jumps during mRNA synthesis are another way to amplify genes.

Answered around 1:10:00
Key Quote

“And just the mismatch between confidence and knowledge here is the most striking I've ever seen in my life.”

— Nels Elde, Gene Copy Number Amplification & NIH Funding Crisis, at 11:00▶ listen at 11:00
Key Quote

“For years, you've been growing on these indirect costs, okay?”

— Vincent Racaniello, Gene Copy Number Amplification & NIH Funding Crisis, at 25:13▶ listen at 25:13
Key Quote

“That's a massive uncontrolled experiment with people who are all confidence, but very little expertise.”

— Nels Elde, Gene Copy Number Amplification & NIH Funding Crisis, at 32:52▶ listen at 32:52
Key Quote

“That means science is stopped.”

— Nels Elde, Gene Copy Number Amplification & NIH Funding Crisis, at 41:35▶ listen at 41:35

Cite this

“Gene Copy Number Amplification & NIH Funding Crisis.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twievo/TWiEVO111.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/gene-copy-number-amplification-nih-funding-crisis.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?