Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

How Nolan's 'Odyssey' Was Influenced by Trump Derangement Syndrome | Ep 69

59:40 recording · AUTO · 3 speakers

Watch the original

Executive Summary AI
  • The hosts open on Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey as the first singular, universal cultural moment in years, and bring on Alex Prio, professor at the University of Austin, as their bard for the text.
  • Prio's immediate takeaway is that the film is a Trojan horse: it takes one of the primary texts of the Western tradition and shoehorns its core into modern secular morality, with Odysseus sailing off into the unknown West.
  • The core difference he names is that in Nolan the choice is moral — Odysseus violated Zeus' law with the Trojan horse to help Agamemnon — where Homer asks what it means to be a mortal man rather than a god, a question Prio says is simply absent.
  • Pressed on the political readings, Prio argues the film is plainly not conservative: a weak man in a big suit manipulating religion for financial gain against trans folks and minorities, with Sinon called almost stunning and brave, while the hosts push back that this reads too much politics into it.
  • His final word is to treat the film as a gateway at best and go read Homer — Richmond Lattimore's translation over Fagles — because the Odyssey is a profound meditation on human nature that Nolan looks down on.

Brief overview

Nolan's Odyssey is a beautifully made film that appropriates Homer for modern progressive morality.

  1. Adaptation crosses into appropriation when the heart is cutPrio accepts Sinon, Virgil borrowings and a villainous Agamemnon, but says replacing the question of human nature with PTSD and suppressed memory is unearned.
  2. Casting choices in the first three minutes are politicalCross-sex and cross-racial casting opening the film, with Elliot Page classed as a white man under Oscar categories, is read as teeing up the Academy.
  3. Calypso's island becomes California therapy cultureShe arrives in a netted swimsuit like a Malibu part-time yoga instructor and tells Odysseus he really has to learn how to let go.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What are the core differences between Nolan's Odyssey and Homer's?

Both turn on homecoming, but in Nolan's version the choice Odysseus faces is moral: with the Trojan horse he violated Zeus' law, the sacred bond of guest friendship, to help the big bad Agamemnon. In Homer the question is what it means to be a mortal man.

What choice does Odysseus face on Calypso's island in Homer?

He arrives feeling saved, pleased, Homer tells us, and seven years later stares off the shore wanting home. The choice is eternal life of pleasure with a beautiful divine being, endless eating, sex and consumption, or a risky return with no guarantee, possibly leaving his wife again.

Why does Alex call the film fundamentally a progressive movie?

It starts from the beginning of the Greeks, nods toward Christianity, then toward the secularization of Christianity, shoehorning one of the primary texts of the Western tradition into modern secular morality. The clear sign is Odysseus sailing off into the unknown West, the roots reworked for contemporary progressive morality.

Is Nolan adapting the Odyssey or appropriating it?

The line between adaptation and appropriation is hard to draw. Cuts are necessary, and using Sinon, who comes from Virgil, or making Agamemnon more of a villain is fair game. But losing the heart, the question of human nature, leaves an everyman, and that becomes unearned appropriation.

How does Nolan change the scene with the nurse Eurycleia?

As the old nurse washes his feet she notices the scar. In Homer, Odysseus grabs her neck so she says nothing, showing he will throttle the old woman who cared for him as a child to survive. Nolan has him touch her chin and win her over with gentleness.

How does the film portray Agamemnon?

He is the representative of the Greeks, black against orange like a Greek vase, bursting through the gates of Troy in a black suit. He manipulated Zeus' law for trade routes: imperialist, capitalist, manipulating religion. Without the suit he is flat, a weakling who kills his own daughter.

What does Elliot Page's casting symbolize in the film?

One reading: the audience sees the trans actor before the character, deliberately tied to the Trojan horse, to deceit and civilizational decline, and she alone is not told it is a ruse. The counter is that Odysseus at the end calls Sinon a stunning and brave hero.

How does the film depict Calypso?

She rolls up in a netted swimsuit, like one of the hot older ladies living in Malibu, a part-time yoga instructor, and she does yoga. At the key moment when Odysseus is finally getting ready to go home she tells him he really has to learn how to let go.

What do the sea people symbolize in Nolan's film?

One reading makes Zeus' law the UN and the sea people a more muscular American foreign policy, imperialism. The sea had to be tamed from pirates, as in the opening chapters of Thucydides, and that gave way to Athenian empire managed by sea: order, and mastery for empire.

Which English translation of the Odyssey does he recommend?

Richmond Latimore, an old translation, roughly seventy years old and done in the fifties. It is not highly poetic but it hews very close to the Greek, is very readable, and gets you pretty close. Teaching Fagles meant correcting it left and right, though it reads beautifully.

Key Quote

“But I think it's fundamentally a progressive movie.”

— Alex Prio, How Nolan's 'Odyssey' Was Influenced by Trump Derangement Syndrome | Ep 69, at 1:27▶ watch at 1:27
Key Quote

“Everybody does that in Western history, but you better do a good job.”

— Alex Prio, How Nolan's 'Odyssey' Was Influenced by Trump Derangement Syndrome | Ep 69, at 26:24▶ watch at 26:24
Key Quote

“That is what the Odyssey is about, this guy who is seeking his heroism.”

— How Nolan's 'Odyssey' Was Influenced by Trump Derangement Syndrome | Ep 69, at 30:13▶ watch at 30:13
Key Quote

“My final thought is just go read Homer.”

— Alex Prio, How Nolan's 'Odyssey' Was Influenced by Trump Derangement Syndrome | Ep 69, at 56:28▶ watch at 56:28

Cite this

“How Nolan's 'Odyssey' Was Influenced by Trump Derangement Syndrome | Ep 69.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QHU1mp75Ka0. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/how-nolan-s-odyssey-was-influenced-by-trump-derangement-synd.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?