Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Lex AI Irving Finkel

2:14:13 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Irving Finkel dates the first writing we can see to around 3500 BC, among people living between the Euphrates and Tigris who made agreed signs on clay and eventually realised a picture could carry a sound rather than a thing.9:59
  • He rejects the standard sequence that pictures came first and sound second, calling it bewildering that anyone would start with the least flexible system, and argues pictographic signs were already the end of a very long trading-and-messaging tradition.20:43
  • His most controversial evidence is a round green stone from Göbekli Tepe, about 9000 BC, with signs carved on its flat bottom: a seal used to ratify, which to him proves writing some 7,000 years before Sumer.24:18
  • On decipherment he describes the trilingual inscription of Darius at Bisutun, read first through Old Persian, and credits Edward Hinks, a clergyman in Killaloe, over Henry Rawlinson, whom he calls the stepfather rather than the father of Assyriology.42:51
  • He recounts identifying the Ark tablet, a 1700 BC Babylonian tablet about eight inches by three whose 60 lines give a blueprint for a round coracle, making the Mesopotamian flood story a thousand years older than the biblical one.1:22:24

Brief overview

Irving Finkel argues cuneiform's story is far older and far larger than the surviving tablets suggest.

  1. Recording sound, not pictures, was the real leapOnce a picture of a foot meant the sound of foot, language itself could be written down.
  2. What survives is a raindrop, not the waterfallThousands of Ur III tablets probably came out of two storage rooms, yet scholars treat them as a whole culture.
  3. The Babylonian flood predates Genesis by a millenniumThe 1700 BC Ark tablet, plus George Smith's 1872 Nineveh find of the three released birds, shows literary dependence.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
When and where did writing first appear?

The oldest evidence we have is around 3500 BC, the middle of the fourth millennium, among people living between the Euphrates and Tigris who used clay for building and eventually as a writing support. Finkel stresses this is only the oldest surviving evidence, and thinks it very unlikely writing actually began then.

Answered around 9:59
How does cuneiform writing actually work?

It is syllabic. They could not write a bare consonant, so a vowel came before or after it, and with four vowels you got ab and ba, ib and bi, ub and bu, eb and be. To write museum a Babylonian wrote mu, then the sign z, then um.

Answered around 35:56
Why is the script called cuneiform?

From about 1840 to 1850 excavations in Iraq turned up clay tablets whose clusters of marks broke down into triangular shapes. Cuneiform means wedge-shaped, because cuneus in Latin means wedge. The shape is clearest on the Assyrian reliefs, where the writing is big; on a tablet the wedge is less predominant.

Answered around 16:27
How was cuneiform finally deciphered?

Through a trilingual inscription of the Persian king Darius carved high on a mountain at Bisutun, in Elamite, Babylonian and Old Persian. Old Persian used a simple cuneiform and the language was still alive, so they read Dari-a-wush and the repeated royal titles, then matched the reiterated passages in the other columns.

Answered around 42:43
Does Henry Rawlinson deserve the credit for deciphering cuneiform?

Finkel says no. Rawlinson is called the father of Assyriology, but Finkel calls him the stepfather, because his first long book on the inscriptions was almost entirely wrong. He credits Edward Hinks, a clergyman at Killaloe in Northern Ireland with five daughters, who worked out that signs are multivalent.

Answered around 45:47
What is the Ark tablet and what does it actually say?

A visitor brought it to the British Museum among other objects, and Finkel identified it almost straight away as flood narrative. About eight inches by three and dating to 1700 BC, its sixty lines are a blueprint the god gives Atrahasis: the shape, the materials and how much of each, for a giant round coracle.

Answered around 1:20:59
Why is Sumerian considered so strange among ancient languages?

Babylonian is a Semitic tongue, extinct but related to Hebrew, Aramaic, Arabic, Ethiopic and Syriac, so decipherers fell back on Semitic dictionaries. Sumerian is not Semitic and not related to any other known language. Unlike Indo-European or Germanic it has no family, so its relatives vanished before writing could record them.

Answered around 38:08
Why did cuneiform survive for three thousand years?

Inertia is the first factor. The second is that the people who could read and write, the archive keepers, temple clerks and the king's writers, held great power because most of the public could not, and had no interest in literacy for all. Early lexicographic standardisation kept the system streamlined.

Answered around 51:08
What makes Finkel think there was writing at Gobekli Tepe?

Among the photographs the archaeologists put online there is a round green stone like an Egyptian scarab, arched on top and flat underneath, with hieroglyphic signs carved on the flat face. Finkel reads it as a seal for ratifying agreements, so writing about 9000 BC, thousands of years before southern Iraq.

Answered around 23:39
Does Finkel think the ark was ever really built?

No. He calls it a literary construction built out of the reality that the people who survived were in boats. He does believe a disastrous flood in Mesopotamia, sweeping the flat plains down to the Persian Gulf, gave the story its inception, but nothing global and nothing that touched America or China.

Answered around 1:30:40
Key Quote

“Well, that seal from Gobekli Tepe is a raindrop from which I infer writing.”

— Irving Finkel, Lex AI Irving Finkel, at 27:50▶ listen at 27:50
Key Quote

“It's predicated on the assumption that what we have is only what there was.”

— Irving Finkel, Lex AI Irving Finkel, at 34:12▶ listen at 34:12
Key Quote

“It means that with A, B could be, might be, ought to be, should be, could be true.”

— Irving Finkel, Lex AI Irving Finkel, at 57:55▶ listen at 57:55
Key Quote

“And it's important because you never get floods in Jerusalem.”

— Irving Finkel, Lex AI Irving Finkel, at 1:25:14▶ listen at 1:25:14

Cite this

“Lex AI Irving Finkel.” https://media.blubrry.com/takeituneasy/ins.blubrry.com/takeituneasy/lex_ai_irving_finkel.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/lex-ai-irving-finkel.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?