Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Meat on Hooves

5:42:19 recording · EN · 2 speakers

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Host Amit Verma introduces Prabal Dasgupta, a former army officer turned historian, whose book General Brasstacks is a biography of General K. Sundarji, a man present at five assassinations and an arms deal across the 1980s.1:33
  • Dasgupta opens with the story of Bandya, a lamb born to a pregnant sheep sent as 'meat on hooves' to the Mahar battalion, who drew a soldier's pay of one anna a month, rose to corporal and then sergeant, was rescued from a Baluchi cook's kitchen at Quetta at Partition, and was buried with a bugle call on the banks of the Dal Lake after dying in 1950.5:17
  • Dasgupta calls Sundarji the most anti-status-quo of all army chiefs, while Verma presses the counter-argument that Sundarji stayed rigidly wedded to his own doctrine of the big conventional battle even as warfare moved to counter-insurgency.18:32
  • On Sri Lanka, Dasgupta quotes General Ashok Mehta and Brigadier Pal Sokar to argue the IPKF went in with no objective, no exit plan and no cohesion with the government or intelligence agencies, because Sundarji thought it could be done in a couple of weeks.33:08
  • On Blue Star, Dasgupta says Sundarji overruled General Arun Vaidya's soft option of surrounding the Golden Temple, promised Indira Gandhi swift action lasting a few hours with no damage to the temple buildings, and came home at two in the night to confess self-doubt to his wife.1:03:31

Brief overview

General K. Sundarji's brilliance shaped India's 1980s, and his hubris shaped that decade's disasters.

  1. Anti-status quo, yet bound by his own dogmaSundarji militated against every inherited protocol but never questioned his own belief in the big conventional battle.
  2. Outcomes, not judgement, decide who is called brilliantManekshaw's monsoon delay in 1971 and Sagat Singh's stand at Nathu La were vindicated; the same defiance at Blue Star was called hubris.
  3. Nobody left in the room to say noWith the political leadership on his side and contemporaries he rated below himself, Sundarji had no one able to temper his certainty.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
Who was General K. Sundarji and why does the 1980s revolve around him?

Sundarji was an iconoclastic thinker who later became head of the Indian Army. He played a key role in Operation Blue Star, Operation Brass Stacks, the selection of Bofors as the gun the army would buy, and the misadventures of the IPKF in Sri Lanka.

Answered around 1:57
Why is Sundarji called the most anti-status-quo of all army chiefs?

Because he militated against the way things were done unless they were rational and he was convinced about them. Like Sam Manekshaw and Sagat Singh, the leaders who stood out succeeded by thinking out of the box, never wedded to protocols or laid-down theories.

Answered around 18:26
Why did the army finally go into the Golden Temple in June 1984?

General Bulbul Bharat, who led the operation, said the intelligence input was that the militants planned to announce the creation of Khalistan as a new nation by 9 June, with Bhindranwale's supporters swarming to the Golden Temple from all over Punjab to make military action very difficult.

Answered around 56:03
Why did General S.K. Sinha refuse to use the army against Bhindranwale?

Asked to evict Bhindranwale from a gurdwara, Sinha was very clear this was the police's work and not the army's, even though Bhindranwale had arms and people with him. Sinha had also laid down a standard operating procedure, spot on, for how military formations should address religious shrines.

Answered around 51:48
What went wrong with India's intervention in Sri Lanka?

General Ashok Mehta and Brigadier Pal Sokar both said India went in with no objective or aim and no exit plan, and there was no cohesiveness with the government or the intelligence agencies. Sundarji thought it achievable in a couple of weeks; peacekeepers became peace enforcers overnight.

Answered around 33:08
How did Sundarji get the 'ji' in his name?

As a small child he heard his parents discussing Gandhi and asked why they said Gandhiji. His father explained that Gandhi was the name and 'ji' was an honorific. The boy said he wanted a 'ji' after his name too, so his parents registered him as Krishnaswami Sundarji.

Answered around 1:28:06
What did Sundarji do in Balochistan at the moment of Partition?

Posted at Sandeman's Fort in Balochistan, on 14 August he attended the Pakistani Independence Day, a rare occasion for an Indian Army officer. He then went to a tailor, had three pieces of cloth stitched together, saffron, white and green, and raised the tricolour there on 15 August.

Answered around 1:33:48
What did Sundarji witness on the night Mahatma Gandhi was assassinated?

Playing basketball in Delhi as a nineteen-year-old, he was called to Birla House and told Gandhi had been assassinated. Nehru asked him to keep Birla House safe and wait. He then saw Nehru, tears streaming down his face, clamber up the wrought-iron gate to address the crowd outside.

Answered around 1:38:40
What does the army term 'meat on hooves' actually mean?

Rations arrive at army units along with live animals: goat, sheep, chicken. The live animal that arrives and can be slaughtered at a time convenient for the troops is called meat on hooves. The term is old, going back to the world war, when regular ration supply was not always possible.

Answered around 4:18
Who was Bandya, the sheep who rose to sergeant in the Mahar battalion?

A pregnant sheep arrived as meat on hooves at the Mahar battalion and troops would not slaughter her. Her offspring was named Bandya, a common Maharashtrian name meaning naughty kid, because he was always running around the unit. Bandya was smuggled aboard ship and became part of the rifle company.

Answered around 6:07
Key Quote

“The 1980s had it all.”

— Amit Verma, Meat on Hooves, at 1:06▶ listen at 1:06
Key Quote

“that the smartest person has only a very, very tiny handle on it.”

— Amit Verma, Meat on Hooves, at 35:56▶ listen at 35:56
Key Quote

“If I were to look at a trade-off, I think brilliance is a curse”

— Prabal Dasgupta, Meat on Hooves, at 38:59▶ listen at 38:59
Key Quote

“in sri lanka we went in without an objective without an exit plan”

— Prabal Dasgupta, Meat on Hooves, at 33:08▶ listen at 33:08

Cite this

“Meat on Hooves.” https://content.libsyn.com/p/d/3/5/d3524ab80fb09d6a/E449SeenUnseen.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/meat-on-hooves.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?