Retired judge Lex Lasry explains why he left the bench and what Australian criminal justice gets wrong.
He was in the middle of a large murder trial in February of 24 when he was told that in August of the year before, the DPP had complained about him to the Judicial Commission, which everybody knew except him. He was hearing DPP prosecutions while under complaint, so he resigned, depriving the Commission of jurisdiction.
Answered around 5:08He was trial judge in the case arising from the Eastern Freeway crash that killed four police. He had the driver's manager, charged with heavy vehicle offences plus four counts of manslaughter. The prosecutor dropped the manslaughter charges and refused to explain why; Lasry granted a stay, and the Court of Appeal overturned him.
Answered around 3:35An act of parliament says that if you commit a particular offence you get a minimum, say ten years imprisonment. Some provisions have a get-out clause for exceptional circumstances, others don't. In the Northern Territory the mandatory sentence for murder is life imprisonment, and the mandatory minimum for murdering a domestic partner is 25 years.
Answered around 18:34Lasry says women in that situation are almost certainly able to run self-defence, on the basis of an honest belief that if she didn't kill him, he was going to kill her. In one case he remembers, the woman was acquitted after saying, I looked at him and I know that look.
Answered around 19:33No. In a case he was involved in, the man came into the house enraged, yelling her name and demanding she do what he wanted, and she believed she would be beaten to death. You don't have to have the knife in the stomach; a reasonable belief the act was necessary to save your own life, or a child's, is enough.
Answered around 20:35A victim impact statement is meant to describe the impact of the crime on the victim, so anything else, including abuse, falls outside it, which is why they are edited. Victims aren't supposed to say what the sentence should be or that they hope the offender suffers. Lasry says he bent the rules a bit to let people have their say.
Answered around 22:33Because he is concerned about the civilisation of our community: if you drop to the level of the criminal by killing the accused, you reduce the community to that level, and we are better than that kind of revenge. Sentencing must occur and the community is entitled to protection, but killing is not the way.
Answered around 15:11Lasry puts it at about 85% of the prison population, against roughly 2% of the population nationally and probably closer to 10% of the Northern Territory. He calls it more evidence that we have failed Indigenous people, filled them with booze, and notes fetal alcohol syndrome disorder up there is very high.
Answered around 33:21Made with barrister Greg Barnes, it is intended to be about the law. The first episode discussed the legality of the attack on Iran by the United States and Israel. Guests have included Rob Starry on crime, Tim Marsh on mental illness and the criminal law, and Julian Assange's brother Gabrielle Shipton on the Assange campaign.
Answered around 16:50Guessing without being egotistical, he says it will be that he fought pretty hard in death penalty cases and fought hard in public against the death penalty in other countries. He and Julian ran the Van Nguyen case and the Bailey case; Van Nguyen was executed. He credits Barry Jones for the commitment.
Answered around 13:12“I just don't want to do this anymore. I've been a judge for 19 years, 34 years at the bar.”
“we're not telling you, we're just not proceeding with them.”
“We're better than that. We're better than that kind of revenge.”
“It's a shame that's happened because what mandatory sentencing does is tell the courts, we don't trust you with a sentencing discretion.”
“this is the most important civic duty you can perform in peacetime”
“Instead of treating them with respect, we've filled them with booze.”
“Law the Podcast with Lex Lasry.” https://28833.mc.tritondigital.com:443/OMNY_AUSTRALIANTRUECRIME_PODCAST_P/media-session/78ccdb65-d17b-42cd-b3de-66469e232e36/d/clips/fa326977-3de5-4283-9b8b-af3500c58607/1cee5934-fec3-4a8e-bb11-b3b6018a4ed9/b532e281-fc8d-4b58-83db-b49600dfc1e3/audio/direct/t1785348564/A_Judge_s_Perspective_on_Murder_Trials.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/law-the-podcast-with-lex-lasry.html.