A cold email wins on credibility, a named mutual connection, politeness and a clear, low-entitlement ask.
Lead with the mutual connection rather than yourself: "For Tom Cruise via Tim Ferriss," then the credibility indicator. Subject lines get truncated on mobile, so the name they recognise has to survive the cut. "Via" beats "referral from" because it doesn't oblige them to vet and call that person.
Be clear about exactly what you want. "Would love to discuss something, let's hop on the phone, how's next Tuesday at 2pm" never gets a reply, because it places no value on the recipient's time. If you can't write a professional first cold email, everything that follows looks doubtful.
No. Include a line or two of text establishing who you are, and hyperlink the phrase "and I've done this thing" instead of sending "hey, here I am, link" with a sketchy attachment. Nobody has time for a scavenger hunt, and you want to remove reasons to say no.
Give a phone number, even a burner or a Google Voice number spun up from any G Suite. Don't bury it in the signature; say explicitly "feel free to text me anytime" or "feel free to hop on the phone, I promise it will not take more than 10 minutes" and then don't go over ten.
Almost always with: "If you've read this far, I really appreciate it, and if you're too busy to get back to me, I totally understand." Displaying as little or zero entitlement gets a much higher response rate, because the cold email is an audition for everything else to come.
Once, and not two days later with "bumping this up," then again two days after that. Wait at least a week, send the one bump, then assume they're not interested and move on. If nobody responds, the common denominator is probably a problem with the email itself.
Assume the person you email will immediately text the people you named, and they will. Nine times out of ten that contact says they have no idea who you are, or that you shook hands once at a party. At that point you're gone, for implicitly or explicitly misrepresenting the relationship.
If you don't have a billion downloads or millions of followers, use examples of the work that at least show you've done your homework: "no one's watched this, but it looks really, really good and it's beautifully edited." The indicator can also sit in the subject line in parentheses.
He volunteered for organisations with name cache, such as TiE, the Indus Entrepreneur, and the Silicon Valley Association of Startup Entrepreneurs, then wrote "for so-and-so via TiE" and left his own name out, because who the hell is he. That got the email opened. All unpaid.
Shoulder-slapping instant camaraderie, "hey Tim, yo bro, yo Ferriss," is a very risky gambit that maybe works one time out of ten. Otherwise it reads as a liability, a general lack of awareness and a reputational risk, and it usually gets auto-archived. It feels like a stranger hugging you at the airport.
“So if they just see for Tom Cruise from Tim Ferriss, it's going to be like, who the fuck is Tim Ferriss? Archive.”
“So your, your job number one is don't do anything stupid.”
“Like, the person who wants the most distance wins that conversation.”
“Like some of the highest paying jobs you'll ever get, you don't get paid for in the beginning”
“So include a line or two on who the hell you are.”
“Number two, anyone who is reasonably well known has a lot of phishing attacks.”
“How to Write a Cold Email That Gets a Response.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bi6N8qzm4Mk. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/how-to-write-a-cold-email-that-gets-a-response.html.