Capping federal grad school loans to force tuition down rests on evidence that is decidedly mixed.
Starting July 1st, the Department of Education will lend most graduate students only about $21,000 a year. If tuition costs more, the department will not lend extra to cover it. More expensive programs like medicine and law school get a higher cap. This replaces the unlimited borrowing allowed since 2006.
Answered around 1:37It comes from a 1987 New York Times op-ed, "Our Greedy Colleges," by Reagan's education secretary William Bennett. He argued increases in federal student aid let colleges blithely raise tuition, confident federal loan subsidies would cushion the increase. Economists dubbed this idea, that more federal aid drives up prices, the Bennett hypothesis.
Answered around 8:37Yes. Economist Jeff Denning of the University of Texas at Austin studied Texas graduate programs after Grad PLUS began in 2006. For every additional dollar students received in loans, graduate schools raised prices by 64 cents, about two-thirds of a dollar. His team calls it a causal relationship, though it covers only Texas.
Answered around 14:19Robert Kelchin of the University of Tennessee, Knoxville, studied business, medical and law schools nationwide and found no evidence of the Bennett hypothesis, with some evidence in favor at for-profit colleges. He says it assumes graduate programs are big profit centers, but fields like medicine are wildly unprofitable to run.
Answered around 14:56Kelchin says it can take a million dollars of resources to produce one medical degree, including labs and student services, so schools run on thin margins. Even if schools raised prices when loans became available, they may not have room to move prices back down. Programs are expensive because they're expensive to offer.
Answered around 16:30According to Corey Turner, the net price of four-year undergraduate programs, what families actually pay after financial aid and scholarships, has been stagnant for roughly 10 years. The sticker price has risen steadily. Graduate school is where net tuition has ballooned, and much of the $1.7 trillion federal loan portfolio is grad debt.
Answered around 4:57Preston Cooper of the American Enterprise Institute says the caps will probably affect only about 30 percent of grad borrowers, since most already borrow within the limits. The aim is to pressure the most expensive schools; a Peer Center analysis found NYU and USC top the list for most affected borrowers.
Answered around 18:42Dominique Baker of the University of Delaware says robust research shows that when you cap aid like student loans without a commensurate grant or scholarship, the number one result is students stop going to college. She expects the same for grad students, who may leave school or turn to private lenders.
Answered around 22:15Maybe not. When federal grad loans became unlimited 20 years ago, borrowers left private loans en masse and the private industry shrank. Now it could be much harder for lower-income borrowers with a short or suboptimal credit history to get a private loan, so some may be unable to borrow at all.
Answered around 23:21Created in Republicans' One Big Beautiful Bill, it evaluates every college program on return on investment for borrowers. If a program's graduates don't end up earning more than a high school graduate who didn't attend college, that program loses access to federal loans entirely, which Corey Turner calls a death sentence.
Answered around 26:13“We want to bring down the cost of education.”
“We've put in caps on programs for graduate students and undergraduate students”
“He called it Our Greedy Colleges.”
“I would say a meaningful increase in the price.”
“It can take a million dollars of resources to produce one medical degree.”
“So I think, you know, going forward, it's important to remember that the new loan limits are still relatively high.”
“Grad School Loan Caps.” https://npr.simplecastaudio.com/43b5acee-463e-4612-95ad-d2596d9dd337/episodes/95999483-ef36-4387-be6a-ef88b29d13d3/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_8a3dd8b91c65b63e0b03560e6a81d1a1_27517255.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/grad-school-loan-caps.html.