Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Hamilton vs Burr Duel

1:17:00 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • The episode opens with Hamilton's farewell letter to his wife Eliza, written exactly a week before his fatal duel with Aaron Burr on the 11th of July 1804.4:00
  • Hamilton, probably born in 1755 on Nevis, rose through talent and Washington's patronage to be the first Treasury Secretary in autumn 1789, leading the Federalists against Jefferson's Democratic Republicans.9:42
  • The personal feud began in 1791 when Burr beat Hamilton's father-in-law Philip Schuyler for the New York Senate seat, and hardened when Hamilton's campaigning helped the House choose Jefferson over Burr after 36 ballots in the 73-73 electoral tie.20:38
  • After Burr's humiliating loss in the 1804 New York governor's race, the Albany Register letter of Dr Charles D. Cooper reporting a "despicable" opinion gave him the pretext to demand an apology Hamilton refused.27:59
  • At Weehawken two shots were fired seconds apart, Burr's ball struck Hamilton above the right hip and lodged in his spine, and he died at two o'clock the following afternoon, the 12th of July, leaving Eliza, seven children and about $50,000 of debt.56:04

Brief overview

Wounded pride and rival ambition drove Burr to kill Hamilton in their 1804 duel.

  1. Honour culture made the duel almost unavoidableHamilton opposed duelling on religious and moral grounds but thought public opinion would require it of him.
  2. Most affairs of honour never reached a shotHamilton had been in at least six affairs of honour before and none had come to the point of pulling the trigger.
  3. What happened on the ledge is still contestedPendleton says Hamilton's gun went off accidentally; Van Ness says Hamilton fired first, and Chernow and Ellis disagree about whether Burr meant to kill.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Why did Aaron Burr challenge Alexander Hamilton to a duel?

Burr was shown the Albany Register of 24 April 1804, printing Dr Charles D. Cooper's letter saying Hamilton called Burr dangerous and had voiced a still more despicable opinion. On 18 June, through William Van Ness, Burr demanded Hamilton avow or disavow the word despicable; Hamilton refused.

Answered around 27:59
What actually happened when the two men fired at Weehawken?

Both seconds and Dr Hosack had turned away, but all agreed that after Pendleton shouted present two shots came within a couple of seconds. Burr was unscathed; Hamilton was hit just above his right hip, the ball ricocheting off a rib, tearing diaphragm and liver, lodging in his spine.

Answered around 56:04
Did Hamilton deliberately throw away his shot?

Hamilton's letter beforehand said he had resolved to throw away his first fire, even reserving his second. Pendleton said Hamilton aimed above Burr's head without firing, and later found a branch shattered twelve feet above Burr. Van Ness said Hamilton fired first and missed, which Dominic finds most plausible.

Answered around 59:17
Why did Hamilton fight a duel he morally opposed?

Days before, in his statement on the impending duel with Aaron Burr, Hamilton wrote that his religious and moral principles were strongly opposed to dueling. But he could not apologise, because he meant what he said about Burr, and had to conform to public prejudice to stay useful in coming crises.

Answered around 38:08
How long did Hamilton survive the wound, and where is he buried?

He was taken to a friend's house in Greenwich Village, asked Bishop Benjamin Moore for communion, and died the following day, 12 July, at two o'clock in the afternoon. Moore said he expired without a struggle and almost without a groan. He was buried in Trinity Churchyard, Lower Manhattan.

Answered around 1:07:13
Why was the duel fought in New Jersey rather than New York?

Dueling was forbidden in both New York and New Jersey, but the New Jersey authorities were much more relaxed about prosecuting duels. The chosen ledge at Weehawken stood about twenty feet above the Hudson, roughly level with West 42nd Street today, and the oarsmen kept their backs turned for deniability.

Answered around 47:55
When did the feud between Hamilton and Burr begin?

It began in 1791, when Burr beat Hamilton's father-in-law, Philip Schuyler, who was running for re-election as senator from New York. From that point there was bad blood, far worse than that between Hamilton and Jefferson, and Hamilton's campaigns against Burr in 1800 and 1804 deepened it.

Answered around 20:38
What happened in the deadlocked 1800 presidential election?

Jefferson and his running mate Burr tied for the presidency on 73 electoral votes each, so the House of Representatives, controlled by Hamilton's Federalists, had to choose. Burr tried to court the Federalists himself; Hamilton told friends to stop Burr at all costs, and after 36 ballots the House chose Jefferson.

Answered around 18:37
What happened to Burr after he killed Hamilton?

Burr fled New York straight away for Georgia, still Vice President, and was charged with murder in both New York and New Jersey, though neither case came to trial. His term ended in 1805; he was tried for treason, not proven, exiled to England, and died in 1836.

Answered around 1:09:11
How did Hamilton's son Philip die in 1801?

In November 1801 Philip Hamilton challenged George Eaker, who had criticised his father. Hamilton advised him to miss on purpose so the duel could be settled peacefully. Both men stood about a minute without firing, then levelled their pistols; Eaker fired, Philip was wounded and died, leaving Hamilton grief-stricken.

Answered around 36:20
Key Quote

“If Hamilton is Marmite, Burr is very much Bovril.”

— Dominic, Hamilton vs Burr Duel, at 21:03▶ listen at 21:03
Key Quote

“So he is the Andy Burnham of post-revolutionary America.”

— Tom, Hamilton vs Burr Duel, at 24:27▶ listen at 24:27
Key Quote

“Yeah, he guns him down like a dog.”

— Tom, Hamilton vs Burr Duel, at 1:02:08▶ listen at 1:02:08
Key Quote

“if I had read Lawrence Stern more and Voltaire less, I should have known that the world was wide enough for Hamilton and me.”

— Dominic, Hamilton vs Burr Duel, at 1:11:46▶ listen at 1:11:46

Cite this

“Hamilton vs Burr Duel.” https://dcs-cached.megaphone.fm/GLT9231431046.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/hamilton-vs-burr-duel.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?