A South Carolina legal dynasty sits at the centre of four deaths that stayed unanswered.
Dr Erin Presnell of MUSC, a few hours after the body arrived, ruled that Stephen died of head trauma from impact in a pedestrian-vehicle road collision, with the manner of death undetermined. Asked directly why she thought it was a road accident, she answered: because he was on the road.
Answered around 25:15Nothing at the scene supported it: no projectiles, no gunpowder residue, no braking marks on the road, no fragments or debris pointing to a vehicle. The road was two lanes and completely flat. The two coroners, Ernie Washington and Angela Topper, first assumed a gunshot, given the catastrophic skull wound.
Answered around 19:38The name Murdoch, Buster in particular, is mentioned more than forty times across the investigation, and over half the people interviewed said they had heard Buster Murdoch might be involved in Stephen's death. Buster was never questioned. No suspect was ever identified and everything stopped in 2016.
Answered around 45:18After the fall on the brick steps at Moselle, Gloria spent more than three weeks in hospital with serious complications, including a stroke and a heart attack. On 26 February 2018 she went into cardiac arrest and died. It was treated as a tragic accident: no autopsy, death certificate natural causes.
Answered around 50:47At or shortly after Gloria's funeral on 28 February 2018, Alec told her sons Brian and Tony to sue him, so that his insurance would pay out rather than him handing them money directly. He recommended a lawyer he trusted, his college friend Corey Fleming, who took the family on in March 2018.
Answered around 52:45Miley saw a bridge and screamed, but too late: the boat hit the protection pillars of the Berkeley Bridge on Archer's Creek at 2.17, then carried on and struck the bank. Girls were hurt on board; Paul, Anthony and Mallory went into the water and only two came back up.
Answered around 1:08:12Paul claimed Connor was driving, but everything taken together, including the evidence from everyone's injuries, showed Connor was a passenger, and he was not charged. At the scene Anthony had already told deputy Stephen Domino that Paul was driving, the first time the question of the driver came up.
Answered around 1:19:51Video and hospital staff describe him moving repeatedly through the emergency room, checking the board to see which room each boy was in. He tried to enter Morgan's room saying he had to tell her what to say, and told Connor there was no need to say who was driving.
Answered around 1:14:49Alec called 911 at 22.06 saying he had just got home and found them. Detective Laura Rutland found Paul face down on the threshold of a shed by the kennels, Maggie about nine metres away, both shot. No weapon was near either body; two different weapons, never found.
Answered around 1:30:41Between 22 and 23 June 2021, two weeks after the murders of Maggie and Paul, SLED released a statement saying that information obtained during the double-murder investigation justified reopening the inquiry into Stephen's death. They said no more than that then, and have said no more since.
Answered around 1:34:09“There are no bubbles, there's no gunpowder residue, there are no signs of braking on the road.”
“Suspects have never been identified and in 2016 everything stopped, so the year after the death.”
“there's no need to tell anyone who was driving.”
“She's gone, don't worry.”
“Murdoch Dynasty Origins.” https://dcs-spotify.megaphone.fm/CSRL4065837733.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/murdoch-dynasty-origins.html.