NASA's first agency risk management officer explains how objectives set the risk you accept.
Mary Scow says it is the first time the role has existed at NASA; she started in November 2023. Early work asked whether it should look like a chief risk officer at a federal agency or at a technical place. Today the job is helping the agency, and also programs, projects and offices, make risk-informed decisions at their own levels.
Answered around 1:12Straight from the handbook: risk is the potential for shortfalls with respect to achieving explicitly established and stated objectives. Put simply, it is the likelihood that something goes wrong when you try to meet one of your objectives, whether that objective is technical, cost, schedule, or a workforce goal such as keeping people at a certain level on the FEVS.
Answered around 13:55Risk management is an overarching process that encompasses identification, analysis, mitigation, planning, and tracking of root causes and their consequences. Basically, it is the process used to identify, respond to and track risks. It is also continuous: once a risk is identified you keep tracking it, deciding whether it is still worth mitigating, acceptable, or trending worse.
Answered around 14:12Absolutely the same. NASA approaches risk management the same exact way for the entire organization, including branch management, legal and contracting, using one framework across the board. It is outlined in NPR 8000.4, which anyone can Google because it is online and open to the public, which Mary says makes life really easy.
Answered around 14:32Security is the big one: cyber and physical, like badging. Program managers build a thing that communicates but do not own the satellites, the ground infrastructure or the physical IT assets, so they rarely consider it. They also miss that an unlocked door in their flying asset becomes a risk to larger ground assets and the broader network. Reputational and supply chain risks are also underweighted.
Answered around 7:25Risk leadership is leading by an accountable leader: risk acceptance decision making within the limits of a defined risk posture, including the authority to allocate portions of that posture to subordinate or supporting organizations. Mary illustrates it with teaching someone to drive, where you keep them on a driveway first and only later open things up.
Answered around 21:23The definition Mary gives is the limits of acceptable risk to the established or stated objectives whose achievement is of direct concern to the stakeholders. Teaching a nephew to drive on a driveway with no obstacles sets a low posture; moving him to a parking lot with obstacles allocates him more risk. The question is how much risk you are willing to take to meet an objective.
Answered around 27:15First recognize the data is lacking, which is not always easy until you are in it or someone asks you a question. Seek other perspectives and stay open to hard questions about technical work, cost, schedule or return on investment. Ask a follow-on question to understand what is behind theirs, take an honest look at yourself, and it is okay to say you do not know and go find out.
Answered around 2:34Effort should be commensurate with the level of risk you are willing to take to meet the objective. If you are willing to wing it and it is okay to fail completely, you may not need the information. If the thing must work ninety-plus percent of the time, turn on, take accurate measurements and shut off, you put in the effort to get it.
Answered around 5:22In fifth grade, astronaut Pam Melroy came to her elementary school in a blue suit. Sitting on the gymnasium floor looking up at her, Mary decided she would be an astronaut, and if not, she would run NASA. Growing up in upstate New York with no NASA center nearby, she had not known it was even an option.
Answered around 28:17“is to help the agency make risk informed decisions at the highest of levels.”
“figure out if you're missing information, which by the way, we all are most of the time.”
“the potential for shortfalls with respect to achieving explicitly established and stated objectives.”
“That conversation is probably the most important part, not the five by five.”
“What I pick up on is that it also has to be a people-focused objective when you do risk management.”
“We're going to keep that risk low. That's called a risk posture.”
“NASA Risk Management.” https://traffic.megaphone.fm/NATIONALAERONAUTICSANDSPACEADMINISTRATION7261471222.mp3. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/nasa-risk-management.html.