Gut-microbiome psychiatry claims stay thin in humans, while guilt beats shame at making people pro-social everywhere.
Sapolsky says the human evidence is weak: studies find microbiomes differ between people with depression, autism, ADHD or schizophrenia and controls, but the measures are qualitative and only correlative, since psychiatric disorders change diet and activity. Genetic-strain findings don't replicate, and probiotic effects mostly vanish once industry-funded studies are removed.
An early 1970s rough estimate claimed about 10 bacterial cells for every human cell, and despite the researcher saying don't quote me, the 10 to 1 ratio spread. A more rigorous 2016 paper showed the ratio is actually more like 1 to 1, which Sapolsky says is still pretty shocking.
The best documented route is the vagal nerve, which has nerve endings throughout the gut and projects to the brainstem. Gut microbiome differences change vagal activity, and in the cleanest subtraction experiment, cutting the vagal nerve in a mouse makes most of the microbiome's effects on brain and behavior disappear.
In germ-free mice raised with essentially no gut microbiome, removing it takes away some of the anxiety behavior, some hormonal features such as glucocorticoid secretion, and some of the pro-inflammation seen in animal models of psychiatric disorder, compared with the same anxiety-prone strain with a normal microbiome.
Americans average about 300 species, Nepalese farmers 500 or 600, and Hadza hunter-gatherers in northern Tanzania 800 to 1,000. Sapolsky blames processed diets, antibiotic abuse, high caesarean rates that stop babies inheriting the mother's bacteria, and extreme sanitation, so findings in Westerners may not generalize.
Guilt is situational and contained: you did a wrong thing, possibly known only to you or God, resembling deontological ethics. Shame is constitutional: you are a rotten human in the eyes of your community, tied to honor and losing face, and it can spread to your family and lineage.
A Nature Human Behaviour study of about 8,000 subjects in 20 countries used economic games such as the dictator game. In every country, regardless of culture type, evoking guilt made people substantially more pro-social afterward, while shame had almost no effect, because a single bad act can be repaired but constitutional rottenness cannot.
Research by Thomas Talhelm links it to farming: the south grows floodplain rice, which demands village-wide cooperation and irrigation systems 100 miles long maintained by 50 villages for a thousand years. The individualistic wheat-growing north is more guilt-based, with higher divorce and invention rates and self-centered sociograms.
A famous 2006 Science paper found Western subjects who recalled something rotten they had done were more likely to wash their hands afterward. A 2015 follow-up showed that under moral disgust, Western guilt-based subjects washed their hands while East Asian shame-based subjects were more likely to wash their faces.
In the West the typical case is an older, often male individual with depression, substance abuse and access to a firearm. In rural China it is a young woman with no mental illness history who, after a shameful community event like her cow trampling a neighbor's crops, swallows pesticides.
“the bourgeoisie are going to regret my carbuncles for the rest of time.”
“You can't reason somebody out of a stance they weren't reasoned into in the first place.”
“If you cut the vagal nerve in a mouse, most of the effects of the gut microbiome on brain and behavior disappear.”
“They've got a whole lot more complex gut microbiome than we do.”
“Guilt is situational. Shame is constitutional.”
“It is hating the sin, but not the sinner.”
“Gut Microbiome; Shame vs Guilt; Your Comments | Robert Sapolsky Father-Offspring Interview.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QTQKMgLxRM8. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/gut-microbiome-shame-vs-guilt-your-comments-robert-sapolsky-.html.