Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Maximilian's Plea

28:11 recording · EN · 3 speakers

Listen to the original

Executive Summary AI
  • At the gate under the chestnut trees, Maximilian Morrel tells Valentine that Franz d'Epinay reached Paris that morning and that the marriage contract will be signed the following day.
  • Valentine refuses to fight the match, calling it sacrilege to resist her father's order and her dying grandmother's wish, which drives Morrel to cold, formal bitterness.
  • Only when Morrel calmly describes how he would write to his brother-in-law and the prefect of police and end his own life does Valentine break, declaring she would rather die of shame than of remorse and promising to follow him, with Noirtier told first so his consent justifies her.
  • Her letter arrives two days later: prayers at the church of St. Philippe de Roule changed nothing, the signature is fixed for nine o'clock that evening, and she will meet him at the gate at a quarter to nine.
  • Morrel waits past ten, scales the wall, and finds the house dark rather than lit for a ceremony; hidden by a sycamore, he overhears Villefort and Doctor d'Avenray speak of a death and of a terrible secret still to come.

Brief overview

Facing a forced marriage, Valentine finally agrees to flee with Morrel, but the appointed night brings silence.

  1. Duty beats love until death is the priceValentine calls resistance sacrilege and only yields when Morrel promises to kill himself.
  2. The escape is planned to the minuteTwo ladders hidden in the clover-field, a horse and cabriolet concealed, the meeting set for a quarter to nine.
  3. The dark house is the real newsNo lights at the windows on a contract night, and Villefort speaking of a fresh death, mean the plan has already been overtaken.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
When is Valentine's marriage contract with M. Franz d'Epinay to be signed?

Valentine tells Morrel that her grandmother, on whom she depended as her only support, is not merely favorable to the match but anxious for it. The family awaits only the arrival of M. d'Epinay, and the following day the contract will be signed; Franz reached Paris that morning.

How did Morrel learn that Franz d'Epinay had arrived in Paris?

Morrel was at the house of Monte Cristo an hour earlier, speaking of the family's sorrow, when a carriage rolled into the courtyard. Albert de Morcerf entered first, then another young man, and the Count exclaimed, "Ah, here is the Baron Franz d'Epinay." Morrel smiled and left five minutes later.

Why does Valentine refuse to resist the marriage her family has arranged?

The idea of resisting her father, her grandmother and all the family had never occurred to her. She calls a struggle sacrilege: to resist her father's order and her dying grandmother's wish is impossible. She will need all her strength to struggle with herself and bear her grief in secret.

What does Morrel propose that Valentine do instead of signing the contract?

He asks her to follow him to his sister, who is worthy also to be hers. They would embark for Algiers, for England, for America, or retire to the country and return to Paris only when their friends have reconciled her family. Valentine calls it the counsel of a madman.

What does Morrel say he will do if Valentine marries Franz?

He will wait until the very moment she is married, since Franz may die first or a thunderbolt may fall on the altar. When his misery is certain and hopeless, he will write confidential letters to his brother-in-law and to the prefect of police, then end his existence by a wood, abyss or river.

What agreement do Valentine and Morrel finally reach at the gate?

If by artifice, entreaty or accident Valentine can delay the marriage, Morrel will wait; she promises by her mother that if dragged before a magistrate or priest she will refuse. Should her father and Madame de Saint-Meran insist on tomorrow's signature, she will come to him and they will fly.

What does Morrel say about Valentine's grandfather, M. Noirtier?

She shall not leave him. Since M. Noirtier has shown a kind feeling toward Morrel, she should tell him everything before she goes; his consent would be her justification in God's sight. As soon as they are married he will come and live with them, so he has two children instead of one.

What does Valentine write in her letter to Morrel?

Tears, entreaties and prayers have availed her nothing; she prayed two hours at the church of St. Philippe du Roule. The signature of the contract is fixed for that evening at nine o'clock, so she will meet him at the gate at a quarter to nine. Her grandmother's delirium is now almost madness.

What does Morrel do when Valentine fails to appear at the gate?

Half an hour past the time she fixed, he sees no white dress and hears no footsteps, and the house stays dark. The clock strikes ten, then the half-hour. Fearing she had fainted or been stopped in her flight, he fixes his ladder, passes a leg over the wall and leaps into Villefort's grounds.

What does Morrel overhear between Villefort and Doctor d'Avrigny in the garden?

Hidden against a sycamore, he hears Villefort say heaven declares itself against his house, lamenting a dreadful death that nothing can alleviate. The doctor replies that he has not led him there to console him: behind this misfortune lies another perhaps still greater, a terrible secret. They sit down.

Key Quote

“I come to bring and to hear bad tidings.”

— Morell, Maximilian's Plea, at 1:16▶ listen at 1:16
Key Quote

“What do you mean by a struggle? Oh, it would be sacrilege.”

— Valentine, Maximilian's Plea, at 4:31▶ listen at 4:31
Key Quote

“I will take you to my sister, who is worthy also to be yours.”

— Morel, Maximilian's Plea, at 6:35▶ listen at 6:35
Key Quote

“But in losing you, I lose my life.”

— Maximilian, Maximilian's Plea, at 11:30▶ listen at 11:30
Key Quote

“No, on my honor.”

— Maximilian, Maximilian's Plea, at 12:55▶ listen at 12:55
Key Quote

“I have but one promise, and but one heart to give.”

— Valentine, Maximilian's Plea, at 18:45▶ listen at 18:45

Cite this

“Maximilian's Plea.” https://www.archive.org/download/count_monte_cristo_0711_librivox/count_of_monte_cristo_073a_dumas_64kb.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/maximilian-s-plea.html.

Transcript

0:00 THE PROMISE chapter seventy three part i the promise it was indeed maximilian morrel who had passed a wretched existence since the previous day
0:32 with the instinct peculiar to lovers he had anticipated after the return of madame de saint-meran and the death of the marquis that something would occur at monsieur de villefort's in connection with his attachment for Valentine.
0:46 His presentiments were realized, as we shall see, and his uneasy forebodings had goaded
0:51 him pale and trembling to the gate under the chestnut trees.
0:56 Valentine was ignorant of the cause of this sorrow and anxiety, and as it was not his
1:01 accustomed hour for visiting her, she had gone to the spot simply by accident, or perhaps through sympathy.
1:08 Morell called her, and she ran to the gate.
1:10 "'You are here at this hour?' said she.
1:13 "'Yes, my poor girl,' replied Morell.
1:16 "'I come to bring and to hear bad tidings.'
1:19 "'This is, indeed, a house of mourning,' said Valentine.
1:23 Speak, Maximilian, although the cup of sorrow seems already full.
1:27 Dear Valentine, said Morel, endeavoring to conceal his own emotion, listen, I entreat you. What I am about to say. This morning the subject was introduced, and my
1:46 dear grandmother, on whom I depended as my only support, not only declared herself favorable to
1:51 it, but is so anxious for it that they only await the arrival of M. d'Ipinay. And the following day
1:58 the contract will be signed. A deep sigh escaped the young man, who gazed long and mournfully at her he loved alas replied he it is dreadful thus to hear my condemnation from your own lips
2:12 the sentence is passed and in a few hours will be executed it must be so and i will not endeavor to prevent it but since you say nothing remains but for m d'epinay to arrive that the contract may be signed, and the following day you will be his.
2:28 Tomorrow you will be engaged to M. d'Epinay, for he came this morning to Paris."
2:34 Valentine uttered a cry.
2:35 "'I was at the house of Monte-Cristo an hour since,' said Morrel.
2:39 We were speaking.
2:40 He of the sorrow your family had experienced, and I of your grief when a carriage rolled
2:45 into the courtyard never till then had i placed any confidence in presentiments but now i can't help believing them valentine at the sound of that carriage i shuddered footsteps of the commander did Don Juan. The door at last opened. Albert de Morsurf entered,
3:07 and I began to hope my fears were vain, when after him another young man advanced, and the count
3:12 exclaimed, Ah, here is the Baron Franz de Epinay. I summoned all my strength and courage to my
3:18 support. Perhaps I turned pale and trembled, but certainly I smiled, and five minutes after I left, without having
3:26 heard one word that had passed. Poor Maximilian, murmured Valentine. Valentine, the time has
3:32 arrived that you must answer me. And remember, my life depends on your answer. What do you intend
3:38 doing? Valentine held down her head. She was overwhelmed. Listen, said Moral, it is not the first time you have
3:46 contemplated our present position,
3:48 which is a serious and urgent one.
3:50 I do not think it is a moment to
3:52 give way to useless sorrow.
3:55 Leave that for those who like
3:56 to suffer at their leisure, and indulge
3:58 their grief in secret. There are
4:00 such in the world, and God will doubtless
4:02 reward them in heaven for their resignation
4:04 on earth.
4:11 But those who mean to contend must not lose one precious moment, but must return immediately the blow which fortune strikes. Do you intend to struggle against our ill fortune? Tell me,

Showing the first 40 of 282 lines.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?