Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Hidden Constraints in Coronavirus Genes

1:38:13 recording · AUTO · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Recording TWEVO 117 on August 20, 2025, Nels tells Vincent he received a letter from the National Institutes of Health flagging the virus-evolution work in his R35 renewal as, in his words, dangerous gain-of-function research, part of a wave in which 40 projects were suspended and another 170 flagged.6:02
  • The paper at the centre of it is Hidden Evolutionary Constraints Dictate the Retention of Coronavirus Accessory Genes, driven by former postdoc Stephen Goldstein, published last December, with contributions from Zoe Hilbert, Diane Downauer, Nima Morshiri and virus and cell reagents from Susan Weiss and Sunny Shin at Penn.14:52
  • The experiment took mouse hepatitis virus with the NS2 phosphodiesterase knocked out in ORF2 and the host gene ACAP7 inserted at ORF4, then passaged it in mouse macrophages and in L2 fibroblasts: ACAP7 was lost in the fibroblasts where OAS/RNase L pressure is relaxed, but the dead ORF2 sequence survived 10 and then 15 passages in both cell backgrounds, like a rock.47:32
  • Nima Morshiri then checked the pattern against millions of SARS-CoV-2 sequences in GISAID and found the same thing for ORF8, which persists despite disabling stop codons such as position 27 in B.1.1.7 and position 8 in XBB.1.X, pointing to hidden non-coding constraints like RNA secondary structure across the gene body.56:14
  • Nels closes on the politics, reading David Relman of Stanford on self-censorship and intimidation of PIs and Mark Lipsitch of Harvard predicting the suspensions will damage health security, while Vincent picks Jake Scott's Stat News piece on Kennedy's terminated half billion dollars of mRNA vaccine funding and its 181-page bibliography.1:06:52

Brief overview

A gene the virus no longer uses sticks around anyway, and NIH called that work dangerous.

  1. A broken gene can still be load-bearingThe mutated ORF2 was never deleted over 15 passages, breaking the less-is-more expectation for RNA viruses.
  2. Coronavirus genomes fold across their gene bodiesUnpublished structure assays show secondary structure throughout ORF2, not just in the 5' and 3' UTRs.
  3. The flag fell on BSL-2 mouse-virus passagingThe experiments NIH objected to were MHV, a virus that has never infected a human in 75 years, passaged in a macrophage cell line.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What did the NIH tell Nels Elde about his R35 renewal?

A jarring letter flagged some of his lab's virus evolution work, quoting it, as dangerous gain-of-function research. After some back and forth the NIH determined that NIH funds cannot be used for one set of experiments, and Elde confirms no NIH money will support that work going forward.

Answered around 6:02
Which experiments did the NIH actually object to?

Through the back and forth it became clear the concern was passaging MHV in a macrophage cell line. Elde calls the stipulation on the renewal wild governmental overreach: it sits totally outside peer review, the expert reviewers never flagged it as a problem, and there is no appeal process.

Answered around 1:04:24
How many NIH projects were caught up in the gain-of-function review?

A Science news piece, NIH Suspends Dozens of Pathogen Studies Over Gain-of-Function Concerns, describes 40 projects meeting the gain-of-function definition, suspended while erring on the side of caution, plus another 170 flagged for potential suspension or termination. Elde thinks his was in that pile of 170.

Answered around 8:21
What paper is being discussed, and who did the work?

Hidden Evolutionary Constraints Dictate the Retention of Coronavirus Accessory Genes, published at the end of last year in Current Biology. Stephen Goldstein, a postdoc in Elde's lab, drove it; contributors include Zoe Hilbert, Diane Downauer, and Nima Moshiri, with viruses and cells from Susan Weiss and Sunny Shin at Penn.

Answered around 14:52
Which virus did the lab use, and how dangerous is it?

MHV, a mouse virus known for 75 years that has never infected a human and has infected a lot of mice. The lab works with it under BSL-2, biosafety level two, in cell lines rather than whole animals, with protocols, training and protective equipment agreed with environmental health and safety.

Answered around 42:42
What was the unexpected result of the passaging experiment?

Doing only the control, passaging in macrophages, the mutated NS2 gene in the ORF2 region did not go away. Less is more evolution predicted natural selection would quickly delete a sequence no longer encoding a working protein. Instead it sat there like a rock, in both cell backgrounds.

Answered around 44:47
What happened to the host gene they inserted into the virus?

ACAP7, the host phosphodiesterase put into the ORF4 location, persisted in macrophages, where the OAS and RNase L pathway runs strong and that enzymatic activity is needed. In L2 fibroblasts, which do not express much OAS or RNase L, selection is relaxed and the gene was lost.

Answered around 46:22
Why would a broken gene stay in the virus genome?

Elde thinks the genome folds up, forming RNA secondary structure that is read out in translation or in replication and transcription. Unpublished assays show a ton of secondary structure not only at the five prime and three prime UTRs but throughout the body of that open reading frame.

Answered around 32:25
Does the same retention pattern show up in SARS-CoV-2?

Yes. Searching the millions of sequences in GISAID, ORF8 by and large sticks around despite debilitating mutations: the B.1.17 variant had a stop codon at position 27, XBB.1.X at position 8. Deletions eat at the sequence in populations, then weeks later most of them have it back.

Answered around 58:07
What else changed in the virus populations during passaging?

Long read sequencing of the populations showed shifts in subgenomic RNA abundance. In four of five clones, by passage 10, the subgenomic RNA encoding spike was up around five-fold in the fibroblast passaged viruses. More spike may help infect the next cell, but would attract antibodies in an animal.

Answered around 51:14
Key Quote

“So it violated this notion of less is more evolution.”

— Nels, Hidden Constraints in Coronavirus Genes, at 44:58▶ listen at 44:58
Key Quote

“So to think that we could engineer a virus is ridiculous, and it shows a lack of understanding of the field.”

— Vincent, Hidden Constraints in Coronavirus Genes, at 1:02:53▶ listen at 1:02:53
Key Quote

“They've shifted that onto the researchers.”

— Nels, Hidden Constraints in Coronavirus Genes, at 1:11:07▶ listen at 1:11:07
Key Quote

“That's why the NIH model is so beautiful.”

— Vincent, Hidden Constraints in Coronavirus Genes, at 1:23:43▶ listen at 1:23:43

Cite this

“Hidden Constraints in Coronavirus Genes.” https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/twievo/TWiEVO117.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/hidden-constraints-in-coronavirus-genes.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?