Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Juvenile Prison Conditions

20:31 recording · EN · 6 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • A child care worker opens the episode warning that the youth prisons are breeding the next generation of adult criminals, because young people who should be treated, educated and kept in contact with others are not getting that help.0:18
  • Rachelle Verdel of Nieuwsuur drove to the Hartenborst institution with Dave, whose son Damien spent about four and a half years inside, and he describes it as a punishment within a punishment: 23 hours in the cell, school cancelled because there is no staff to take him there, visits cut short, and a treatment that never really came into effect.2:03
  • Marcel Compagne, a member of the supervision commission for the youth prison in Lelystad who also represents the commissions of all six youth prisons, brought a folder full of complaints showing the boys do not get the 77 hours of day programme they are legally entitled to and are too often in their room.7:02
  • A year ago three state inspections sent the State Secretary an alarming letter about the acute personnel shortages and the safety of both the young people and the employees, and the inspection says that a year later nothing has been solved.11:09
  • As a possible way out, experts point to electronic supervision: more than 80% of the boys in detention are there for less than three months and could be guided at home with an ankle band, while the ministry expects to present its structural measures in 2027.15:53

Brief overview

Staff shortages leave detained youngsters locked up instead of getting the schooling and treatment they are owed.

  1. A legal day programme that rarely happensBoys have a right to 77 hours of school, treatment and activities a week, but often sit 23 hours in the cell instead.
  2. Staff shortage is the recurring causeIt is code black in juvenile detention too: qualified people are hard to recruit and, under the pressure, hard to keep.
  3. Complaints answered with money, not careThere are so many complaints that compensation is now paid automatically, while young people say they want their schooling and treatment, not cash.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
How many hours of day programme are detained young people entitled to?

These boys have a right to a 77-hour day programme, made up of guidance, treatment, education and activities. Marcel Compagne says the complaints submitted by the boys show they are too often in their room and do not meet the legal requirement of 77 recreation hours per week.

Answered around 7:02
Why aren't the young people taken to school or treatment?

It comes back every time to the lack of staff; it is code black here too, they say, and has been a problem for years. Judicial institutions say qualified people are hard to recruit, because sometimes it concerns TBS treatment, and hard to keep, since the losses make the pressure very high.

Answered around 12:08
What does Damien's father say about his son's life inside?

Dave calls it a punishment within a punishment. His son arrives late to visits, which halves the visiting time; he sometimes spends 23 hours in his cell and is told there is no staff to take him to school. His treatment came very late and he often fell out of it.

Answered around 2:03
What does the official day programme in a juvenile prison look like?

From the website of the judicial institutions: breakfast at half past eight, school at nine until about five or six, a group lunch, then therapy, homework or a library visit, homework in the room, eating together at 6.30, a game or reading at half past seven, and night at half past nine.

Answered around 7:40
Are detainees discouraged from filing complaints?

A detainee says there are sorts of buying mechanisms: if you don't serve your complaints, they have something delicious for you, or a pack of cigarettes. He was too afraid to submit any. Damien's father recognised it — his son was bought off more than once, with a bottle of water or a coke.

Answered around 4:52
What happens to all the complaints that are filed?

As a detainee you can file a complaint, and when it is clarified you get a certain amount of money. Marcel Compagne says complaints increased so much that they decided on an automatic amount; you don't even have to call. Young people tell him they don't want money, they want their education and treatment.

Answered around 9:43
What did the inspections warn about a year ago?

Three state inspections sent an alarming letter to the State Secretary. Its heading names serious concern about the effect of the acute personnel shortages on the young people and the employees, so the safety of both is not guaranteed. A year later the inspection says nothing has been solved.

Answered around 10:52
What alternative to locking young people up is being discussed?

Electronic supervision: a single band, so the house becomes the prison. Seventy per cent of the population serving at DJI is with them shorter than three months, and more than 80% of boys in detention less than three months. Ten youngsters at home with a band need no staff; structural measures are expected in 2027.

Answered around 15:07
Why does the child care worker say we breed our own adult criminals?

She means that if it continues this way it will not remain a youth sin, but that they will also end up in the institutions for adults. To get better, young people need treatment, education and contact with others so they can enter society again — and they don't get that help in the right way.

Answered around 0:18
What detention damage does Damien's father already see at home?

Dave's son is serving the last part of his sentence at home, and Dave says he can already see the detention damage: after eating he goes straight to his room. He worries about those patterns and behaviours, and about the hardening caused by promises that were made and never fulfilled.

Answered around 17:41
Key Quote

“We breed our own adult criminals.”

— Child care worker, Juvenile Prison Conditions, at 0:00▶ listen at 0:00
Key Quote

“Too little education and spending 23 hours a day in your cell.”

— Marco Geitenbeek, Juvenile Prison Conditions, at 0:46▶ listen at 0:46
Key Quote

“From the beginning, I was so afraid that I didn't want to submit any complaints. I thought I'd do an extra pack of cigarettes.”

— Detainee, Juvenile Prison Conditions, at 5:01▶ listen at 5:01
Key Quote

“What we see from the complaints we get, which are submitted by the boys, is that they are too often in the room.”

— Marcel Compagne, Juvenile Prison Conditions, at 7:08▶ listen at 7:08
Key Quote

“Will they get enough guidance and support to return to society?”

— Marcel Compagne, Juvenile Prison Conditions, at 10:36▶ listen at 10:36
Key Quote

“Dave says to us, I can already see the detention damage, he calls it.”

— Rachelle Verdel, Juvenile Prison Conditions, at 17:41▶ listen at 17:41

Cite this

“Juvenile Prison Conditions.” https://podcast.npo.nl/file/de-dag/143926/nieuwsuurverhaal-23-uur-op-cel-hoe-het-is-in-jeugdgevangenissen.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/juvenile-prison-conditions.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?