Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Kinnahan-Hutch Feud Questions

55:52 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Jordan Canning asks about Ruth Coppinger TD, who told the Dáil that mainstream media had irresponsibly stoked up the flames of racism by reporting that an asylum seeker was being sought for the murder of Jamie Carney.3:02
  • Mick O'Toole says their paper was the first to report the suspect was an asylum seeker, and although the law bars naming anyone in the international protection system, both stand over naming him once he fled the country after the murder.6:02
  • A listener asks whether it sat right to publish the photograph of Noel Kirwan, an innocent father of three later shot dead outside his home in Clondalkin, walking beside Gerry the Monk Hutch at Eddie Hutch's funeral three days after the Regency Hotel attack.14:37
  • Encrypted messages that came out at Sean McGovern's recent sentencing showed the Kinahans called Kirwan the duck and wanted a gunman to cut his teeth on a soft target, and the hosts say they would never publish that photo with hindsight, though not even the Gardaí saw the danger in March 2016.18:37
  • Asked whether Brian Grendon, Jonathan Gill and Daniel Kinahan could be jailed at the same time, they explain Grendon, 48, is sent forward to the Special Criminal Court over directing a crime gang and cocaine worth 13 grand, Gill has lost his fight against extradition to Northern Ireland over the murder of Robbie Lawler, and that someone always steps in at the top of the tree.38:14

Brief overview

Two crime reporters defend publishing facts about the Kinahan-Hutch feud, including the asylum seeker and the Kirwan photograph.

  1. Report the facts, whatever the reactionThey were first to say the suspect was an asylum seeker and stand over naming him, grief or not.
  2. The Kirwan photograph was everyone's blind spotNobody, not even the Gardaí, thought a man in the background of a funeral photo would be targeted.
  3. Someone always fills the voidGardaí now call the West Dublin gang known as the Family the biggest in the country.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Why did the paper report that the murder suspect was an asylum seeker?

They were the first newspaper to say it, and did so knowing they would get grief. They argue the fact was highly relevant: the man had lost his asylum application and was appealing it, and he then fled to the very country he was supposedly seeking asylum from.

Answered around 6:02
Who was Noel Kirwan and how was he killed?

An innocent father of three, shot dead outside his home in Clondalkin at the height of the Kinahan-Hutch feud. He had been heavily involved in anti-drug movements in the inner city for years and was a childhood friend of Hutch family members, but had nothing to do with criminality or the feud.

Answered around 16:42
Why did the Kinahans choose Noel Kirwan as a target?

Facts from Sean McGovern's sentencing showed how desperate they had become. In encrypted conversations they discussed a soft target for a gunman to cut his teeth on and referred to Kirwan as the duck. Gardaí were all over the inner city, and the main Hutch targets were protected or out of the country.

Answered around 18:22
Why was the funeral photograph published, and did it make Kirwan a target?

Every outlet ran it because it was a striking picture of Gerry Hutch, then considered a Kinahan target and unseen since the Regency Hotel attack three days earlier, at Eddie Hutch's funeral. Kirwan was simply walking beside him; nobody, not even the Gardaí, thought a man in that photo would be shot.

Answered around 17:04
Where is Patrick Hutch now and what does he do?

He is a private citizen living in Dublin's north inner city, back with his father Patsy and his brother Derek Delboy Hutch. He works as a labourer for a business calling to people's houses, window cleaning or similar. He is out and about openly, and the 24-hour Garda post on Champions Avenue is gone.

Answered around 23:42
Why was Patrick Hutch's Regency Hotel murder charge thrown out?

The Kinahans believed he was the gunman in drag at the Regency Hotel, and he went on trial for it. The charge was thrown out after the tragic death of the lead detective, Superintendent Colm Fox. Gardaí continue to investigate the murder, but a fresh prosecution is considered highly unlikely.

Answered around 26:25
What is Brian Grennan accused of?

Grennan, 48, was before the District Court in Dublin and has been sent forward to the Special Criminal Court, a non-jury court. He is accused of directing the activities of a criminal organisation in importing and distributing controlled drugs, and money laundering the proceeds, over cocaine worth 13 grand, allegedly in 2024.

Answered around 38:44
Why is Jonathan Gill fighting extradition?

He is not being sought by authorities in the Republic. He was arrested here on a trade and cooperation agreement warrant issued in Belfast, and has lost his argument against extradition, remanded in custody while his legal team consider other avenues. He is accused of the murder of Robbie Lawler, which carries life.

Answered around 39:54
What security is planned if Daniel Kinahan is brought back to prison?

A lot of security upgrades have been done in Portlaoise. If he is returned successfully he goes to an area in what they call the basement, isolated from the rest of the prison population; Sean McGovern might be put in with him, though that must be assessed. The Defence Forces will be involved.

Answered around 51:56
Which gang is the biggest in Ireland now?

Gardaí say the biggest gang in the country is now the one known as the Family, a West Dublin gang that took over the territory as the Kinahans lost the influence they once had. It was seriously degraded by a major operation in Spain, and others may in turn take over from them.

Answered around 42:52
Key Quote

“Firstly, we were the first newspaper to say the suspect was an asylum seeker. And we did that despite knowing that we would get grief.”

— Mick O'Toole, Kinnahan-Hutch Feud Questions, at 6:02▶ listen at 6:02
Key Quote

“So I guess we were all naive to that fact. What happened to Mr. Kerwin was dreadful.”

— Paul Healy, Kinnahan-Hutch Feud Questions, at 20:21▶ listen at 20:21

Cite this

“Kinnahan-Hutch Feud Questions.” https://dcs-spotify.megaphone.fm/RPSL8986870034.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/kinnahan-hutch-feud-questions.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?