Suicidal brains show real prefrontal differences, but mental illness overlap makes them nearly impossible to isolate.
As of 2024, over 700,000 people die by suicide annually. In America, suicide is the second leading cause of death among adolescents aged 10 to 19. Over 90% of people who have died by suicide had some sort of mental disorder, a figure that became a major obstacle in this research.
There are very few neurobiological differences between the suicidal population and non-suicidal people who happen to have a mental disorder. Seven sources agree that attempters have less prefrontal gray matter, but clinical depression, schizophrenia or bipolar personality produce the same deficit, so suicide-specific deviations are incredibly difficult to isolate.
The suicidal population generally has reduced gray matter volume in the prefrontal regions, a genuine structural abnormality broadly covering the ventral prefrontal cortex, dorsolateral and orbitofrontal areas. The frontal lobe handles reasoning and decision making. People with bipolar personality, depression or childhood abuse can show the same abnormality without being suicidal.
Higher lethality attempters have much more gray matter volume because they have a heightened ability to plan and intend suicide, they use more lethal methods, and they have a much better chance of completing it. They also have lower delayed discounting, suppressing the desire for immediate suicide in favour of a carefully planned one.
Delayed discounting measures how much you favour smaller rewards sooner over larger rewards later. Offered $50 right now or $200 in one year, you might take the $50 because the year's wait makes $200 feel less valuable. Someone with lower delayed discounting waits patiently, having better self-control.
The impulsive and the non-impulsive, for lower and higher lethality respectively. The impulsive subgroup has lower gray matter volumes in prefrontal regions, is significantly younger, has few widowed or divorced members, less severe suicidal ideation and less lethal injuries. Higher lethality attempters retain more gray matter than even non-suicidal people.
Its main role is controlling social tasks, including moral judgment, social decision making and social emotions. It also regulates negative emotions like fear and anxiety through its connections with the amygdala, which initiates fear responses, and the ventral striatum, which processes reward-based behaviour. The more damaged it is, the worse someone's social relationships become.
Relaying Cass's book The Evolution of Life Worth Living: our minds house pain and intelligence. Pain motivates people to escape or end it, and nothing hurts less than being dead, so chronic mental pain can drive suicide. Human intelligence is the means; virtually nobody under five or severely intellectually disabled kills themselves.
We adapted to self-killing with biological anti-suicide defenses that work for about 98.5% of us: depression, anxiety, substance abuse and self-harm. They either lessen pain or lessen intelligence. Depression and substances numb; self-harm redirects pain, like biting your lip after stubbing your toe; the impulsive subgroup loses planning ability.
Capability for suicide is marked by an increase in physical bodily pain tolerance, not social pain, acquired over time through repeated acts of self-harm or general exposure to painful events. In attempters the posterior insula functioned normally, but the paracingulate gyrus, which dictates how much we care about pain, was much less active.
“As of 2024, over 700,000 people have died by suicide annually.”
“So if someone is experiencing chronic mental pain, they can be driven to suicide.”
“Pain is the motivation, human intelligence, human intelligence specifically, is the means.”
“It's a last resort, but it's still a method.”
“We've adapted to the problem of self-killing via various biological anti-suicide defenses.”
“These biological anti-suicide defenses happen to be common mental disorders like depression, anxiety, substance abuse, self-harm, and so on and so forth.”
“Neurobiological Aspects of Suicide.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N9_fxl1CmXs. Transcript summary by WhipScribe, https://whipscribe.com/transcript-pages/neurobiological-aspects-of-suicide.html.