Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Guy Turcotte's Tragedy

50:21 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • On the morning of February 21, 2009, Marguerite drove to her son Guy Turcotte's house in Piémont, about 70 km from Montreal, found it locked with his car outside and called 911.2:28
  • SQ patrolman Patrick Bigrasse broke in and found three-year-old Anne-Sophie with 19 stab wounds and five-year-old Olivier with 27, while their father lay groggy from methanol under a pillow asking to be left to die.4:33
  • Admitted to his own hospital in Saint-Jérôme under his ex-wife's name, Turcotte told nurse Chantal the sentence that would follow him through both trials: he had done it to hurt Isabelle.9:00
  • At the first trial in 2011, defence psychiatrist Dominique Bourget argued that adjustment disorder plus antifreeze intoxication clouded his judgment, and the jury declared him not criminally responsible, sending him to the Philippe Pinel Institute instead of prison.25:41
  • After a Supreme Court ruling on voluntary intoxication killed the antifreeze defence, the 2015 retrial convicted Turcotte of murdering Anne-Sophie and Olivier, with at least 17 years before parole eligibility in 2033.37:22

Brief overview

A Quebec cardiologist killed his two children, was first ruled not criminally responsible, then convicted at retrial.

  1. Voluntary intoxication stopped excusing the crimeThe Bouchard-Lebrun ruling by the Supreme Court made the antifreeze argument useless at the second trial.
  2. Paid experts split the two verdictsDominique Bourget was mandated and paid by Turcotte's own defence, which Isabelle Gaston attacked as a conflict of interest.
  3. The mother's research forced a reckoningIsabelle Gaston filed a thesis-like memoir and a complaint with the Collège des médecins, which issued clearer forensic-expertise rules.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What happened to Guy Turcotte's children in Piemont in February 2009?

Patrolman Patrick Bigras broke a window, went upstairs and found Anne-Sophie, three years old, lying on her bed with 19 stab wounds, and in another room Olivier, five, with 27 more, 46 knife blows in total. Both were dead and resuscitation was hopeless.

Answered around 4:33
What was the defence psychiatrist's explanation for the killings?

Dominique Bourget, mandated and paid by the defence, told the jury Turcotte had an adjustment disorder with anxious and depressive mood, living the separation far worse than most people would, and that evening was intoxicated with methanol from the washer fluid, so his judgment was disturbed: criminal non-responsibility.

Answered around 20:58
What did the jury decide at the first trial in 2011?

After six days of deliberation the jury president rose and declared Guy Turcotte not criminally responsible. He was sent to the Philippe Pinel psychiatric institute rather than prison. Isabelle Gaston, the mother, left in tears, saying adults have no right of life or death over children.

Answered around 25:41
How did the second trial end and what sentence was given?

After ten weeks of trial and six years of judicial battle for the mother, Guy Turcotte was found guilty of the murders of Anne-Sophie and Olivier. The jury condemned him to at least 17 years in prison, and he can only request conditional release from 2033.

Answered around 37:22
What does Turcotte say happened on the night of the killings?

Alone after putting the children to bed before 7pm, he opened his computer and read the emails between his wife and her lover, searched the internet for how to commit suicide, went down to the basement for the washer fluid and drank almost two litres. Then, he told the jury, he decided to bring the children with him.

Answered around 18:21
What did the emergency doctor find when Turcotte reached the hospital?

Dr Marie-Pierre Chartrand, his colleague at the Hotel Dieu of Saint-Jerome, scored him 15 out of 15 on the Glasgow scale: conscious and lucid, only a little slow, like someone who had drunk a few beers. He was vomiting, blood tests showed ingested methanol, he claimed his five-year-old son was ten, and he had been admitted under the name Isabelle Gaston.

Answered around 7:25
What did Turcotte tell the nurse who came to his bedside?

Chantal, a nurse who had worked beside him the previous day and knew him as kind, polite and calm, ran to his bed and took his hand. Hand in hand, Turcotte turned to her and asked her to tell Isabelle a message for him: he did that to piss her off.

Answered around 9:00
What changed in Canadian law between the two trials?

The Supreme Court ruled on Tommy Bouchard-Lebrun, who beat a neighbour while in a mystical delirium after taking ecstasy and amphetamines, and dismissed his appeal. A new jurisprudence was born: you cannot plead mental disorder caused by voluntarily taken substances, unless the disorder existed beforehand. The washer-fluid argument became useless.

Answered around 36:46
Why did Guy Turcotte and Isabelle Gaston separate?

Patricia, a coach at the gym and the wife of their trainer Martin, called Guy Turcotte to tell him her husband and Isabelle were having an affair, and that she had found emails they had been exchanging for months that seriously looked like love. Guy refused to believe it at first.

Answered around 14:52
What did Isabelle Gaston do after the first verdict?

Alongside her half-time work as an emergency physician, she read every manual on forensic psychiatry and, night and day, printed hundreds of pages of psychiatric expertise, court decisions and case law. She filed a thick memoir, like a medical thesis, with the Council of Doctors, and lodged a complaint against psychiatrist Dominique Bourget.

Answered around 30:16
Key Quote

“I will bring them with me.”

— Guy Turcotte, Guy Turcotte's Tragedy, at 19:11▶ listen at 19:11
Key Quote

“I did that to piss her off.”

— Guy Turcotte, Guy Turcotte's Tragedy, at 9:00▶ listen at 9:00
Key Quote

“We cannot ignore the effect of 46 knife blows on the bodies of two little children.”

— Prosecution psychiatrists, Guy Turcotte's Tragedy, at 21:53▶ listen at 21:53
Key Quote

“For me, we're putting a criminal free.”

— Isabelle Gaston, Guy Turcotte's Tragedy, at 29:11▶ listen at 29:11

Cite this

“Guy Turcotte's Tragedy.” https://dcs-cached.megaphone.fm/BABA5686244023.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/guy-turcotte-s-tragedy.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?