Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Mackenzie Shavilla's Trial and Appeal

41:24 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • The second half of part four walks through Mackenzie Shirilla's trial and her reaction to the verdict in a recorded call with her mother Natalie.0:25
  • The Shirillas allege corruption because the judge shares the Russo surname and Dom's mother Christine Russo once worked for the DA's office, though the host notes the judge and the family are not related and no medical or POTS expert was ever called at trial.2:29
  • After the judge finds her guilty, Mackenzie tells Natalie she is in shock and asks why she was kept alive if she was meant to go to jail, while her father Steve says he would click his fingers and make everybody disappear.8:09
  • Davion Flanagan's family describes a boy adopted at eight and a half who lived for football until he tore his ACL in his senior season, and Christine Russo tells the court she lost three children in the crash.12:50
  • Natalie's plea drew the judge's rebuke that she was hearing an awful lot about the daughter and very little about the two dead people; Mackenzie was sentenced to 15 years to life served concurrently, with a first parole hearing in 2037 and appeals rejected up to the Supreme Court of Ohio.30:33

Brief overview

Mackenzie Shirilla's jail calls, the victim statements and her 15-to-life sentence show no remorse.

  1. Corruption claims rest on a shared surnameThe judge and Dom's family are not related, and Christine Russo no longer works for the DA's office.
  2. The POTS defence was never actually provenNo medical or POTS expert was brought in to show a medical episode caused the crash.
  3. The calls read as self-focus, not remorseMackenzie asks about her belongings, a protest and a book, while the families speak about the boys who died.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What sentence did Mackenzie Shirilla receive for the deaths of Dom and Davion?

She was sentenced to 15 years to life, with the sentences served concurrently, so she becomes eligible for parole after 15 years, though even the judge said release seems unlikely. In a jail call Mackenzie told her mom she was surprised, having expected something like 85 years, the death penalty, or life without parole.

Answered around 34:59
When is Mackenzie Shirilla's first parole hearing, and what happens if she is denied?

Her first parole hearing is expected in 2037, and Dom's and Davion's families will most likely attend to keep her behind bars. If parole is denied, she must wait between one and ten years before the next hearing; the host thinks her young age would probably make the wait shorter than ten years.

Answered around 38:47
What happened with the Shirilla family's appeals after the conviction?

Their first appeal was rejected. A second appeal was filed one day past the 365-day deadline, and they argued the leap year made it confusing. They then tried the Supreme Court of Ohio, where Chief Justice Sharon Kennedy declined to accept jurisdiction. A U.S. Supreme Court petition remains possible but is lengthy and usually not worth the fees.

Answered around 35:51
Is Judge Russo related to Dom Russo's family, as the Shirillas suggest?

No. The judge and Dom's family share the last name Russo, but it has been proven they are not related. Dom's mother, Christine Russo, did work for the DA's office at one point, but she no longer does, and nothing shows any connection that would have affected the trial.

Answered around 0:40
Why do the Shirillas say a jury trial would have changed the outcome?

They claim they had a poor defense and were almost bullied into a bench trial instead of a jury trial. Steve Shirilla says that with a jury she would never have been convicted and would be free today, adding that Mackenzie asked for a jury but her lawyer talked her out of it.

Answered around 36:17
What did Natalie Shirilla ask the judge for, and how did the judge respond?

Natalie called it a tragic accident Mackenzie does not remember and asked the judge not to run the sentences consecutively, since 15 years consecutive would mean 30 years before parole. When she kept talking about her daughter, the judge interrupted: she was hearing a lot about the daughter and very little about the two dead people.

Answered around 24:45
Who was Davion Flanagan, and what happened to his football plans?

Davion joined the Flanagans at eight and a half and was adopted with his two sisters after time in county care. He was obsessed with football and even served as the team barber. He tore his ACL in the third game of his senior season, losing his hoped-for college football scholarship, which his dad calls the start of a downward spiral.

Answered around 12:50
What is Dom and Davion's Law meant to change in Ohio?

Ohio's Son of Sam law protects victims' families from perpetrators profiting off their crimes, but it has not been updated to cover social media. The families are pushing Dom and Davion's Law after a former inmate said Mackenzie journaled daily for a book and planned to become a social media influencer telling her story.

Answered around 39:53
How did Mackenzie Shirilla react to the guilty verdict in her jail calls?

Soon after the judge found her guilty, she told Natalie she was literally in shock and it was the last thing she expected. She sounded distraught, complained about cameras zooming in on her face as she was handcuffed, and asked why they would keep her alive if they wanted her in jail.

Answered around 8:09
How did Davion's family feel about the sentences running concurrently?

Davion's mom said they were taken aback when they learned the sentences would run concurrently. She pointed out that Mackenzie is essentially serving the same sentence she would have received if only one of the boys had been in the car, and said that is very hard to stomach.

Answered around 35:32
Key Quote

“i think there's some collusion going on i think it's a fix i think it's a favor”

— Steve Shirilla, Mackenzie Shavilla's Trial and Appeal, at 3:45▶ listen at 3:45
Key Quote

“I'm literally in shock that was the last thing I expected to happen”

— Mackenzie, Mackenzie Shavilla's Trial and Appeal, at 8:14▶ listen at 8:14
Key Quote

“why would they keep me alive if they want me to be in jail?”

— Mackenzie, Mackenzie Shavilla's Trial and Appeal, at 8:38▶ listen at 8:38
Key Quote

“He was so much more than cargo.”

— Davion's mom, Mackenzie Shavilla's Trial and Appeal, at 18:15▶ listen at 18:15
Key Quote

“Mackenzie Sherilla had a choice. Dom and Davion did not.”

— Christine Russo, Mackenzie Shavilla's Trial and Appeal, at 21:16▶ listen at 21:16
Key Quote

“I'm hearing an awful lot about your daughter. I'm not hearing very much about the two dead people.”

— The judge, Mackenzie Shavilla's Trial and Appeal, at 30:33▶ listen at 30:33

Cite this

“Mackenzie Shavilla's Trial and Appeal.” https://stitcher.simplecastaudio.com/ca05dec2-017c-4888-bda3-ab746f266395/episodes/f3f78935-15d4-48fa-a219-c82698ae8f77/audio/128/default.mp3/default.mp3_ywr3ahjkcgo_569491a3a25256af5572d0bc3ee61cd3_39904502.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/mackenzie-shavilla-s-trial-and-appeal.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?