Recording intelligenceAI-generated brief · check the source for context

Monarchy's Last Chance

23:32 recording · EN · 1 speaker

Listen to the original

Listen to the episode
Executive Summary AI
  • Historian and journalist Marco Patricelli introduces a book built around the institutional referendum of 2 and 3 June 1946, in which he inserts one invented element — a plausible path to a monarchist victory — while keeping every character and circumstance documented.0:54
  • He grounds the question in Italy's double laceration: twenty years of dictatorship and a lost war on one side, and the 1943–1945 civil war and the Savoy monarchy's collapse after the escape of Pescara on the other.2:49
  • The imagined intervention has the United States, fearing Soviet influence in the Mediterranean, work through Ambassador Kirk in Rome and the Italian prisoners still held abroad, using them to sway the women who would vote at home — with Umberto di Savoia's placet needed for the operation Patricelli calls White Cross.5:46
  • He argues the female vote was the real multiplier: women had first voted in the administrative elections of March and April 1946, and in a society shaped by centuries of patriarchy their vote was orientable, not least by the wish to bring the prisoners home.12:23
  • In fact the Cassation Court proclaimed on 18 June 12,717,000 votes for the Republic against 10,719,000 for the Monarchy — about 2 million — while Patricelli's book lets the monarchy win by a few thousand, too thin a margin to save it, and he closes by noting that no American document from Sowers or Kirk on the referendum exists at all.13:19

Brief overview

Patricelli's counterfactual asks whether a secret US operation could have won Italy's 1946 referendum for the monarchy.

  1. One invented element, everything else documentedPatricelli grafts a single fictional operation onto real characters and verified circumstances, like a botanist's graft.
  2. The women's vote was the intended multiplierItalian women had voted for the first time only months earlier, and their orientation was the great unknown of June 1946.
  3. No American paper trail exists on the referendumNeither Admiral Sowers nor Ambassador Kirk left a single written statement or position on the Italian institutional vote.

Questions this recording answers

10 questions, each answered where it is said
What were the official results of the 1946 institutional referendum?

The figures proclaimed on 18 June by the Supreme Court of Cassation were 12,717,000 votes for the Republic against 10,719,000 for the Monarchy, a gap of about two million votes. They are the definitive numbers of the vote held on 2 and 3 June 1946.

Answered around 13:36
How does Patricelli's book change the outcome of the referendum?

In the book the monarchy prevails by only a few thousand votes. That margin respects the orientation of history while keeping the door open: the monarchy, not being a party, would have needed a heavy, significant victory, so a handful of votes saves neither Umberto nor the dynasty.

Answered around 13:50
How could the Americans secretly have influenced the Italian vote?

By acting on the mass of Italian prisoners still held on their territory, suggesting what Italy would become if the Republic won and the communist component acted as Stalin's fifth column. Each soldier could involve his mother, girlfriend, wife, daughter, whose liberation was tied to the referendum's orientation.

Answered around 5:52
Who would have been the Americans' Trojan horse in Rome?

Ambassador Kirk, the United States ambassador to Rome, an Italian thread beyond any doubt. His service personnel were exclusively Italian during his tour of the world, one waiter, Mario, being very loyal; he spoke to his servants only in Italian and was very well introduced in Roman circles.

Answered around 7:22
What is the secret operation called White Cross in the book?

It is the imagined American operation to supply the monarchy with a package of votes, needing Umberto's placet as lieutenant of the kingdom. It had to remain under track: beyond the political problem there was a moral one, since the United States could not appear equated to the Soviet Union.

Answered around 8:33
Why was the women's vote treated as a multiplier in 1946?

Because, beyond any political correctness, it was orientable: by a centuries-old history of patriarchy in families, in the address and in decisions, and also by interest, namely bringing the prisoners back as soon as possible and giving them a role in work, employment and profession.

Answered around 12:55
Which Italians were unable to vote in the referendum?

About a million Italians from the territories of Venezia Giulia did not express themselves. Repatriated prisoners of war did not vote, nor the deposed, the refugees and the homeless in other cities, nor those who never received the electoral certificate, while Victor Emmanuel III and Queen Elena held double certificates.

Answered around 20:27
Did Umberto II abdicate when he left Italy on 13 June?

No. Umberto di Savoia does not abdicate, because he does not recognise the republic, and he does not go into exile either: he moves away, which is a completely different thing, thinking that sooner or later he will be able to return. These factors are often hidden or merely rumoured.

Answered around 14:42
Is there American documentation supporting the White Cross hypothesis?

None. Beyond the intrigue with Admiral Sowers, who would later lay the foundations of the CIA, and Ambassador Kirk, the American documents contain not a single statement, position or address on the Italian institutional referendum; neither man left any written document or interpretation of those facts.

Answered around 21:45
How did the Cassation Court interpret the 'majority of voters' formula?

The draft of the legislative decree spoke of the majority of voters, a formula that changes the numbers and the proportions. The Court gave it the exact interpretation of the majority of valid votes: a hard decision, with 12 magistrates in favour and 7 against, including President Giuseppe Pagano.

Answered around 21:15
Key Quote

“imagined a real element that could have brought the monarchy to success in the Republic.”

— Marco Patricelli, Monarchy's Last Chance, at 1:16▶ listen at 1:16
Key Quote

“in my book there is no fantasy character and circumstances that are documented and verified.”

— Marco Patricelli, Monarchy's Last Chance, at 4:59▶ listen at 4:59
Key Quote

“But according to Albertino's statute, the signature under the declaration of war is that of Vittorio Emanuele III.”

— Marco Patricelli, Monarchy's Last Chance, at 10:54▶ listen at 10:54
Key Quote

“So the vote of women, beyond any possible political correctness, is orientable.”

— Marco Patricelli, Monarchy's Last Chance, at 12:55▶ listen at 12:55
Key Quote

“In my book I make the monarchy prevail for a few thousands of votes,”

— Marco Patricelli, Monarchy's Last Chance, at 13:50▶ listen at 13:50
Key Quote

“Simply, Admiral Sowers and Ambassador Kirk have not left any written document”

— Marco Patricelli, Monarchy's Last Chance, at 22:14▶ listen at 22:14

Cite this

“Monarchy's Last Chance.” https://dcs-cached.megaphone.fm/MONDADORI6842174018.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/monarchy-s-last-chance.html.

Report this page
What is wrong with this page?