The narrator sets out to investigate two viral Roblox creepypastas, KittyCooties48 and MikaylaMaya, whose players allegedly disappeared after their incidents.
In the Kitty story, a girl escapes her parents' constant fighting in Brookhaven and later comes downstairs to find her mother covered in blood saying she was just hungry, after which Kitty is never heard from again.
The narrator finds the KittyCooties48 account still exists with two playable games, She Was Hungry and My Story, which retell the scene, and asks why someone who never came back would build them.
The Mikayla story dates to 26 June 2011, when a link from her friend Jacob briefly switched on her webcam, he later said it was almost time, and she was never seen online again, with Jacob said to be a kidnapper.
Checking the accounts, the narrator finds Mikayla's bio unchanged, Jacob's 2008 account renamed Police Squad, and a login on her account two years ago, but admits he has found no evidence either story is real.
Brief overview
Two viral Roblox creepypastas, KittyCooties48 and MikaylaMaya, leave real accounts behind but no evidence either story happened.
The KittyCooties48 games are still playableShe Was Hungry and My Story both rebuild the same scene with the same blank-faced mother.
Mikayla's account showed activity after a decadeSomeone logged in two years ago after more than ten years of silence since 2011.
No evidence confirms either storyThe narrator says he found nothing proving the stories real and asks viewers for their theories.
Questions this recording answers
7 questions, each answered where it is said
Is the KittyCooties48 Roblox account real?
Yes. The narrator says the KittyCooties48 account still exists and anyone can find it. It contains two games, one called She Was Hungry and one called My Story, and both are still playable. Nobody has come forward to claim they made it as a joke.
What happens in the She Was Hungry Roblox game?
It starts outside a basic-looking house. Inside, a dead bacon hair avatar lies on the floor with another standing over it, completely still. Getting close triggers a hard-coded line, I'm sorry, I was just hungry, and the face model is deliberately built so the expression does not match the words.
How is Kitty's My Story game different from the first one?
My Story is less a game and more like watching a movie scene of how the murder happened. It moves from Kitty introducing herself, to her parents arguing, to Kitty in her room, a Time for dinner prompt, and a final room with the father on the floor and mother over him.
What happened to MikaylaMaya on Roblox?
On 26 June 2011, while playing a camping game, Mikayla got a weird link from her friend Jacob. Clicking it opened her webcam, which then shut off. Days later Jacob joined her game, said it was almost time and left. She was never seen online again, and Jacob was said to be a kidnapper.
What did the narrator find on Mikayla's and Jacob's accounts?
Mikayla Maya's account is still there with the same bio from the original video. Jacob's account, created in 2008, was renamed Police Squad at some point, and every detail matches. Mikayla's account also shows someone logged in two years ago, after more than a decade of silence.
Are the Kitty and Mikayla stories true?
The narrator says he has not found any evidence showing whether they were real. He notes that Kitty's games remain with a silent account, and that Mikayla's account registered activity two years ago with no explanation, then asks viewers to share their theories in the comments.
Why did Kitty play Roblox so much?
Her parents fought constantly, screaming and crying every day, and Roblox, specifically Brookhaven, was her only escape. The retold version adds that she was homeschooled, so she loved Brookhaven because it had a school where she could role-play, and she used noise-canceling headphones to block out the fighting.
Key Quote
“Both of these stories went massively viral, but nobody investigated the backstories of these girls.”
— Narrator
Key Quote
“I'm sorry, I was just hungry.”
— Narrator
Key Quote
“She sat down and made two games that walk you through the worst night of her life.”