Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Lex AI Julia Shaw

2:48:50 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Criminal psychologist Julia Shaw explains the dark tetrad — psychopathy, sadism, narcissism and Machiavellianism — as four scales on which everyone scores somewhere, mostly subclinically, rather than a binary label of monster or non-monster.8:40
  • Asked whether she would go back and kill baby Hitler, she says no, because she does not believe people are born evil and because the word evil itself others people and ends the conversation we need for prevention.10:35
  • She cites deception-detection research, including Aldert Fry's, showing that lie detection is unreliable and that police and investigative interviewers are no better than chance while remaining highly confident, which drives wrongful accusations and, in relationships, jealousy.21:46
  • On murder she says most killings are fights that get out of control over stupid reasons — a person owed me $4, this person stole my bike — not planned serial predation, and homicide recidivism is only 1 to 3% while fraud, elder abuse and sexual violence are the high-risk crimes.45:03
  • Turning to sexuality, she describes Alfred Kinsey's 0 to 6 scale from his 1940s Sexual Behavior in the Human Male, where about half of men and about a quarter of women fell somewhere in the middle, and argues visibility is what stops bisexual and kinky people being dehumanized.1:11:25

Brief overview

Evil is not a type of person but a continuum every one of us sits on.

  1. Calling someone evil ends the inquiry that prevents harmShaw refuses the word because labelling a person evil removes the need to understand what led them to the act.
  2. Most murders are overreactions, not predationReal stated motives are a $4 debt or a stolen bike, and homicide recidivism runs only 1 to 3%.
  3. Fantasy and rehearsal are protective, not warning signsAbout 70% of men and over 50% of women have fantasized about killing someone, and thinking it through is how we decide not to.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What is the dark tetrad and why is it a continuum?

The dark tetrad is sadism, pleasure in hurting other people; Machiavellianism, doing whatever it takes to get ahead; narcissism, seeing yourself as superior; and psychopathy, which lacks empathy and pairs with a parasitic, deceptive lifestyle. Each trait is a scale, so everyone scores somewhere, usually subclinical rather than clinically diagnosed.

Answered around 8:40
If you could go back in time, would you kill baby Hitler?

Her answer is no. The question really asks whether people are born evil or socialised into harm. Psychologists poring over Hitler ask whether he was mad or bad, and find traits like sadism and low empathy, but his early life showed few of them. It is not a straight line from baby to adult.

Answered around 10:35
Why shouldn't we call a human being evil?

Because the word others people and ends the conversation. Calling somebody evil says they are so different from you that you need not understand why they did terrible things, and that labelling is what makes us capable of horrendous crimes against them. She prefers continuums of negative traits, since we all have the capacity to kill.

Answered around 11:58
Why have empathy for people who commit terrible crimes?

She calls it evil empathy. Working as a criminal psychologist on sexual abuse, rape and murder cases, she hears the word evil used constantly. Labelling changes nothing; what we actually want is to stop the behaviour, and that only happens if we understand the psychological and social levers that led that person there.

Answered around 14:20
Can police officers reliably tell when someone is lying?

No. Aldert Fry, one of the leading deception detection researchers, has found across many studies that detecting lies reliably is really hard. Police and investigative interviewers have high confidence from their vast experience, yet in experimental settings they are no better than chance, so they miss liars and may push innocent people toward wrongful conviction.

Answered around 21:38
How common is it to fantasise about killing someone?

Research on murder fantasies finds most men have fantasised about killing someone, about 70% in two studies, and more than 50% of women. Some researchers call that a good thing: a dress rehearsal that shows how you do not want to live. Constant rumination about a specific person is when it becomes a risk factor.

Answered around 37:27
Why do people actually commit murder?

Most of the time it is a fight that gets out of control, not planning. The stated reasons are stupid ones: this person owed me $4, this person stole my bike. It is a bad decision in the moment, an overreaction to an argument. Intimate partner homicide is one of the top four reasons.

Answered around 44:21
Which crimes carry the highest risk of reoffending?

Murder is a really low recidivism risk; the high risk crimes are fraud, elder abuse and sexual violence. She argues our sanctions are upside down, matching how we perceive justice rather than prevention. If we want a safer society, sanctions should follow what deters crime and who is most likely to commit it.

Answered around 47:22
Is jealousy a red flag in a relationship?

She thinks persistent jealousy is basically always a red flag: the jealous person is not secure, either because the relationship is wrong for them or because they are insecure in themselves. It is not love but control and the desire to possess, and it is almost always a precursor to intimate partner violence.

Answered around 57:00
What does the Kinsey Scale measure?

Alfred Kinsey's scale runs from 0, exclusively heterosexual tendencies, to 6, exclusively homosexual, because applying a binary to sexual orientation was not useful. Placing people from everything they told him, he found about half of men and about a quarter of women sat somewhere in the middle, not exclusively either.

Answered around 1:10:56
Key Quote

“The question is why we don't do those things rather than why we do do those things quite often.”

— Julia Shaw, Lex AI Julia Shaw, at 12:51▶ listen at 12:51
Key Quote

“The idea being that evil is a label we place onto others.”

— Julia Shaw, Lex AI Julia Shaw, at 14:55▶ listen at 14:55
Key Quote

“Very few people want to murder.”

— Julia Shaw, Lex AI Julia Shaw, at 46:37▶ listen at 46:37
Key Quote

“I think monogamy is setting us up to fail.”

— Julia Shaw, Lex AI Julia Shaw, at 58:22▶ listen at 58:22

Cite this

“Lex AI Julia Shaw.” https://media.blubrry.com/takeituneasy/content.blubrry.com/takeituneasy/lex_ai_julia_shaw.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/lex-ai-julia-shaw.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?